Hi, this is my new KRplus channel. My old channel was suspended so I created a new one. If you like my videos, Plz follow me on social media to get the newest notifications 🤗 KRplus: krplus.net/Cd0MBeYAEDv84vyEMA64K7A Facebook: facebook.com/hyeongiee.official/ Instagram: instagram.com/hyeongiee.official/
@@crystalcastle660 according to some articles that I Saw, main vocalist has better vocal techniques than lead, but let's be Frank, with their talents, i don't even make the difference. So much talent.
I hope Giselle can gain more confidence. It looks like she’s holding back a lot. She just needs a little more push and she’ll be unstoppable. You go girl!
I think after Ningning belted the first pre chorus high note, they decided to adjust the volume of her mic because she overpowered the AR. But still, they really ate this up. Monster rookie ❤️
unbelivable. that’s amazing as a new girl group. And Ningning also Winter are belting. It’s can’t see in another else. I’m truthly hope Aespa more successful than now. They desevere it.
멤버 밸런스가 너무 좋은듯. 일단 보컬멤 2명이 각각 다른 느낌으로 탄탄하게 꽉 잡아주고 있음. 윈터는 이름처럼 시원시원하고 벙뚫리는 고음으로, 닝닝은 쫀득쫀득한 느낌으로.. 그리고 단순히 비주얼멤버인 줄 알았던 카리나가 알고보니 밸러스캐였던 것도 발리고.. 얼굴, 춤, 랩 다 평균 이상.. 특히 중저음 보이스가 고음멤인 윈터 닝닝이랑 대조돼서 매력적으로 다가옴.(여돌중에 저런 중저음 보이스는 첨 들어봄) 마지막으로 제일 독특하다고 생각된 랩멤버 지젤. 솔직히 여돌랩퍼 대부분 노래를 못불러서 가사 읽는 식의 랩파트 맡는 경우 많은데 지젤은 정말 랩을 잘해서 랩멤버가 된거라 포지션이 확고함. 기본적으로 3명이 보컬이 안정적이고 지젤 역시 라이브에 능하기 때문에 아주 탄탄한 그룹 같다. 오래 보고 싶다
This song is difficult for singing. They are still rookies and they did encore great without any exuses like "they were tired", "they wanted to thank their fans", "they were just having fun". Good job, SM.
Ningning didn't use falsetto at all, she's really belting those high notes and uses headtone, you can literally hear how loud her crisp voice is among the other girls voices at the start.If sound tech didn't adjust her mic it would be as if they're not in sync together and will literally overpowered others.Tho I must agree it's too much of an adjustments.Even Giselle's mic is too low even tho at first Giselle's voice is not that loud.They less adjusted Winter's mic which in the first place they should,that tiny but loud unique voice of hers comes out naturally and should be toned down cause it really is overpowering others.Karina's mic and Giselle's doesn't really need a lot of adlustments cause of their tone quality and they're not belting that much.I think sound techs really got confused on how to adjust their voices 😅 but anyways I'm one of the MY and I don't have any biases cause I love em all! I just said things like this cause I also sing in a band.peace y'all!
@@AmiAki It's not that they can't sing (OK admittedly some of them can't lol) but it's just that they don't have the right training. Poor Nayeon is going to ruin her voice if she keeps getting pushed to sing high notes when she doesn't get the training to handle them correctly, and let's not even get started on how shaky they all are when singing live.
@미야자키무야호 아 마마시타 엠알 제거가 유명하긴 한데 대중적으로 실력 좋은 그룹 노래 잘하는 그룹으로 잘 알려지지 않은게 엘프로서 좀 아쉽다는 느낌이죠ㅠㅠ 맴버 9명중 5명이 정식으로 솔로 데뷔도 했고 맴버가 다 솔로 음원을 낸 그룹인데 어른분들은 아직도 슈주를 많이 저평가 해서ㅠㅠ
I am so happy that ningning is so appreciated in the comments section,she is so young but so skilled, no wonder they compared to her sunbae Bada also is it just me or karina has a beautiful voice, she got indie vibes while singing,anyways Aespa ate this cb🔥🔥🔥
Actually when i first saw their debut teasers, my mental image of karina is that she’s someone who would try hard to act cute with such teeny tiny singing voice and talks in baby. but in reality she’s so matured and has this very thick velvety voice. she actually exceeded all expectations.
2:10 KARINA ISNT EVEN A MAIN VOCALIST Jesus and she's 10x better live than MOST idols. Also did u notice, they do not have in an ear piece to hear themselves, and are singing over a loud backing track. I would absolutely sound like a dieing cat and I consider myself a decent singer. These girls deserve way more props for their raw talent
honestly amazed about how everyone still sounds a bit diff but perfect all tgthr but the way karina’s tone literally sounds the exact same as the original audio..she’s amazing
This encore stage is the proof that what we heard until now was all pre-recorded. And now I'm even more mad with the company. Aespa are already top tier vocalist even if they are new in the industry. Why sm doesn't allow them to sing live? They train everyday to sing, let them sing sometimes please, their raw voices are amazing.
