The Eerie Vanishing Of The Flannan Isles Lighthouse Keepers
μμ€ μ½λ
- κ²μμΌ 2020. 10. 15.
- What happened to the three lighthouse keepers of Flannan Isles?
Watch ALL-NEW episodes of Unsolved: True Crime every Friday at 3pm here!: β’ BuzzFeed Unsolved - Tr...
Want more spooky related videos? Watch Lindsay and three brave fashionistas wear haunted fashion to uncover whether the items are possessed π» New episodes every weekend in October!
β’ Haunted Beauty
Credits: www.buzzfeed.com/bfmp/videos/...
MUSIC
SFX Provided By AudioBlocks
(www.audioblocks.com)
Licensed via Audio Network
Welcome to the BuzzFeed Unsolved Network! This channel is your one-stop destination for all things mystery, conspiracy, supernatural, true crime, and everything in between. Subscribe here: bit.ly/2zuaR06.
STILLS
Vintage poster for magic performance - Magician tricks show retro flyer designlukeruk/Getty Images
Bearded fisherman on his ship.Tina Terras & Michael Walter/Getty ImagesPortrait of confident surfer standing at beachCavan Images/Getty ImagesFaces of Business - Confident Colour Image
JohnnyGreig/Getty Imagesconcrete polished texture backgroundchingraph/Getty ImagesMid twenties British male stood on a beachJamie Garbutt/Getty ImagesSouth Africa, portrait of white haired man wearing turtleneck standing on beach dunes before sunriseWestend61/Getty Images
Portrait of mature man on the beachOliver Rossi/Getty ImagesMan At Helm of Yacht During a Sydney Stormdavidf/Getty ImagesDiverse People SmilingJohnnyGreig/Getty ImagesWe're all special in our own wayYuri_Arcurs/Getty ImagesSustainability portraitRichard Drury/Getty Images
London Antique Viewnicoolay/Getty ImagesChevy Impala Grillxydous/Getty Images
Lighthouse on the Isle of Ornsay seen from Isle of Skye in Scotland. Exposed seaweed and mudflat at low tidehopsalka/Getty ImagesBusiness Forecastingguvendemir/Getty ImagesRed door in old stone lighthouse - squareJohn Fader/Getty ImagesMens Waterproof Winter JacketKypros/Getty ImagesEilean Musdile Lighthouse, in the West Coast of Scotland, seen from the sea with clouds in the skyEduardoRM/Getty ImagesBarbaria Lighthouse in formentera Islan in spain with a cloudy sky before an stormVictor Fernandez/Getty ImagesAntique photo: "Tantallon Castle" ship
ilbusca/Getty ImagesSailship in the open sea on a sunny summer dayalekseystemmer/Getty Images
Lighthouse on sand dunes in Cape Cod beachlucky-photographer/Getty ImagesRustic Wooden Door on Adobe Building Wallsanfel/Getty ImagesScotland blue loch reflecting green mountains
Easyturn/Getty ImagesUnited Kingdom Country 3D Render Topographic MapFrankRamspott/Getty ImagesDramatic stormy dark cloudy sky over seaeugenesergeev/Getty ImagesFingerprint on white backgroundPeter Dazeley/Getty ImagesVintage light bulbschoness/Getty ImagesRustic Cabin InteriorTimAbramowitz/Getty ImagesSet of various paint splattersitchySan/Getty ImagesLighthouse in MenorcaSensorSpot
VIDEO
flight over a water surface to green screenvitanovski/Getty Imagesman on the boat at sunset
Ugreen/Getty Imagescrashing waves on pier docks, sea spray, hurricane gale force wind storm, bird coasting, Icelandhumanizr_AV/Getty ImagesKnocking on Wooden Doortavi_repede/Getty Images
Rescue flight over the stormy ocean HD loopbaska8777/Getty ImagesCoastal lighthouse. Lindesnes Lighthouse is a coastal lighthouse at the southernmost tip of Norway.cookelma/Getty Images
Waves breaking on the pier,stones.Vladislav Pavlenko/Getty ImagesGreen screen of moving white clouds with 4K resolution.Bubball/Getty Images
SLOW MOTION: Carefree man dives off a rocky cliff and into the deep blue sea.
