@@vc5831 'Shuhua is untalented' 🤡 Shuhua is extremely talented, have you even heard her beautiful voice or seen her stage presence that keeps improving each comeback?
Shuhua looks strong and confident, I'm so proud of her! Thank you camera man, you did her justice 💜 The girls are so bright and beautiful in these outfits, they are literally blooming.
that's why i dont blame Soyeon everytime shuhua gets few lines because she always make sure that if one member doesnt have many lines she'll give more savage dance part or will be the center in their performances. I think it's always balanced. So don't hate Soyeon. Soyeon's a real leader. ❤❤
@@mara_q9979 pretty sure she decides most of it (some is by the company) [so I've heard] [ soyeon said she wrote this song about/looking at/from shuhua so like >.< so cute!! ]
@@pandoodihimchi4451 I havent seen the interview but I've always felt that. :v Man, shuhua is eating up the vibe of this song. I always think this whenever I see them perform. I'm sure she also loves this song given that she performed even when her wrist got injured, that's some dedication right there.
@Thomas O'Bannon they can't probably? Their stage outfit are made so they can perform with.. long dress are hard for dances. + It's the same with hairstyle, it's hard to maintain them with the jumps they are doing ! ^^ It would be amazing but it's impossible :ccc
I love her intro so much because her first long note is on the word something like "frozen" and she doesnt vibrato it until the very end making it feel very cold and like frozen in time
I burst into tears since a huge amount of people praise Shuhua for this video. Hopefully it is not temporary due to the issue she got these days. I just wanna say every compliment she got is what she deserves. I believe she has been taking time to improve her skills to prove that she respects her career and her fans. I hope that everything she does will be paid off. Best wish for IDLE and Shuhua. Btw remember to s****m and collect vote. We have to get them a lot of trophies this comeback.
Imas Ayu Inggil Pangestuti with the amount of creative control these girls have over their own music, I highly doubt that they just do Shuhua like that. I’m sure Shuhua decides herself that she doesn’t want much lines. We should instead admire all other aspects that Shuhua thrives in like her stage presence, visuals and dance ability.
When I see the mv the first time, i didn't notice that she have 3sec of line, maybe it was because she have a lot of takes of her in the video,also she is the centre in some parts of the dance
@@ammarmunawwar2617 i have fhe same thought too. because soyeon one said that her voice is a mixture of minnie miyeon voice right? which why we cannot recognise the chorus. It looks like her voice.
It’s really not... it’s yuqi’s era. Not saying shuhua didn’t do good but it can be her era with such little lines. Yuqi really shines here we should give her the appreciation. Also yuqi has never gotten an era, please let’s give her this one
Shuhua got so lil lines but I think she got quite a lot of times at the center. Baby Shuhua, we'll support you til you're more confident with Korean language,
and now Miyeon always in the back, I mean couldve it been soyeon or minnie bc their lines are many miyeon is always in the back it’s irritating that i survived such comebacks with the goddess in the back
@@anjicrz I did not mean it to bash any other members i just wanted to prove that this comeback was fair to every members including shuhua because her screentime makes up for her lack of lines
it’s yuqi’s era. Not saying shuhua didn’t do good but it can be her era with such little lines. Everyone talks about shuhua in this era for the wrong reasons, and I don’t want her to live with that. Let’s PLEASE not give shuhua the era just because of the pity. She does shine, but Yuqi really shined when the song came out, we should give her the appreciation. With the hot topic about her hair, center time, screentime, it was obviously her era before everyone started complaining about shuhua’s lines. Sorry but that’s the truth. Also yuqi has never gotten an era, please let’s give her this one. Please, she deserves it
it's okay even though Shuhua didn't get enough lines. Fact about it is that you can't deny the fact that despite of having the shortest line she owned the stage!
they’re so different from each other! in so many group nowadays it’s hard to tell the members apart because they have similar singing tone but gidle is definitely not the case! so unique
I hafta agree shuhua really has come a long way. From unconfident rookie to this huge presence on stage. I think ppl won't complain anymore with her lack of lines, as she still catches our eyes even with very few lines.