TOTALLY AGREE. they nailed it but why SM doesn’t allow them to sing live like this. live stage with pre-recorded vocal is perfect, i know, but it’s boring. and i guess we don’t need the 1000% perfect stage. all we need the real and powerful live stage
@@hasyaqinthara6868 It's not just only Aespa but their fellow labelmates of SM Music and even to their future roofmates of the soon-to-be Lyfe Labels Family (existing SM Labels such as Mystic Story + Woollim, FNC, Blockberry, Kakao Labels and CJENM Labels because SM management is keen on having a multi-label structure like Hybe does in the upcoming years and a possible company change to Lyfe) as well are also caught in lipsync too. Every Kpop acts were caught in the act in lipsync, no one is safe in the first place.
@@hasyaqinthara6868 Exactly! I don't understand why but during this corona era, more and more agencies became obsessed with perfection. Even agencies whose groups were known to sing 90% of their stages live..
So far, I saw some ppl somehow didn't appreciate Ningning abt her vocal as much as other group's main vocalists. We all know there's always a reason why someone debuted as main vocalist and it shows in Ningning. Main vocalist in SM. Eventho somehow I feel her voice hadn't matured yet at first, she definitely grows better and better as time goes, I believe sooner or later, in the future she'll get that title "one of best female main vocalists"
@lola dacutest stayc is full of vocals they are very stable and they do a lot of amazing high notes so i think it wouldn’t be the best group for her cause she wouldn’t shine a lot like she does with ning in aespa
The truth I want to hear her sing an entire vocal based song I love her tone so much and I’ve heard people say this already but she gives LeeHi vibes with the tone of her voice
This encore will be much better if SM didn't provide track with loud backtrack vocals on it. I bet most of their performances has loud backtracks even if they sang it live. It will be overpowered by backtrack vocals.
걍 스엠이 요즘은 퍼포 중심으로 하고 왠만한 아이돌도 ar깔고 그 위에 부분부분 라이브하는데 어쭙잖게 노래 못해서 라이브 안한다 이러면서 깐 놈들 다 어디갔는지ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ,,, 가요대제전도 라이브였고 포에버도 라이브였는데 라이브한 적 없다 하면서 사실왜곡이나 하고ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ…
그리고 무조건 라이브에 집착하는 것도 진짜 이해가 안 감 쌩라이브만이 노래 실력이라고 생각해서 눈에 불을 키고 라이브라이브라이브 이러는 사람들…. 그냥 존나 사람 한명 보내버리고 싶어서 작정한 사람들 같음 지들딴엔 착한 말투로 말해보지만 심성 삐뚤어진 거 다 티남 으윽 쌩라이브만 소리내서 잘한다고 그게 잘하는 건지 진짜 이상한 거에 집착하는
아 잘하는 건 알겠는데 눈막귀막하고 라이브했다고 좀 하지 맙시다 팬들이 라이브 부심을 하도 부려대니까 앵콜에서 라이브 얼마나 잘하는지 두고보려고 대중들이 눈 부릅뜨고 있는 거임 솔직히 무대에서 늘 립싱크하고 라이브 한번도 안 한 거 맞는데요 포에버 때 마이크에서 입 떼도 목소리 나오는 건 어떻게 해명하실 건가요? 립싱크 다 들통났는데요?
Considering that this video has a lot of views, proving that everyone is anticipating to see Aespa in their encore, nevertheless they never disappoints.
Tengo que decir que me quedo sorprendida con NINGNING no uso falsete, en el MV pense que lo hacia, pero literalmente canta la nota alta de cabeza y no le cuesta nada, domina un gran rango vocal es supremamente maravillosa su voz y puedo decir que para su voz esta muy bien practicada lo que se reduce a una buena tecnica vocal... Todas son talentosas se merecen los mejores exitos.
aespa members have such distinct voices. I feel like if they were trained in other company, it wouldn't be like this and people might be mesing with them right now.
They'll still be good cause they all have nice voice but won't be this good. That's why good training is really important even other idols that trained in SM sound good even when debuted in other agencies
Aaaa aespa, they never make mistakes in vocals, I'm multifandom. They rocked, there won't be anything to take it away :) Winter is beautiful as always, angel vocals. Ningning, what a wonderful vocal!! Giselle the rap impeccable, Karina looks great in costumes! Being in this fandom is wonderful! The girls are complete
Wow i love the way you filtered their voices, damn you did a great job with this compared to other channels that does this you outdo them!! keep it up.