helivideo/Getty ImagesWalking in transparent water of mountain river. Undewater view
HotFlash/Getty ImagesSlow motion of a cold dark sea wave beating against an ancient concrete breakwater late in the eveningIVAN ZHURAULIOU/Getty ImagesHeavy seas spray mist as they crash into rocks on the shore.Discovery Access/Getty ImagesMountain trail in the mountains Old Man of Storr in ScotlandShaiith/Getty ImagesDepressed Sad Young Man Sitting on Rock By The Beach While Staring at OceanYuriFineart/Getty ImagesThe man running on a beautiful mountain and doing exercise. slow motionArtem Peretiatko/Getty ImagesLarge Crashing Waves Hit Taiwan Coastline During Tropical Storm BailuJames Reynolds - Footage/Getty ImagesFurious aggressive man beats with his fists the lying person outdoor at forestmagicmore/Getty ImagesClose Up of Two Male Hands Gently Touching and Holding Each Other. Cute Queer Relationship Concept. Gay Couple are Casually Dressed. Room is Bright and Sunny.gorodenkoff/Getty ImagesSignal Flare Held Up In SnowstormRockfordMedia/Getty ImagesDepressive man in dark room standing by the window
stevanovicigor/Getty ImagesA hand in the water calling for help.otofx/Getty Images
High wave breaking on the rocks of the coastline. Extremely Big Wave crushing coast , Large Ocean Beautiful Wave. Super Slow Motion.volkovslava/Getty ImagesMan jumping
![[μ€νμ
μ 곡κ°] λ€μ λΆλΆ μ μΈν λ°±ν! 본격 κ»λ±μ§ μ νΌ μν μμ..?β€ #λλ¬Όμμ¬μ EP.13](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/GYBFP5ZTICQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Y 681ν μμ½] λΈμ μλ¬ΌμΈκ°μ΄ λλλ° κ°ν΄μ ꡬνμ 5λ
? | μμμ΄](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EkOzlQWIiyI/mqdefault.jpg)
![[μ 곡κ°]λ€μ λ§λΆμ μ μ μ§ vs νμΏ λ€ λ―ΈλΌμ΄!μ°μΉμλ€μ 리맀μΉμ !ο½β‘νμΌκ°μμ β‘](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/PPHCPreDI40/mqdefault.jpg)
Make sure to leave your questions for our Post Mortem episode down below!
AAAAAAAAAH
Hello!
How are you two handling quarantine?
How has your quarantine and what is your favorite episode
Hi how are your guy day going
Everyone: Death! Abduction! Murder! Madness!
Shane: polyamorous gay lovestory !
Instead of Tiger King Sheep King lol
He really did say poly rights.
we love a supportive king
shane continues to say gay rights
Shane be supporting gays all around the world.
i donβt understand why ryan was so quick to dismiss the big wave cause it wasnβt in the logs... maybe they didnβt write it in the logs cause they were busy being hit by a giant wave
WAITTTJSHJDDHK AHAHHA YOURE RIGHT LMAOAOA
I mean, he didnβt really dismiss that theory because when Shane said it couldnβt have been waves because they reported everything was fine afterwards, Ryan explicitly stated that that isnβt necessarily true because of the reason you said.
Would the logs not have been wet and caused the writing to be hard to read? Cause if it was a wave I donβt think the logs or much in the lighthouse would have been found cause if it can take bodies, it can take a book.
I looked it up and they really shouldβve emphasized more about how these logs were probably fake. They made it seem like they were likely legitimate, but it seems like this is just a rumour that spread.
krplus.net/bidio/qsh-d3lqgXrKp4Y
I actually agree with ryan on this one, having a place with missing people look completely normal is way more creepy than full of blood and stuff. Bc upon seeing gory mess you'd just be like, "ok, there was a murder, yikes", but people just VANISHING without a trace spooks me
Itβs insane. Itβs eerie, and horrifying.
Ok, there was a murder, but people just Vanishing without a trace spooks me
Yeah, people vanishing like they fell into some random black hole on their way somewhere creeps me out. Same with bodies that have been around, sometimes hidden in plain sight, and not discovered for years. Even worse when we don't even know how they died let alone who they are. Also, murders/disappearances that happen in the middle of nowhere and are never solved.
A couple of examples: even though most have been identified and it's been partially solved (though it took over thirty years), The Bear Brook Murders still greatly disturb me. Same with the murders in and around Mineral, Washington.
@@tayloranderson7547 why you just repeating what he already said? Cant come up with any thoughts of your own?
@@CourierSiix and why are you mad? Go do something with your life
Fun fact: lighthouse keepers were known to go insane due to the high exposure to mercury which may have had something to do with what happened at this lighthouse.
The isolation can be enough to drive men mad. Aye.
Where do they get the mercury from?
@@kyledelrosario8963 Mercury vapours in old lightbulbs.
@@kyledelrosario8963 frensel lights (the giant rotating lightbulb) would sit on a mercury bath in order to rotate
shane:
little women:
shane: *muffled crying*
*sNoRt*
I havent watched this video yet so this out of context is even more funny to me
i was like yeah i cried while watching Little Women too and then shane was like no they were just little and i was like okay shane....
love the profile pic haha
Historykrplus.net/bidio/qLuAnYJ4nm3On6g
βalien juiceβ
shaneβs soul literally left his body
...What soul?
SUPER UNDERATED (LEGEND)
krplus.net/bidio/ZdCfqZprdqi6eWE
Don't send any hate β€π
@@underatedmusic4574 no
The disappointment was palpable.
Shane, babe, you gotta just accept by now that its ALWAYS aliens. It's just a fact of life. You can't escape it π€£
As someone who lives on an island and is very familiar with the ocean, Iβm betting one got swept into the sea and the other two tried to save him only to end up the same. People constantly underestimate the sea and think theyβre safe when in reality the ocean is unpredictable and dangerous.
Half of me wants to move to an idland..the other half says your a sitting duck lol. Which island do you live on and is it nice ?
@@stephentucker614 one that is a continent
Same. Very sad.
You sound like a bitter yet timid ocean spirit ushering a word of warning to your next potential victims lol
We where doing this is in class and I said the exact same LOL
I like Shane's theory that the three men ran off together and lived happily ever after.
Me too
I live for the poly lighthouse keepers.
@Jason Martinez Huh?
that's gay
Seriously, they deserve to be happy
And when the world needed them most, they returned.