@@leo-rs3cj fr, what is the point of this comment even? it's not about people complaining, it's literally about the mistreatment. no one deserves to get less than 10 seconds of lines at least in any title track, especially these foreign idols who've had it even worse than the korean trainees back in the days.
@@vg4025 is official, Shuhua sings 12 seconds of the song, she sings the last "hwaaa" in the bridge, just because she doesn't sings that much (maybe because her position is SUB VOCALIST) doesn't mean that she is mistreated lol
The cameraman did a really great job tho, they didn't record the other members while this member is singing but turn to the whole group, love the respect😊🥰
I think it’s yuqi’s era. She really shines and her hair is a hot topic. She really fits the song. Yuqi has never gotten an era so I think we should give her this one. She deserves it
I love the whole group and have my bias in the group but I tend to find I watch the other girls in past eras more than Shuhua. But HERE, Shuhua is nothing short of CAPTIVATING. She stands out so much in this performance. She looks completely at ease, happy, and gorgeous. Her dancing is INCREDIBLE. I'm so proud of her- this is her era!!!!
this live performance just like Hwaa ~ Shua ft. G Idle 😂😂 .. i love to see shua at center and killing part , this come back Shua showing her best dance skill
@@ginaalexopoulou8908 This may be true! Soojin and Soyeon's dress are too short I wonder why they don't give that dress to Yuqi, imma throw hands now to the stylist
All the dresses were pretty short, while the dresses beautiful you can tell they’re not meant for dancing. Maybe if they went for something longer with same patterns or vibe?
I think that the dress that yuqi is wearing made her look more fat when she is not and the balloon sleeve made her movement more difficult to do, so if they gave her another dress maybe she will look more beautiful and more confortable
![이분 사실 챌린저라고요..? 대머리 챔피언 장인, 김계란 장인초대석 [테스터훈]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/iPnqvGgtEuQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![[From. PLAVE] 노아 - Sugarcoat (NATTY Solo) (원곡 : KISS OF LIFE)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/F9CzzZfpOlI/mqdefault.jpg)
cameraman stans shuhua and we stan him
Periodt.
Top comment haha😊
yesss! I'm so happy to see him focous on her.
Cameraman promoting shuhua better then her company!
Yup
3:08 the amount of emotion shu puts on that one line!
SHUHUA NEVER DISAPPOINTS
IKR
THE HIGHLIGHT OF THIS PERFORMANCE
Definitely shines a lot this era!
Yesss ♥️
its the only one she has, she had to
도입부부터 AR 뚫고 나오는 성량...... 그런데 이 카메라 진짜 대박이네요ㅠㅠㅠ 멤버들 자기 파트 때 확실하게 찍어주고 단체안무 때 단체안무 찰떡같이 잡아주시고!!!
ㄹㅇ 캠진짜깔끔하다...
MR아닌가요..? 아니라면 죄송합니다..
ㅇㅈ 어딘 멤버 정수리 찍든데
@@innil117 아뇨! 여자아이들은 데뷔곡 빼고 다 라이브랍니다😊 AR깔고 라이브 하는것 같아용
@@user-jh9mo4jd6b 오 좋은 정보 감사해요!!
아니 카감님이 네버랜드급으로 진짜 잘찍어주셨는데 코디가 안티네 ㅜㅠ 띵곡인데 나중에 숨듣명으로 나오게 하지 말고 그냥 지금 띵곡해주게 코디님 좀 바꿔주시던가 해주세요 ㅠㅠ 오마갓 코디님 어디가셨어요..
Cameraman: okay shua has few lines lets give her the moment she deserves atleast. ❤️
And we ain’t complaining 😍
Y’all always bring up her lines talk about something more than just her lines
@@victorianichkhun8568 This comment isnt even complaining smh
Shuhua always got outstanding Line, she is icon from Gidle😍
😒
Soyeon with that hairstyle and that makeup is just a masterpiece. *chefs kiss*
Periodt
did not know it would hit me that hard xD
Ikr, she creates art and she IS art
look like akali =)))
Ikr, she's so prettyyyyy. This style really suit her
The amount of center Shuhua gets is a yes. Everyone shines in this comeback
but she's untalented
@@vc5831 if she is "untalented" then why did she debut?