Stop saying ning is not confident Reason why her 2 highnote belts on the end is not as loud is because it looks like her mic is toned down same as Giselle
was amazed as how Ningning could blend almost perfectly with the backing track! If it did not have the backing vocals they would sound much better (because they were a bit out of the timing)
I think the reason aespa never did full live singing, either it prerecorded or always backed up with loud backtrack was; 1. Every music shows or award shows i watched have been doing this to every idol and especially became a "natural" thing to do ever since the pandemic (except the encore stage like this maybe)and probably just because they want the show and the idols looks "perfect" in their performances but idk if this is the show's, the idols' or the company's decision 2. For savage i think the keep changing tune/key of the song and tiring choreography probably the main reason
They should saw their sunbaes like snsd, fx, shinee, etc, they sang live. I think, music show nowadays prioritize dance performance than balanced performance
@@alondraa.3522 technically itzy aren’t rookies anymore, I feel like a group like ive could be a better comparison since aespa and ive are both amazing
What are y'all talking about? It's "Mixed Voice". You can clearly hear that she connected her head voice to her chest voice which is Impossible to do with Falsetto, In Falsetto there should be a cut.
![[ HyeongieeㅣMR Removed ]](http://yt3.ggpht.com/WAPTaC8jWw-FCThVsBYh6IjsG4k6wp-tHmsfytcJFTmIO1ehOhF40V8inodpo4OkgJieOEDG-w=s48-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj)
![[앵콜캠4K] 에스파 'Savage' 인기가요 1위 앵콜 직캠 (aespa Encore Fancam) | @SBS Inkigayo_2021.10.24.](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/404m3pSi4oM/mqdefault.jpg)
![[앵콜캠4K] 에스파 'Savage' 인기가요 1위 앵콜 직캠 (aespa Encore Fancam) | @SBS Inkigayo_2021.10.24.](/img/tr.png)
![[MR Removedㅣ엠알 제거] aespa(에스파) _ Spicy(스파이시) @ 240330 KCON HONG KONG 2024](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/HB_E385Bqdo/mqdefault.jpg)
![[4K] LOL😁 THE UNSTOPPABLE CHOI SOO YOUNG!!! (Turn on CC)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/CTThXhphEAk/mqdefault.jpg)
![[스페셜] 등장만으로 투수조 사기 저하💦 역대급 트라이아웃 지원자의 등장💥 | 최강야구 | JTBC 240415 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XS5qT9orzdA/mqdefault.jpg)
![[#눈물의여왕 13화] 9천억이 왜 여기서 나와...?🌸 모슬희VS퀸즈가💥 홍만대 회장이 평생 악착같이 모은 돈의 주인은!?](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/u4-VZFdSkc4/mqdefault.jpg)
![[CLEAN MR REMOVED] 231111 aespa Drama | Show! MusicCore MR제거](/img/0.gif)
Hi, this is my new KRplus channel. My old channel was suspended so I created a new one.
If you like my videos, Plz follow me on social media to get the newest notifications 🤗
KRplus: krplus.net/Cd0MBeYAEDv84vyEMA64K7A
Facebook: facebook.com/hyeongiee.official/
Instagram: instagram.com/hyeongiee.official/
And if you have any questions or requests, please leave a comment 👇🏻👇🏻👇🏻
@@hyeongieemrremoved9763 엔하이픈 음악방송도 엠알제거 해주세요~~
How about a MR. REMOVED on their performance not encore please. The REAL, FIXED MIC PLEASE. 🙏
Ningning knows how to protect her voice. She uses her head tone here for the high notes. a true vocalist.
Uh what?
Its heady mix
Thanks for pointing the obvious
@@scarlett9750 vocal talk
@@AmiAki why are u so salty for no reason lol
0:55 this was the moment the sound director said, "holy shit lower her mic volume, she's too powerful for this world"
probably almost destroying the mic lol
Ningnings deserves the main vocalist position !! Shes hitting those high notes with confidence 🥰
She is main vocal along with Winter
@@harryandria5136 no, winter is lead vocal
@@crystalcastle660 according to some articles that I Saw, main vocalist has better vocal techniques than lead, but let's be Frank, with their talents, i don't even make the difference. So much talent.
@love there is, in smtown global shop and it mentioned ningning is the main vocalist. Although it's obvious, you can check it by yourself
@love no, SM global shop revealed aespa members with their positions when they debuted.
Winter high notes coming so clean even on the MR because her voice is really really loud
I'm actually shaken watching their encore stages, like winter's high notes are too powerful it even Overpowered the loud backtrack.
NingNing mic was messed up during the performance as well. She was trying to tell the staff but she couldn't and had to sing with the out of tune mic
I hope Giselle can gain more confidence. It looks like she’s holding back a lot. She just needs a little more push and she’ll be unstoppable. You go girl!
I can see why SM choose them she's a strong idol
I think her mic is lower volume
I still think they turned her microphone down
The beginning scared me lol😭❤️
@@asm_clc Why did the beginning scare you?