They didn't really leave
@@PhantomStella I think they did at some point to do there own channel the watcher
OMG why didn't I know this! Thank you π¬π§π
@@bluewolfe6048 yea so they didnt really leave
@@bluewolfe6048 ohh i didn't know about this!
HEARING THE *''THIS WEEK ON BUZZFEED UNSOLVED''* GIVES A FEELING LIKE NO OTHER
Yeah, "Welcom To Watcher Weekly" doesn't give u the nostalgia yet.
Except for HELLLOO hennies, how we all diddly doin
@@charfree6888 Also "Welcome one and all, to Puppet History!" uhh I miss Puppet History and Watcher Weekly :(
So does βSuh tuhdeyβs videuh...β
@@gluchie LMAOOOO YES I LOVE ELEANOR
What they don't mention in this video is that Ducat was fined roughly a week's wages earlier for not affixing the boxes to the moorings properly. My theory is that he didn't want to risk another fine so took Marshall down to do the repairs (the faults having been noted in the log) and left Marshall behind in the lighthouse (as per the rules). It was at that point that Marshall saw the huge wave coming and rushed out, not bothering to don his coat, to warn the other two. But he got there just as the wave struck and all 3 were washed out to sea. It was later noted that a large rock had been dislodged in that area by an "unknown force" and moved some 150 feet. Which gives you an idea of how powerful the wave was. So the tragedy happened primarily because the head keeper didn't want another fine - and he timed the visit to the cliff edge just as the freak wave came hurtling towards the island. (ps - I'm Scottish, from that area, and your impersonations were the worst I've ever heard! Worth watching just for that!).
This is a great theory!!!
Honestly This one makes more sense then the ones in the videoπ
It's not your theory, but OK.
@@mini696 wdym its not their theory lmfao what]
This theory does fit pretty well, and it does explain why MacArthur would leave his jacket behindβ¦ When someoneβs in danger youβre not gonna take time to grab your phone or make a sandwich
βWaves donβt get that big thatβs like 100 feetβ
βThough one time there was this 300 foot wave in that exact region.β
Yeah, that was a wierd statment to make. I was about to write a comment saying waves can easily reach WAAAY above 100 feet on open sea, but then he contradicted himself a minute later.
That sounds terrifying and also reinvigorates my fear of open seas.
Ryan: β...alien juice...β
Shane: **visible disappointment**
@niosonwii lool we wont
He krplus.net/bidio/k52cc3urh4XUpGE
YOO LOOK WHAT I FOUND π€―π€― krplus.net/bidio/c5uFjJSgrJrDi6A
which Shane the Shane in the video or Shane Dawson?
@@vp91049 rick roll i think
Ryan: these three men mysteriously disappeared without a trace and possibly faced a horrible painful demise
Shane: they're boyfriends :) and they live in Jamaica :)
We love an ally
We ship
he's an ao3 verified fanfic writer
@@andikaputri2625 Drop the account name Shane. Don't be shy ksksks
@@andikaputri2625
*yes drop the @*
They probably just ate the magic grass and become sheep
Reject humanity
Become shep
Yea happened to me one time
itβs true, I was the grass
I don't get why one of the theories isn't that there was an unknown boat that came in contact with the island, they asked the keepers for help, they rushed out (explaining missing coat) but it was actually a trap. The boat would have been a pirate boat looking to take 3, un-watched, strong, and good for manual labor men who they could sell in the labor market or just keep for themselves.
Surely if pirates kidnapped them there would be signs of violence or struggle
@@Aidan_7 not necessarily, If the men jumped on board to help or if they were in the water already. The waves could have also washed away any sign of struggle.
@@justaname4136 you're right!
But two of the light keepers are experienced and falling for pirates easily would be unreal, depends if they were really drunk or been hallucinating at that time. One of them should have given a sign like writing on the log or an emergency signal like the disc or smtng. Cause it came also to my mind that kind of theory but being an experienced lighthouse keeper can make you think all possible things that might happen in the lighthouse and later on think of ways to prevent it. They took the risk of the job which i guess should have made them at least prepared especially that they have family.
@@jessicastjames6202 dude, slavery and pirates still exist today
*talking about being outside*
Ryan: Itβs open concept.
Shane: I can really slap my thighs without the desk!
@FIN GHOULIE becuase of COVID-19, their staying safe
I died π€ as someone who has been forced to watch too many HGTV shows, I can attest to this
@@izzycole2601 love ur pfp lmao
Theyβre going insane
Shaneβs utter disappointment when he said βis this where this is going?β
I love it, he sounds so tired.
I loved that part haha
U G H
In that one sound there is so much damn emotion
tbf that was my exact reaction too.
My reaction whenever Ryan mentions ghosts or aliens tbh
Fun fact: The log books were actually made up much later as a dramatic retelling of a story in a magazine, so the men still being at the lighthouse after the storm occurred couldnβt have happened.
The most likely reason for their disappearance was because they were going after a toolbox that they accidentally left out, and would suffer a paycut as they were fined if anything was lost or damaged. And considering one of the lighthouse managers lost a piece of equipment in a storm before and was fined for it, it would make sense for them to go out so they wouldnβt get punished due to their meager salary of 42 shillings.
"couldn't have happened" or "could have not happened" ?