@@vc5831 untalented but in the process of improving herself
This is what you called 'untalented'? Then what are you? How about me? Get some dictionary to improve your vocabulary.
@@vc5831 'Shuhua is untalented' 🤡 Shuhua is extremely talented, have you even heard her beautiful voice or seen her stage presence that keeps improving each comeback?
Shuhua looks very beautiful with that dress
Am i the only one who get surprised everytime Shuhua's in thumbnail?!
Shuhua always got cathcing line since debut, she is icon of Gidle song🔥
lol a fellow fudan/fujo ps:eyooo jiwon sunbae
VISUAL YEH SUSAN
Shuhua looks strong and confident, I'm so proud of her! Thank you camera man, you did her justice 💜
The girls are so bright and beautiful in these outfits, they are literally blooming.
good
Shuhua looks strong and confident w/ gidle members...
that's why i dont blame Soyeon everytime shuhua gets few lines because she always make sure that if one member doesnt have many lines she'll give more savage dance part or will be the center in their performances. I think it's always balanced. So don't hate Soyeon. Soyeon's a real leader. ❤❤
wait so Soyeon decides the line distribution. I'm new and still learning about them.
@@mara_q9979 yes.
@@mara_q9979 pretty sure she decides most of it (some is by the company) [so I've heard]
[ soyeon said she wrote this song about/looking at/from shuhua so like >.< so cute!! ]
@@pandoodihimchi4451 aww that’s so sweet 🥺
@@pandoodihimchi4451 I havent seen the interview but I've always felt that. :v Man, shuhua is eating up the vibe of this song. I always think this whenever I see them perform. I'm sure she also loves this song given that she performed even when her wrist got injured, that's some dedication right there.
뭐지? 너무 잘찍었는데????
부장님이 찍었나봄
저만 느낀게 아니였네요ㅠㅠ 너무 좋아요
Kbs는 제법 잘 찍어요 mbc같은데가 문제지...
Thank you cameraman for many shuhua’s screentime ;-;
The way Miyeon improved on stage it’s crazy, I really like her outfits and Shuhua’s btw
@Thomas O'Bannon they can't probably? Their stage outfit are made so they can perform with.. long dress are hard for dances. + It's the same with hairstyle, it's hard to maintain them with the jumps they are doing ! ^^
It would be amazing but it's impossible :ccc
Shuhua look like a princess and the dress is perfect for her
간간히 계속 슈슈 비춰주시길래 엔딩도 슈슈일거 같더라니 역시 ㅠㅠ
갑자기 알고리즘에 떠서 들어왔는데... 파트 적은 멤버 챙겨주시는 감독님의 섬세함ㅠ
Soyeon intro is very iconic honestly this era and comeback are so perfect and iconic very talented queens.
I love her intro so much because her first long note is on the word something like "frozen" and she doesnt vibrato it until the very end making it feel very cold and like frozen in time
@@judithkim4050 Yeah her voice is amazing, espacially her deper voice.
Shuhua's beauty is just next level. she has barely any lines and still captures the viewer.
trueeeeeeeeee
Trueeee
뮤직뱅크가 뮤직뱅크하네 이번 무대 진짜 잘찍음
I burst into tears since a huge amount of people praise Shuhua for this video. Hopefully it is not temporary due to the issue she got these days. I just wanna say every compliment she got is what she deserves. I believe she has been taking time to improve her skills to prove that she respects her career and her fans. I hope that everything she does will be paid off. Best wish for IDLE and Shuhua.
Btw remember to s****m and collect vote. We have to get them a lot of trophies this comeback.
Same
What happen?
what happened????
omg what
Nothing special, just about the line distribution makes her being famous outside the fandom!!
This is Yeh Shuhua's world, we're just living in it
Sadly cube turns her into G-iddle back dancer with that amount of line :'(
Imas Ayu Inggil Pangestuti with the amount of creative control these girls have over their own music, I highly doubt that they just do Shuhua like that. I’m sure Shuhua decides herself that she doesn’t want much lines. We should instead admire all other aspects that Shuhua thrives in like her stage presence, visuals and dance ability.