When they lowered Ningning's mic volume output because she's not afraid to belt 😂
NingWang 👑🦋
what does belt mean？
@@marczhao2734 "pull off"
@@biteme9505 that's literally not what it means
Gfriends it's good too
I think after Ningning belted the first pre chorus high note, they decided to adjust the volume of her mic because she overpowered the AR. But still, they really ate this up. Monster rookie ❤️
same thoughts but it was too low that we almost cant hear her
@@nuguya6194 yes. I think Giselle's mic was also toned down. You can really see she is rapping her lines out but we can barely hear anything.
Ningning used falsetto in the last part
@@denmarkbaltazar6907 no its not, its heady mix voice also her mic is toned down
@@denmarkbaltazar6907 yes.
윈터랑 닝닝이 잘하는건 알았는데 생각했던거보다 카리나 보컬이 훨씬 탄탄하고 듣기 편해서 놀랏음..
카리나가 진짜 알참
ㅇㅇ 기본기가 탄탄하다고 해야 하나 그리고 뭐든 열심히 함
카리나 님이 의외로 sm으로 캐스팅 되기 전부터 가수가 꿈이셔서 어릴 때부터 보컬트레이닝 받으면서 꾸준히 준비해오셨다고 하네요
음역대 낮은 파트를 받아서 그런 거 같음
@@user-db5kv6nc4z 칭찬 하나를 그냥 보고 지나가지를 못하네..
Karina's tone will always remain my favourite! I don't know what she has in her voice but I'm a big fan!
same . I love voices like hers and Jennie's.
Her tone is beautiful
Her tone is too husky for me.
I prefer Winter
Same
Samee
unbelivable. that’s amazing as a new girl group. And Ningning also Winter are belting. It’s can’t see in another else. I’m truthly hope Aespa more successful than now. They desevere it.
Chào đồng chí🌧🌧
krplus.net/bidio/Yc9tq12gnoPcloo
Mv..❤
it's not unbelievable, kpop stans are just used to kpop idols literally not knowing how to sing
@@rachel8872 literally, like most of the time only 1 or 2 members can actually sing
nothing unbelivable about singers being good at singing
이정도는 해야 스엠에서 데뷔할 수 있는거군
진짜 어렵고 힘들겠다...
krplus.net/bidio/Yc9tq12gnoPcloo
Mv..❤
@@DEHN0 랩 담당
이잖아,
@@DEHN0 정작 춤실력으로 SM도 못들어갈 사람이ㅋㅋ
@@DEHN0 너 병먹금이 일상맞지??안봐도 비디오임 ㅇㅇ
닝닝이 성량 다 뚫고 나오는 거 봐,,,
theyre singing without in ears?! what the heck ?! TALENT
And on top of that they had to compete with the loud backtrack 👏
OMG- I just realised, no matter what anyone says no one can deny aespa's vocals and even raps are no joke
Because of the loud backtracks that even louder than their mics
@@dystephiary I was thinking that they weren’t good with their pitch at some points then forgot they were doing their encore with the backtrack
no one uses in-ears during encore in music shows
지젤도 코러스? 살짝살짝 하는데 노래 잘함
그냥 넷다 잘함. 쩐다
krplus.net/bidio/Yc9tq12gnoPcloo
Mv..❤
멤버 밸런스가 너무 좋은듯. 일단 보컬멤 2명이 각각 다른 느낌으로 탄탄하게 꽉 잡아주고 있음. 윈터는 이름처럼 시원시원하고 벙뚫리는 고음으로, 닝닝은 쫀득쫀득한 느낌으로.. 그리고 단순히 비주얼멤버인 줄 알았던 카리나가 알고보니 밸러스캐였던 것도 발리고.. 얼굴, 춤, 랩 다 평균 이상.. 특히 중저음 보이스가 고음멤인 윈터 닝닝이랑 대조돼서 매력적으로 다가옴.(여돌중에 저런 중저음 보이스는 첨 들어봄) 마지막으로 제일 독특하다고 생각된 랩멤버 지젤. 솔직히 여돌랩퍼 대부분 노래를 못불러서 가사 읽는 식의 랩파트 맡는 경우 많은데 지젤은 정말 랩을 잘해서 랩멤버가 된거라 포지션이 확고함. 기본적으로 3명이 보컬이 안정적이고 지젤 역시 라이브에 능하기 때문에 아주 탄탄한 그룹 같다. 오래 보고 싶다
ㅇㅈ 깔끔하네여
깔끔 정리 굳🙆♀️
Ningning's voice is so clear and sharp!! The true main vocalist of 4th gen
0:54 내가 이래서 닝닝을 좋아해....
보컬 미쳤다ㅜㅠㅠ
저두요ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ💕
와 쩐다 성량 미쳤...