@@emackenzie could not have happened. meaning impossible cuz it's a story in a magazine, not reality.
β@@emackenziewhen you try to correct someone else but you're wrong anyway lmao
WHAAAAAAAAT
Ryan: Takes a little more nuance to scare the Bergmeister. *cut to Ryan being startled by a disco ball* *cut to Ryan being scared by Shane's fart* *cut to Ryan screaming after feeling a breeze on his hand*
*Cut to Ryan screaming screaming at a pidgin*
@@yaboileon3758
You tried your best.
Ryan's narration voice really makes Unsolved "Unsolved". It's kind of like a trademark.
Exactly why I donβt watch the other videos without them lol
Well they have a channel βwatcherβ they no longer work at buzzfeed which saddens me
@@kendallbricks9945 they still work at buzzfeed lol
@@Fa1ry they technically have a contract for Buzzfeed Unsolved for 1 more season after this, but they work at watcher mainly
π€£π€£π€£
Shane: loses a rap battle
Shane, minutes earlier: βMoore went ashore to knock on the doorβ
He folds under pressure
i don't know, i'm a sailor myself. i have over 5 years of sailing experience and any knowledge i have on how the ocean behaves is half estimation and half fact. is it unlikely for an extremely large wave to come up suddenly and wash away three fully grown men after a huge storm? yes, but it feasibly COULD happen. if they were outside checking to see if the storm was gone or working outside, the storm could've had one final fit and got them. i definitely believe that they were briefly checking outside on the status of the storm, hence the coat being left behind, and they were blindsided. the fact that there had been prior 300 ft waves and they were at 110 ft- it's possible.
The western landing showed signs of damage and areas above 200ft also showed damage from either a wave or the storm.
Near the west landing was a box in which gear was stored and one of the keepers had previously been fined for not securing properly in a previous storm.
They were almost definitely blown off or swept away.
It couldβve also been something as simple as all 3 of them falling from the iron railing. Iron is especially prone to rust from salt water, and maybe they all leaned on it to talk about whatever, and their combined weight made it give way. Falling 50 feet into water can potentially break bones, so 110 feet wouldnβt have made for a fun landing. Then, the current couldβve swept them further out to sea. Admittedly, it would be odd for all 3 of them to fall with it, but not impossible.
Yeah, I think to this day we don't actually know why Rogue waves happen.
this background music that starts at like 4:02 is incredibly anxiety-inducing... props to whoever composed it
yeah definitely dont watch when youβre trying to go to sleep π€£
Thanks!
I don't understand why the Gamekeeper isn't a key suspect here. He doesn't do his job properly for nearly two weeks and that just happens to coincide with the disappearance of the Keepers.
It was all part of his plan to convince the lighthouse association to pay him Β£10 a year instead
Lack of motive.
I mean Β£8 a year isn't a motivation to do your job
@@thoughtfulthoughts4645 i mean Β£8 in 1900 is about Β£1000 today
@@kktt725 and it went a lot farther too
I'm Scottish and I'm not offended by those accents. Shane and Ryan however, should be very VERY embarrassed by them.
I just wish a real Scotsman had said the line so we could all practice. Lol. Iβm pretty sure I spent 20 minutes doing a bad impression of Ryanβs bad impression. π€£π€£
The way shane said Light Hoose, was kinda accurate
@Alex *Okay Mr.Kinky boots*
Ikr lmao, Shanes wasn't terrible but it also wasn't good
@Alex I've never been so offended by something I completely agree with.
Although I believe it was a case of freak weather, the mental image of lighthouse keepers being abducted by aliens because they were attracted to a big light like moths is so funny to me
I like the big wave theory. What do they mean there wasnβt evidence of such a wave? What evidence would you want, the wave to leave a note?
"The killer left a sign."
'SURFS UP MORTALS!'
"Damn wave! Killed 3 more people! GOD, DAMN IT!!! WAAAAAAAAAVVVVVEEEEE!!!!!"
I think such a wave should leave shattered glass, damaged structures in and around the lighthouse, maybe even water damage inside the tower
@@atlaspagura8838 if the men were outside or closer to the shore when it swept them away, there wouldnβt necessarily be any evidence of a wave
Not like that but if a wave 300 ft high hit the island and the lighthouse, there would be evidence like salty water on the woods or wet clothes, equipments inside the building having water in them, other items swept up etc.
Obviously the wave isnβt gonna leave a note but evidence exists in everything, it would be odd to anyone there was no sign of a giant wave
Shane giving off middle school "horse girl" vibes with the headband
it's true but you shouldn't say it
SUPER UNDERATED (LEGEND)
krplus.net/bidio/ZdCfqZprdqi6eWE
Don't send any hate β€
I hope this makes it into postmortem π€£
We love you, horse girl Shane! Let that mane flow!
we need this in the roast-mortem
Based on Shane and Ryan's respective rhyming skills, Shane better hope he's with Ryan if they ever come across a clan of water sprites otherwise it's curtains for Shane.
I'm starting to think Shane had a ghostwriter helping him with the Hot Daga's music
I was shocked Shane wasn't better at this since he did not only the songs from the Hot Daga, but also all the songs in 2 seasons of Puppet History.
You could even say he'd be swimming with the fishes!