@@imasayuinggilpangestuti9607 Shuhua don't need those lines. Girl is slaying even though we only hear her in choruses.
@@koa_al NO FR I DONT STAN GIDLE BUT SHE CAUGHT MY EYE THE MOST LMAO
@@enqueque that's the power my dear Shuhua holds. Anywayy, stan (G)I-DLE 😌✊
That husky deep tone of Shu is really catchy.
Finally someone noticed how beautiful and husky her voice is!
THIS IS SHUHUA’S STAGE!!! SHE SHINED
the best ending fairy ever
When KBS cameraman promotes Shuhua better than CUBE:
Cube actually promktes shuhua pretty good but could do better
When I see the mv the first time, i didn't notice that she have 3sec of line, maybe it was because she have a lot of takes of her in the video,also she is the centre in some parts of the dance
@@juancampos2752 it seems that the chourses are all hers.. the members just harmonise at the back.. so she definitely has more than 4 sec
Nice one
@@ammarmunawwar2617 i have fhe same thought too. because soyeon one said that her voice is a mixture of minnie miyeon voice right? which why we cannot recognise the chorus. It looks like her voice.
The flower concept is so pretty and SHUHUA in that thumbnail ending fairy queen.
뭔가 아이들은 다른 걸그룹처럼 음역대가 무리하게 높지 않아서 좋음 특히 민니 몽환이랑 우기 저음은 되게 특색있는 보컬이라고 생각하는데 곡이 그걸 너무 잘 살리고 보컬도 곡을 너무 잘 살리고.. 진짜 전소연 최고된다..
Shuhua being the thumbnail is everything.
THE VOCAL OF THIS GROUP IS ON ANOTHER LEVEL.
Ending fairy Shuhua, yes I love it!
yes we lovee itt
저만 카메라가 정말 잘 잡았다고 생각헌 고 아니네여 와아아....중간에 보라빛 불이 나는 것도 진짜 대박이에요. 앞으로 더 많이 찍어주세요!!
This stage is PERFECT. Shuhua looks stunning and the fact that they are all singing live and dancing that amazing choreo makes my heart warm
Shuhua ending fairy always on top😫
Soyeon's and Soojin's dresses are uncomfortably short but I love the styling so much T^T
the idol world. what else is new :((( I think (g)i-dle is particularly unlucky with that because they are all pretty short lol
But they rockin,😍
@@judithkim4050 i think Shuhua, Minnie and Yuqi are the best here
Are those dresses, or just shirts!? I don't mind short, but they should not be 'featuring' their safety shorts!
R LM I mean arguably it’s perfect, it creates the same effect with a feature that Kpop stans hace learned to ignore!
연말에 또 마마할거아녀 그때 카메라맨 이분으로 하는게..
케이비에스든뭐든 카메라만 잘들면되는사람;;;; ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ엠칸줄앙았네
Shuhua visual queen
OMG SHUSHU ENDING FAIRY!!! She really shines in this era ^ ^
Shuhua wow Shuahining ;;;;;; so pretty
OMG SHUHUA PLEASE-
I BEG YOU DONT MAKE ME FALL IN LOVE WITH YOU EVERYTIME I SEE YOU.. PLEASEE
Wow, Shuhua looks stunning. Cameraman definitely loves her.
Shuhua's improvement is AMAZING. Even though she has little lines, she literally caught my eye the whole time. her aura is amazing
right?!?!
OMFG Shuhua ate the performance today ❤️
이 썸넬을 어떻게 지나쳐.. 개이쁘다 진짜
shuhua you're so charming
Shuhua's outfit shines the most to me *chef kiss*
Agree!
THIS IS *SHUHWAA* ERA NO ONE CAN'T TELL ME OTHERWISE🔥
It’s really not... it’s yuqi’s era. Not saying shuhua didn’t do good but it can be her era with such little lines. Yuqi really shines here we should give her the appreciation. Also yuqi has never gotten an era, please let’s give her this one
It's Shuhua stage🔥🔥❤
Shuhua visual is out of the world
No one can beat ending fairy Shuhua. Her visuals are unreal
Shuhua is indeed the modern Snow White
Yeh Snow ❄️
susan white
Dreamy visual shuhua
I seriously cant get over this performance
Rebecca ❤️❤️
Soojin slayed this style
Shuhua got so lil lines but I think she got quite a lot of times at the center.