근데 끝엔 왜그래ㅐ
윈터랑 닝닝은 원래 보컬라인 이기도 하고 잘하는거 알고 있는데 카리나 엄청 탄탄하네..ㄷㄷ 개사기캐...
'카리나는 신이에요'
@Hayeon Kim 지젤은솔직히 그정도까진아닌.. 춤이나 보컬이나 비주얼도
@@assaps 엥 ... 비주얼은 왜?ㅋㅋ
@@assaps 아이즈원 팬ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@assaps 칭찬글에 굳이 시비털고 가네
@@assaps 비주얼 오지는데? 보컬도 학창시절에 성악(?) 했었고..ㅋㅋ;
This song is difficult for singing. They are still rookies and they did encore great without any exuses like "they were tired", "they wanted to thank their fans", "they were just having fun". Good job, SM.
krplus.net/bidio/Yc9tq12gnoPcloo
Mv..❤
SNSD has the most fun during encores and they never disappoint
twice can't relate
@@user-bo4fb3ne6l of course no )))
@@Cheffamily red velvet ?
Ningning didn't use falsetto at all, she's really belting those high notes and uses headtone, you can literally hear how loud her crisp voice is among the other girls voices at the start.If sound tech didn't adjust her mic it would be as if they're not in sync together and will literally overpowered others.Tho I must agree it's too much of an adjustments.Even Giselle's mic is too low even tho at first Giselle's voice is not that loud.They less adjusted Winter's mic which in the first place they should,that tiny but loud unique voice of hers comes out naturally and should be toned down cause it really is overpowering others.Karina's mic and Giselle's doesn't really need a lot of adlustments cause of their tone quality and they're not belting that much.I think sound techs really got confused on how to adjust their voices 😅 but anyways I'm one of the MY and I don't have any biases cause I love em all! I just said things like this cause I also sing in a band.peace y'all!
My thoughts too
Only twice use falsetto for high notes cuz they can’t sing and scared their own high notes properly lol
@@AmiAki why you have to bring other groups here? Stop it
@@AmiAki It's not that they can't sing (OK admittedly some of them can't lol) but it's just that they don't have the right training. Poor Nayeon is going to ruin her voice if she keeps getting pushed to sing high notes when she doesn't get the training to handle them correctly, and let's not even get started on how shaky they all are when singing live.
@@sims2lovealot they all can sing, just cause they aren't Main vocal level doesn't mean they cant
ar이 저렇게 빵빵한데 인이어도 안차고 저정도면 진짜 잘부른다. 역시 슴돌은 실력으로 깔수가 없음
와씨 인이어 안 찬거엿음??
ㄹㅇ 인이어 없어서 조금씩 밀리긴한데 음정 잡는거 진짜 대단
Ningning is the best. Karina's tone is amazing.
카리나 ar에 묻혀서 소리 잘 안들렸는데 이거 보니까 진짜 보컬 진짜 탄탄하구나 깨달음… 닝닝 윈터 개잘함ㄹㅇㅜㅜㅜㅜ
krplus.net/bidio/Yc9tq12gnoPcloo
Mv..❤
Ning Ning and winter are not boys
@@lowspects8027 acho que traduziu errado hahaha
@@lowspects8027 u translate wrong lol
스엠은 진짜 실력으론 구설수 오르는게 이상한거지..레벨,엔시티,엑소,소시,샤이니 등등 다 라이브 mr제거 볼때마다 완벽해서 사이다 한 병 마시는 느낌
+헉 슈주를 빼먹었네요!!ㅜㅜ죄송해요!!
본방 첫방 부터 라이브 뛰는 엔시티(원래 첫주는 ar)
마이크로 라이브 인증 강슬기
ㄹㅈㄷ 샤이니 돈콜미 앵콜
이번에 엠카 스티커 앵콜 라이브도 미쳤어요 다들 보세요
슈주도 라이브 진짜 잘 하는데 많이 모르는거 같아서 아쉽ㅠㅠ
일단 .. 못하는 그룹이 없음 그래서 슴콘 가면 귀르가즘 때문에 미쳐버림
@미야자키무야호 아 마마시타 엠알 제거가 유명하긴 한데 대중적으로 실력 좋은 그룹 노래 잘하는 그룹으로 잘 알려지지 않은게 엘프로서 좀 아쉽다는 느낌이죠ㅠㅠ 맴버 9명중 5명이 정식으로 솔로 데뷔도 했고 맴버가 다 솔로 음원을 낸 그룹인데 어른분들은 아직도 슈주를 많이 저평가 해서ㅠㅠ
3:40 윈터 진성 고음 극락 파트
방금해봤는데 나도 쉽게 되네요? 헐
@니애를낳게해줘 너무해...