@@johanvajse8410 yeah but keep in mind that this is on the spot
There's a 50/50 chance that Ryan will win a rap battle
And he's gonna win all 50
Canβt believe aliens and old folklore creatures were part of the theories, but not pirates ππ
I feel like some people might just really be overlooking the idea that the elements are brutal and nature can take a nasty turn out of nowhere
Yea it was most likely a wave.
Shane: If this is offensive, I apologize.
Ryan: If you're offended, you should be.
Shaneβs wasnβt awful, but Ryanβs was borderline offensive.
I love how Ryan said 'life buoy'. It was very entertaining aha π€£π
@@TomCL-vb6xc yeah shane's was pretty good lmfao
I am not Scottish but I thought Ryan's accent was not good.
I'm Scottish, both terrible but extremely funny
Ryan: aliens
Shane: they were in love π§‘
BAHAHAHAHAHSVXJSV
ryan: murder
shane: .... they were in a poly relationship and ran away
Better oneβ¦β¦Aliens
I'm only two minutes in, so maybe it's already been covered in the episode, but *as a farmer*, it is more common for sheep (and goats, for that matter) to give birth to twins than single babies. We have a fairly small flock, but it's generally expected that we'll get at least one set of triplets every couple years.
It's more likely that having sheep graze on the island benefited them because when you have a flock on the same pasture for a while, the nutrients in the grass decrease, and the parasites in it increase. You have to switch sheep to different pastures every few months to keep them on good grass and keep the parasites down.
I was thinking about this and was waiting for one damned comment to mention it!!
Imagine being the guy who was off duty when all this sh*t went down
its like missing a day of school and everybody plays kahoot
I bet it haunted him for the rest of his life, not knowing what happened to his co-workers. Unless he met them again in Heaven and they explained what happened. But still, it'd be pretty gut wrenching.
@@CRUSH40RULES Lol met in heaven.
@@VirtuaSavage that sounds so cheesy
@@CRUSH40RULES Aw... that was honestly cute lol
When Ryan said, βItβs a can of alien juice,β Shaneβs face fell and I LOST it.
me too
"Oh, thats where this is F__king going?"
My favorite part π€£
An interesting thing to look into would be if this area, or the ocean area around this island is prone to seaquakes.
Especially since geographically it isn't that far off iceland, which is a volcanic region, maybe a sea quake occured that cause massive waves coupled with a storm. The men thought the storm had subsided, only to be surprised by a massive tsunami like wave. It would explain why they were outside despite there being stormy weather. Maybe they tried retrieving the swept away resources and they were surprised by that wave.
Finally a logical explanation!
Quakes in Scotland are rare most occur along the Great Glen and Highland boundary fault and rarely reach 5 on the Richter scale. I live in that area and have only felt one in my life that barely shook anything. Flannen Isles are only 18 miles off the Hebrides and I cannot find a single recorded earthquake there! Had seaquake caused a 100ft wave at Flannen its going to hit the Hebrides as well and be obvious what happened.
My thoery is something simple like one of them fell in for some reason and the other two were lost trying to rescue him
In terms of the banter between the two, this is one of the best episodes ever
I feel like theyre downplaying how terrifying the ocean can be. Rogue waves are no joke. Wanna talk spooky? Rogue waves man. Rogue waves. Why reach for aliens when the spookiness of the ocean is RIGHT THERE.
sure but rogue waves only really happen in the middle of the ocean, they need to draw energy from the surrounding waves and the closer you get to shore the less energy there is in the wave
@@dannytwomey9071 There are already records of 300ft waves hitting the island and the keepers said there was a storm (something supported by Mackenzie not being able to see the lighthouse for over a week), so I don't think lack of energy is really an issue here
wouldn't there be evidence of water in the lighthouse if this were the case?
@@fijiapples5122 if they were at the dock the wave would only be about 120ft not enough to reach the lighthouse. Plus water on the dock or water damage wouldn't be weird in that area.
i agree
Shane and Ryan: Let's get into some theories.
Me, without hesitation: THEY WERE EATEN BY THE SHEEP.
ππ
Great theory, very possible
Lol.
this is even better: They turned into sheep.
I KNEW IT
I can totally see Shane as a cryptic old man who lives in a lighthouse and mysteriously disappears, sparking internet speculation, having in reality been taken by a rogue wave as he stood by the sea. He is eaten by sea creatures and his ghost haunts the lighthouse, content with his own death but eternally pissed at the idiots who replaced him.
Me: But what if... they ran away togther
Shane: But what if they ran away together
Me: YES YOU'RE A GENIUS
Gamekeeper was possibly an Imposter. He wasn't doing his tasks.
Very sus
Gamekeeper sus
Best comment
Pretty sus
vote Gamekeeper all
for post mortem: Hey ghouligans! I'm from the Isle of Lewis (mentioned in the video) and I studied this in school! One thing that wasn't mentioned was that when investigators came upon the scene inside the lighthouse, the dinner was ready and untouched at the table, and a chair was toppled over as if it was all left urgently. He also left his coat behind which adds to this theory. Great to have the boys back, Happy spooky season! x
Thatβs a really interesting detail. I hope they mention this in the pm. Did you leave this under there pinned comment to just to be safe?
I agree with the person above me! This comment is great and you should definitely put it under the pinned comment at the top. Hopefully the boys will see this because this is a great detail!!
They kinda proved that was probably false, though; someone made features like that up a few years after they disappeared.
#postmortem (to raise your chances of this being seen hopefully)
My teacher told us about this in primary school and scared the crap out of me lol π
20:30 Love the implication that the lighthouse keepers were also mothmen
Plot twist: they ate the magic grass and just disappeared
Or they ate another kind of "magic grass" and stumbled off the island trying to look for the nearest Taco Bell
Aliens grow the magic grass and the keepers saw them and got snatched
I've smoked the magic grass and felt like I disappeared.
Plot twist the magic grass is weed and they got high and left the island.
They believed there was enchantment in the grass
*Went mad they did*
Ryan: believes in everything
Also Ryan: them being drunk or high just isnβt plausible to me.
βThem being drunk just isnβt plausible to meβ Ryan, have...have you been to Scotland?
And when he was talking about how it takes a lot more than blood to scare him,
Like lmao ok Ryan we're just supposed to eat some magic grass and forget about how you get scared by wind every time you go ghost hunting?
βThem being drunk just doesnβt seem plausible, so OBVIOUSLY it was aliens.β
aha sure...wind@@peridotasadeadbritishmonar7924
Idk as someone whose lived on the coast all my life, I'm always ready to believe the ocean is capable of anything
What if they made a suicide pact after no one came for them when the light was out for so long since they had low morale, thought that no one cared for them, and maybe became super depressed, then jumped into the ocean and froze to death then got swept out into the depths.
I actually like this theory
I hate this theory but it makes a whole lotta sense
What if they made a suicide after no one came because super dependsed, theΓ± jumped into the ocean and froze to death then got swept out into the depths.
And maybe the log and stuff was just to make everyone scared and sad for them to play a cruel prank post mortem.
Dude
Shane is out here, writing homoerotic fanfiction.
Quarantine does strange things to a man..
If I wanted to read homoerotic fanfiction about Scottish people, I wanted it to be Merida and two other Disney Princesses (in which they are all age appropriate)
and we love him for it
@@carsfan1995 mood
Omg he would so do that
Ok weβve blamed the sea, weβve blamed the aliens, but why have we not considered the sheep? I mean they seem like also possible candidates for all dastardly behaviour
But sheep are so innocent
@@DogeDogeriffic that's what they want you to think
Please answer this on post mortem ππππ
Yeps I don't trust those sheep
dam you look good follow my instagram mamas π₯΅ - curlyrafff
This is a fascinating story. What could possibly have happened to the three lighthouse keepers? I think the fact that one of them went out without his jacket could mean whatever happened was sudden. What makes the most sense is that they were somehow swept out to sea, but how? This is one of those mysteries I unfortunately donβt think weβll ever have the answers for.
It is fascinating. Especially when you take into account; A) that's the North Sea they are in, and waves get HUGE, over 100ft. is not unusual, B) the lamp they were using was floated on a LOT of mercury so it moved without friction, and part of the duties would be to keep that pool of mercury clear of debris and refill it as needed.
Due to the amount of mercury vapors inhaled, many lighthouse keepers went mad...just like hat makers, and for the same reason, inhalation of poison gas. If you want to see what the North Sea can be like, check out a few videos from bigwavemaster. He is on a 110ft. rescue boat in the North Sea, and posts videos of storms, shipboard life and some of the drills and real rescues they do. That piece of water is known for its storms and waves. The fishing boat Andrea Gail, (Storm of the Century) was out there during a major hurricane and was lost with all hands. βπΈ
@@PhoenixLyon This is probably the most educational comment I've read all week. Cheers!
I think science kinda figured it out by now. we know now about rogue waves, which are way bigger than an average wave, which in the North Sea is already bigger than average. plus, if it happened at night, they probably wouldn't have seen it until it was pretty close and too late to hunker down. it sounds insane to think a 300ft wave could sneak up on anyone, but the ocean is a terrifying place with immense power we are barely beginning to understand. back then, I bet that would've sounded ludicrous, but today, we have footage of such waves.
Imagine doing a rap battle with an army of Scottish faeries for your life and to avoid a horrible death by drowning
It was clearly mothman who killed them. He was attracted to the light
ππ Brilliant
Big light for a big moth
Bro hilarious
Haha! Yes!
Giant predatory moth
Iβm Scottish and I can say with confidence that Shaneβs accent was horrible but was definitely better than Ryanβsπππ
π same!
Right? It was so funny, they were both so bad
@@RaeGreywood Ryan sounded Russian?! Hahahaha
Ditto
THEY WERE BOTH SO BAD LOL
rapping mermaid geezer : "anyone wants to have a rap battle!? "
eminem: "hold my beer, i will volunteer and i'll end your deadass career"
This is still the best True Crime episode. The energy they have from finally being back together after the VID lockdown is shining.
i believe shaneβs theory. they were a throuple, left the island and lived happily ever after
Well I guess the only unbelievable thing about this theory is that one of the guys didn't grab his coat although it was late December. Oh and also in the logs there was nothing saying anything about that. If they were contemplating leaving the island together they would have at least wrote where they were going, maybe not exactly why, but that they were going ππ¨π¦ππ°π‘ππ«π. But it still is a sweet theory. Sorry if I went to in-depth about this.