@니애를낳게해줘 ㅋㅋㄱㄱㅋㅋㄱㄱ
@니애를낳게해줘 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ개웃기네
@@sungjin3175 귀여웡
I am so happy that ningning is so appreciated in the comments section,she is so young but so skilled, no wonder they compared to her sunbae Bada also is it just me or karina has a beautiful voice, she got indie vibes while singing,anyways Aespa ate this cb🔥🔥🔥
still tons of haters blame her for the mic issue and bash her for poor vocal and hope winter could replace her as the main vocalist.
@@Max-my6rk these people doesn't even know what are they talking about
@@Max-my6rk but i think winter deserves to be the main
@@wintermy5885 your saying? can you elaborate? :')) 'cause for me, you're saying that winter is better than ningning? or??? elaborate please.
@@brokensoul_8408 in vocals.. i think but ningning also good but i love more winter voice she can sing a high notes
I hope they didn’t minimize the volume of Ningning’s mic, I’d love to hear her loud and powerful voice
이건 진짜 라이브 맞잖아.. 미친거이님 닝닝윈터카리나.?지젤도 랩 개쫄깃하네 우악악
Ningning slayed
스엠 엠알제거는 좀 믿고 들음
Actually when i first saw their debut teasers, my mental image of karina is that she’s someone who would try hard to act cute with such teeny tiny singing voice and talks in baby. but in reality she’s so matured and has this very thick velvety voice. she actually exceeded all expectations.
me too i’m so glad she’s not like that
And this why you should never assume
idk why u thought that she never gave off that vibe at all lmao
There's a difference between how she looks like and her personality, that's why she was incredibly popular even before debuting.
닝닝 고음 미쳤다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
00:48 윈터 닝닝 몰아치는 고음 극락
닝닝 너무 고음 시원하다
닝닝은 진짜 몇개월만 지나면 더더더 발전할듯 지금도 소름돋게 잘 하는데 어쩔수 없는 발음 차이가 있는거같음 (한국인과 외국인)ㅠㅠ 그치만 진짜 너무 잘해 막닝이..
Winter's voice sounds so confident when she hits the Highnote I really like her voice
2:10 KARINA ISNT EVEN A MAIN VOCALIST Jesus and she's 10x better live than MOST idols. Also did u notice, they do not have in an ear piece to hear themselves, and are singing over a loud backing track. I would absolutely sound like a dieing cat and I consider myself a decent singer. These girls deserve way more props for their raw talent
"10x better live than MOST idols" that's too much lol
Now, I understand why Ningning is the main vocalist. She is by far the most skilled. Winter is also good but she hasn't good sense of support.
@@juicebox7755 fun fact winter hight note hurt my ear
cos her voice is originally high
@@ningningharbinqueen4112 hater
why ain't anyone talking about vocal goddess Winter. her consistency until the end was amazing 😭😍
Karina is so stable.
왜 윈터최고라고만,, 닝닝도 고음 안정적에 개잘하는데ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 물론 겨울이 미쳤지만..
honestly amazed about how everyone still sounds a bit diff but perfect all tgthr but the way karina’s tone literally sounds the exact same as the original audio..she’s amazing
They really lowered Ningning's mic volume so that she won't overlap the AR haha nice try. My girl's still killing it.
...
yes cause they were shaken after ningning first chorus belting lol
이 노래가 라이브가 되는게 신기하다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Ningning is truly incredible!!!!!
This encore stage is the proof that what we heard until now was all pre-recorded. And now I'm even more mad with the company. Aespa are already top tier vocalist even if they are new in the industry. Why sm doesn't allow them to sing live? They train everyday to sing, let them sing sometimes please, their raw voices are amazing.
TOTALLY AGREE. they nailed it but why SM doesn’t allow them to sing live like this. live stage with pre-recorded vocal is perfect, i know, but it’s boring. and i guess we don’t need the 1000% perfect stage. all we need the real and powerful live stage
Exactly
@@hasyaqinthara6868 It's not just only Aespa but their fellow labelmates of SM Music and even to their future roofmates of the soon-to-be Lyfe Labels Family (existing SM Labels such as Mystic Story + Woollim, FNC, Blockberry, Kakao Labels and CJENM Labels because SM management is keen on having a multi-label structure like Hybe does in the upcoming years and a possible company change to Lyfe) as well are also caught in lipsync too. Every Kpop acts were caught in the act in lipsync, no one is safe in the first place.
@@hasyaqinthara6868 Exactly! I don't understand why but during this corona era, more and more agencies became obsessed with perfection. Even agencies whose groups were known to sing 90% of their stages live..
@@weareunitedasonefamily wait? What fnc? They did join sm merge?.+.
윈터 완벽..👍
So far, I saw some ppl somehow didn't appreciate Ningning abt her vocal as much as other group's main vocalists.