@@mortis.1618 itβs fine. i just made this comment as a joke. i donβt think that is a very plausible theory, since (like you said) there is no evidence in the logs about them contemplating leaving the island and that the one had forgotten his coat in december. i feel like maybe one had fallen in the water and got swept under a wave and when the other 2 tried to help him, they also got swept under
Honestly magic grass isnβt the weirdest thing in Gaelic/Scottish history. We were really superstitious back in the day π
Gae.lic.k.
@Malina Fogina bruh
Back in the day? We are still like that
I'm wondering if the minerals soaked up by the grass would have provided a nutritional boost
@@adderkay no its gaelic
Shaneβs face at 8:13! He was so done when Ryan mentioned βAlien Juiceβ I had to stop the video because I had a laughing fit. βIs that where this is f**king going?β Man is so disappointed. π€£π€£π€£π€£
The look of disappointment on Shaneβs face when Ryan mention aliens.
As a Scottish person, that was the worst but most hilarious Scottish accent I've heard
@Dark Star who hurt you πππ
It offended me how bad it was haha
I so agree I am Scottish American and my cousin would come to the states and we would try and mimic each other it was hilarious π I sounded like that too
@Dark Star yes. British food is the best cuisine in the world doubtlessly
@@mercury728 nothin better than mucky fat and bread or some mushy peas
The way the βalien juiceβ comment destroyed Shaneβs joy in mere seconds
I feel like theyre downplaying how terrifying the ocean can be. Rogue waves are no joke. Wanna talk spooky? Rogue waves man. Rogue waves. Why reach for aliens when the spookiness of the ocean is RIGHT THERE.
@@joaniewalen7821 ikr, the ocean is a scary place man....it could kill even the strongest man
His disappointment was palpable
@@fawkespryde9183 And his day was ruined.
What? You knew this was coming
I lost it when the dusgust covered his face and hes just like
"Is that where this is fuckin going....? Is that where this is going?"
βWhat did you learn from this episodeβ
βScottish accents are hard to doβ
Shanes sounds like groundskeeper willie
Ryan: "yea the lighthouse keepers probably died in some horrible way, rip them"
Shane: **drinking his respect gays and polys juice** "what were you saying?"
Shane, trying to do a Scottish accent: does a Yorkshire accent
Ryan, trying to do a Scottish accent: does a Russian accent
so i wasn't wrong when I thought shane sounded like one of my friends with Russian accent ππ
No one in america knows the difference
@@wuzhappening eeehhhhh, ones a commie and ones a drunk lol. Pretty sure βmericanβs can tell that difference
@@zacariasnelson5753 who's who
@@perishonimpact Russians are the commies and yorshirians are the drunks lol
Ryan: Oh look, it says alien juice
Shane: .......is that where this is going-
The IMMENSE disappointment in his tone ππ Oh how Iβve missed this
LMFAOOO it's the look he gave for me
Well cannot blame him though...the moment Ryan mentioned about that i'm like...."owh,Ryan not again."
8:10
β¦
Very odd how the clocks stopped, was it a coincidence that they broke or did the keepers stop them before they left? Canβt think of any other explanations
If they needed wound, they must've wound them all at the same time so then they'd stop at the same time (or approximately).
Maybe the clocks got water damage in one of those big freak waves that swept the light keepers away, then dried out over the course of the two weeks it took for the lookout to report the light was out.
Ye olde wind-up clocks, eh? Gotta wind them up every now and then or they top.
They wound down & stopped after the men disappeared. I have a mantle clock which needs wound once a week.
Thank you guys, the clocks was the one thing I couldn't really connect to a rogue wave or pirates or something, but I totally forgot that clocks would have needed to be wound back then XD
I was once told by someone who used to work as a boarding officer that once you got swept out to the sea there is really nothing any person can do as the sea would just pull you away really fast.
Could throw a rope, chase em in a boat, hell there's lot you can do
@@dougr8646 Nope the wave are faster than your reaction.Esp in the dark dark sea.Maybe during the day there are higher chances you are not wrong but in the dark is another story.
Postmortem theory: theyβre all mothman and thatβs why they attracted to the alien light
I'm a shaniac, but I agree.
*[mothman noises]*
Solved
ππ»ππ»ππ»ππ»
Big Brain theory
I missed Ryanβs narrating voice...
At random moments I say things like "In *1934,* " in his narrator voice
you should check out Watcher, it's a company that Ryan, Shane and Steven Lim all started, and Ryan narrates on there
Did he say sheep who died on the grass give birth to twins or recover from illness? What?
@@mr.bubbles8351 dined?
@@JonPITBZN ohhh lol. Cuz even the captions said dined. Had me confused
There is nothing scarier than the mysterious disappearance of people when they are in an area that they are already considered experienced in that area
My words in a rap battle with a sprite would be
βYou are a sprite
To death you will choke
And Iβll throw you away
Because I prefer Cokeβ
I am indeed a sprite
One of the very best
I got that nice green shade
And a lemony zest
i was 57 seconds into this video and shaneβs already talking about slapping his thighs this is gonna be a fantastic season
Please stop messaging my son. Get over it. If you donβt stop, Iβll report your channel for harassment. Move on please.
@@LazyLizzy706 what do you guys mean
@@LazyLizzy706 wtf
@@LazyLizzy706 what?
As an animal science major-I laughed at the βmagic grass makes sheep have twinsβ Sheep give birth to twins like 90% of the time magic grass or not
Yeah, I get the feeling the farmers were like, "Anybody using this grass? No? HAVE AT IT, SHEEP!"