We all know there's always a reason why someone debuted as main vocalist and it shows in Ningning. Main vocalist in SM. Eventho somehow I feel her voice hadn't matured yet at first, she definitely grows better and better as time goes, I believe sooner or later, in the future she'll get that title "one of best female main vocalists"
Winter is main vocalist material wtff she’s so good
???? But she is the main vocal of aespa
@@joaopaes2198 no, she is lead vocal.
right she could be main vocalist in some other group. but you know it's sm, full of great vocalists
@lola dacutest sm vocals aren’t jokes
@lola dacutest stayc is full of vocals they are very stable and they do a lot of amazing high notes so i think it wouldn’t be the best group for her cause she wouldn’t shine a lot like she does with ning in aespa
0:51 가사 실수 라이브 인증ㅜㅜ♥♥
닝닝 귀여워큨큐큐ㅠ큐큐
0:49 never getting tired of listening this again and again😭.
Winter literally has everything, talent and beauty
they’re having fun here but you can hear exactly how their natural voices fit into the real thing. looking forward to more aespa❤️❤️
Ningning is the 4th gen vocal queen periodt
Karina sings better than most main vocalists Ive heard
The truth I want to hear her sing an entire vocal based song I love her tone so much and I’ve heard people say this already but she gives LeeHi vibes with the tone of her voice
Actually ningning is the main vocalist
@@ele5223 i think she is talking about other group main vocalist
I want karina to sing some more. Her voice is so stable and beautiful.
I can believe it
00:52 널 부ㅅ..앏아 줄게~
닝이줘 귀여워ㅠ
카와잉 ㅠ
This encore will be much better if SM didn't provide track with loud backtrack vocals on it.
I bet most of their performances has loud backtracks even if they sang it live. It will be overpowered by backtrack vocals.
Music core always has loud backtrack vocals on their encores
I think it’s musiccore not sm who makes that decision since sm artists have done 100% live encores on mcountdown, music bank and inkigayo
Wait for inkigayo. They will get win 100% and inki never use backtrack. So prepare your ears cuz it gonna be like in the haven.
It's not SM's fault
@@nafscho7489 music core always uses tracks with backtracks in encore wait if they win in mcountdown or inkigayo
와 후렴에서 귀 찢어지는 줄 알았다,,, 다들 성량 무슨일인데
걍 스엠이 요즘은 퍼포 중심으로 하고 왠만한 아이돌도 ar깔고 그 위에 부분부분 라이브하는데 어쭙잖게 노래 못해서 라이브 안한다 이러면서 깐 놈들 다 어디갔는지ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ,,, 가요대제전도 라이브였고 포에버도 라이브였는데 라이브한 적 없다 하면서 사실왜곡이나 하고ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ…
그리고 무조건 라이브에 집착하는 것도 진짜 이해가 안 감 쌩라이브만이 노래 실력이라고 생각해서 눈에 불을 키고 라이브라이브라이브 이러는 사람들…. 그냥 존나 사람 한명 보내버리고 싶어서 작정한 사람들 같음 지들딴엔 착한 말투로 말해보지만 심성 삐뚤어진 거 다 티남 으윽 쌩라이브만 소리내서 잘한다고 그게 잘하는 건지 진짜 이상한 거에 집착하는
이거지 ㄹㅇㅋㅋ
salty wkwk susah banget lo apresiasi karya aespa. padahal kalian dari korea, malah ngehujat rakyat mereka sendiri. karma be real
아 잘하는 건 알겠는데 눈막귀막하고 라이브했다고 좀 하지 맙시다 팬들이 라이브 부심을 하도 부려대니까 앵콜에서 라이브 얼마나 잘하는지 두고보려고 대중들이 눈 부릅뜨고 있는 거임 솔직히 무대에서 늘 립싱크하고 라이브 한번도 안 한 거 맞는데요 포에버 때 마이크에서 입 떼도 목소리 나오는 건 어떻게 해명하실 건가요? 립싱크 다 들통났는데요?
@@szxr1312 savage
really aespa are such queens, but ning ning is such a gem
0:54 닝닝이 성량 미쳤다 역시 메인보컬
3:17 this part without music is so weird lol
3:40 백구 함성발사
0:54 와 귀찢어지는줄알았네
닝닝 성량 어나더레벨;;;;
Wow the aespa girls don't need autotune, they sing beautifully
Considering that this video has a lot of views, proving that everyone is anticipating to see Aespa in their encore, nevertheless they never disappoints.
0:51 is crazy wth ningning it sounds edited ☠️ she is amazing they all slayed
The best vocalists in K-pop!!!!
let’s relax lol
@@tarynstake It's a reality another thing is that you're hurt Jsjsj Jsjs
Let's not
Pls 💀
Dont set them up
Winter is awesome gurl your voice speaks so muchh
SM소속 그룹들 중에 비주얼 담당들을 보면.. 솔직히 아 이사람은 육각형 멤버다 하는 생각은 안들었는데 (영웅재중 제외) 카리나 이친구는 육각형 멤버의 스멜이.... 왜 데뷔전에 관계자들이 무슨 포지션으로 데뷔할까 궁금해했다는거 이해됨 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
닝닝 윈터 미쳤다...
ningning VOCALS ARE OUT OF THIS WORLD
Tengo que decir que me quedo sorprendida con NINGNING no uso falsete, en el MV pense que lo hacia, pero literalmente canta la nota alta de cabeza y no le cuesta nada, domina un gran rango vocal es supremamente maravillosa su voz y puedo decir que para su voz esta muy bien practicada lo que se reduce a una buena tecnica vocal... Todas son talentosas se merecen los mejores exitos.
krplus.net/bidio/Yc9tq12gnoPcloo
Mv..
지민이 목소리도 진짜 독보적이야♥️ 개잘해
aespa members have such distinct voices. I feel like if they were trained in other company, it wouldn't be like this and people might be mesing with them right now.
They'll still be good cause they all have nice voice but won't be this good. That's why good training is really important even other idols that trained in SM sound good even when debuted in other agencies
윈터 존나 잘하네
Aaaa aespa, they never make mistakes in vocals, I'm multifandom. They rocked, there won't be anything to take it away :) Winter is beautiful as always, angel vocals. Ningning, what a wonderful vocal!! Giselle the rap impeccable, Karina looks great in costumes! Being in this fandom is wonderful! The girls are complete
Thank you so muchhh! This version is so clear ❤️
앵콜무대를 기다렸다고여~!! 닝닝이랑겨울이 고음 미쳤네
닝닝성량이 미쳤음..다른멤버들도 보컬실력더있지만 성량은 닝닝이가 더 타고난듯
Wow i love the way you filtered their voices, damn you did a great job with this compared to other channels that does this you outdo them!! keep it up.
aespa is really on the next level ✨
아니 닝닝 미친거아니야..???
So glad they got to do an encore and finally win. Their vocals are so clear here I was so excited to hear an uncut version of their singing.
닝닝 저음 개조아
와 대박… 윈터랑 닝닝 너무 잘해ㅠㅠ
Stop saying ning is not confident
Reason why her 2 highnote belts on the end is not as loud is because it looks like her mic is toned down same as Giselle
@love that's not falsetto is heady mix.
was amazed as how Ningning could blend almost perfectly with the backing track!
If it did not have the backing vocals they would sound much better (because they were a bit out of the timing)
Just noticed karina said MYs we love you. Instead of Naevis. Lol
Yeah so cute
Nævis crying after being sacrificed 🥲
And giselle calling aes lazy 😭😭😭😭
I like mys we love you more
I think the reason aespa never did full live singing, either it prerecorded or always backed up with loud backtrack was;
1. Every music shows or award shows i watched have been doing this to every idol and especially became a "natural" thing to do ever since the pandemic (except the encore stage like this maybe)and probably just because they want the show and the idols looks "perfect" in their performances but idk if this is the show's, the idols' or the company's decision
2. For savage i think the keep changing tune/key of the song and tiring choreography probably the main reason
They should saw their sunbaes like snsd, fx, shinee, etc, they sang live. I think, music show nowadays prioritize dance performance than balanced performance
I mean not really tbh Itzy sing live a lot.
@@alondraa.3522 technically itzy aren’t rookies anymore, I feel like a group like ive could be a better comparison since aespa and ive are both amazing
윈터가 최고다 ㄷㄷ
I thought it was falsetto at first but Ningning I think is using her head voice at 3:28 and 3:53, this MR remove makes it sound clearer.
It www falsetto
@@user-cv2vi5tu7k nope, its head voice
@@strawberrymoon412 its falsetto... see different first hn
What are y'all talking about? It's "Mixed Voice". You can clearly hear that she connected her head voice to her chest voice which is Impossible to do with Falsetto, In Falsetto there should be a cut.
I love Ningning, she's an as 💖
Dios mio, WINTER ❄
Que gran voz, mucho talento vocal.
Eso es lo que realmente debemos apreciar: Singers that *REALLY* can sing
ㅉㅉㅉㅉ 가 mr 이었어...? ㅠㅠ
가장 좋아하는 부분인데.. ㅉㅉㅉㅉ 특집으로 한번 해줬으면..
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ고음도 아니고 ㅉㅉㅉㅉ 라이브로 듣고 싶어하다니 특이한 분이시군요..
앙 내가해줄게
쯧쯧쯧쯧!
이거를 텍스트로 써놓으니까 너무 하찮아 보임ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Karina's tone remain the best 😍
Ningning winter
2:22 Winter's savage is soooo So cute, i can't take it !!
Really happy to see they singing. Sadly that nowdays it's hard to have a opportunity to sing live nowdays (even though idols are singers)
아니 이게 어떻게 데뷔한지 1년도 안된 아이돌 보컬이야..
진짜 연차 더 쌓이면 얼마나 더 잘해질거야.. 하.. 덕질의 참맛이다..