And sometimes you wish they didn't...
You say that, but maybe all grass is magic.
Shhhhhh magic grass π
Do they really!? That's crazy, I didn't know that.
iβm obsessed with the implication that the lighthouse keepers have the same light obsession as moths
This is my hangover/anxiety comfort video
Ryan : βLooks like a can of alien juice!β
Shane : βIs that where this is f***ing going....β
Ofc it is ππ
the disappointment π
It always is..πππ
I love the light disappearing in Shane's eyes as Ryan said that
I love that Shane thinks ghosts and ancient aliens are nonsense, but heβs willing to shrug off Scottish sheep magic like itβs nothing
what flag is that in your icon? i can't tell if it's the bi flag with a wide middle stripe, the pan flag, or something else entirely. (god please don't "duhhh it's so obvious tho" me, not everyone has the same color vision as you 24/7)
@@bosselotiscanon it's bi
@@wishnyx cool, i love that! thank you
use r gay
Bro ik right i had to rewind to make sure I heard that correctly cause he just kept going like itβs nothing WTFFFF
βI just saw some little women on the street and I sobbedβ was by far the best part
β there were no signs of a major waveβ yeah there was. The life ring was missing
Being Scottish, the accent is not offensive. I love when someone tries a Scottish accent to see how terrible it is, Iβm not disappointed. 10/10 for effort, 4/10 for execution.
Alba gu brath
Scottish and Irish accents are gorgeous though letβs be real hahaha
Also Scottish, not offended but it made me cringe just a tiny bit
For post mortem: The reason that British Lighthouses had teams of three keepers was because of an incident called the Smalls Lighthouse Tragedy where one of the two keepers died in an accident. The other keeper was terrified of being accused of murder, since the two of them had been known to feud, and so tied the body in a makeshift coffin outside the lighthouse to try and preserve it, but the coffin broke and released an arm in such a way that in the wind it seemed to beckon to the remaining keeper, who had lost his mind by the time he was finally relieved. Could something similar have happened here, where two of the three keepers were accidentally killed, and the remaining one lost his mind out of the fear of being blamed?
Thatβs terrifying
@@Bananachan289 sounded like The Lighthouse movie
@@surinurkholifah2083 well, thatβs because this story inspired the movie
thats alarmingly possible
BUMP. i like this one
I listen/watch these as I am going to sleep. Whenever Shane talks I can't help but imagine The Professor now.
Same
honestly if they ever do a braveheart reboot i want shane and ryan to be in it-
For the post mortem: As a person who lives on a coastal town in Scotland the fact that one of them went out without a jacket in December and how their logs said it was cold makes me confused because If youβve lived on a coastal town in the winter the wind is freezing and you know better something else happened on that island
I agree!
I wear a jacket even in the summer time cause itβs still cold π
That is unusual. But if the situation was so dire and someone request his help, he might not have had time to retrieve it.
@Denix Vames But if there was a storm there wouldnβt have been silence? Although maybe if the silence did make them go mad they could have imagined the storm.
@Daniel it just doesnβt sit right with me and the fact that the fire wasnβt burned for a while none of it sits right with me
Guess who's back, back again? The ghoul boys are back, tell a friend
I've told seventeen friends so far
Thank you, Kim Jong-Un. Very cool.
Hi god
Better call the demons back
@@ethanallen6898 u have 17 friends? Must be nice...
17:00 Ryan's little gremlin laugh is adorable
i think this particular case comes under the case of people being mystified by the "Spookiness" of the environment that this story takes place, like with the Elisa Lam case. It's more than likely that these poor men had met with a terrible accident- someone fell into the sea, the others tried to save him, and resulted them all dying.
for post mortem, consider this: a big light and disappearances? mothman.
MOTHMAN
@@jannaojah THERE'S NO NEED TO FEEL DOWN
They did Mothman
For Post Morten: Shane, PLEASE drop your hair care routine. Help a girl get luscious locks boi
Yup π anyhow consider checking βdaily_discourseβ on instagram for debates yβall! Appreciate it πππ₯
@@joelpark3075 wow you are shameless
use r both gay
I'm from Scotland (Glasgow) and this was really fun to watch. Those impressions of the scottish accent need some work but awesome attempt love you guys ! :))
I saw one episode of BussFeed Unsolved and have spent two days in a BuzzFeeding frenzy!!! So love that youβve covered the Lighthouse in Scotland! This story has always scared the crap out of me! You guys need to do a ghost hunt there!! Pleeeease!!
I love how the sex with sheep joke went over Ryan's head lol
And Shane's dejected face afterwards
Time stamp?
@@actuallyatlas 2:35
@@joshuahadams thanks g
Ikr..?
I know that they are not in the office, but every time the camera goes to Shane I get scared that the mannequin is gonna be there in the shadows.
EDIT: NEVERMIND I FOUND IT
There is something in the doorway behind them, looks like a mannequin π
@@AxxLAfriku probably cause you self advertise and weird af
Haha silly woman
There was one episode where the mannequin's head turned towards Shane.
@@JerBuster77 lmao what one??
Ryan repeating "their final logs" to explain his poop joke made me cackle out loud alone in my apartment.
"Tell me more about these .. men.."
Crying laughing.