Baby Shuhua, we'll support you til you're more confident with Korean language,
Shuhua in the thumbnail is beautiful she needs more recognization
Everyone is talking about her. QUEEN
In the East she is known as Shuhua,
In the West she is Known as Susan,
In the fantasy world , she is known as Snow-White
Man, I am proud of Shuhua. Look at her stage presence, and her facial expressions are on point. Her dancing has improved so much.
I noticed that in the whole of the choreography shuhua never really moved to the back she was almost always at the front
To compensate for her 3 second line
and now Miyeon always in the back, I mean couldve it been soyeon or minnie bc their lines are many miyeon is always in the back it’s irritating that i survived such comebacks with the goddess in the back
@@anjicrz I did not mean it to bash any other members i just wanted to prove that this comeback was fair to every members including shuhua because her screentime makes up for her lack of lines
@@catyanne8351 to realize she has a whole chorus hmm
@@d.b20028 I don’t think there is actually a reason to justify this poor line distribution she deserves way better. But that’s just my opinion.
VISUAL SHUHUA WORLD DOMINATION!!!! Breathe if you agree
*takes a deep breath*
Omg i can’t breathe
Yes!
...
*inhales*
Shuhua is amazing!!!
Shuhua as opening >> I'm in
I think this comeback is Shuhua’s era cuz everyone is talking about her
I’m so happy
Yess that's true tho🙊
Soojin too.
it’s yuqi’s era. Not saying shuhua didn’t do good but it can be her era with such little lines. Everyone talks about shuhua in this era for the wrong reasons, and I don’t want her to live with that. Let’s PLEASE not give shuhua the era just because of the pity. She does shine, but Yuqi really shined when the song came out, we should give her the appreciation. With the hot topic about her hair, center time, screentime, it was obviously her era before everyone started complaining about shuhua’s lines. Sorry but that’s the truth. Also yuqi has never gotten an era, please let’s give her this one. Please, she deserves it
Okay now.. It's all G-IDLE members era 😍 they all work hard 💕
@@iwatchyoutube3511 I agree. Shuhua didn't get any lines basically. For me it's Yuqi's and Soojin's era.
Shuhua she was pretty
very nice
ikrrr
Is*
Shuhua so pretty, thank you cameraman for giving her more screen time❤️
She's not the Goddess of rap only, she's the Goddess of vocals and everything.
she is Soyeon
it's okay even though Shuhua didn't get enough lines. Fact about it is that you can't deny the fact that despite of having the shortest line she owned the stage!
For me, They have the best vocal colors in kpop.
they’re so different from each other! in so many group nowadays it’s hard to tell the members apart because they have similar singing tone but gidle is definitely not the case! so unique
@@Anna-vl1ib CLC also has distinct vocal colors. CUBE groups are really something else
yesss I can tell it right away which part is whom voice
@@phillipdeleon9506 cube artist is unique
meanwhile: cube being devil.
Blackpink n Gidle have really unique vocal
Shuhua's visual is on fire
Shuhua so pretty wtf
MIYEON and MINNIE vocals queens.
dont forget Yuqi and Soojin
@@AF-sh1qk no I don't
QUEENS😍
Shuhua dress really go well with her skin colour...she is shining
Soyeon is a gorgeous woman, she looks so delicate and fierce
Shuhua and Minnie’s outfits are so pretty 🤩
I hafta agree shuhua really has come a long way. From unconfident rookie to this huge presence on stage. I think ppl won't complain anymore with her lack of lines, as she still catches our eyes even with very few lines.
That doesn't mean that it's right to give her 2 seconds of a song
@@leo-rs3cj she literally has good amount of lines, stop complaining for once omg, she literally has the highlight of the song 😭
@@leo-rs3cj fr, what is the point of this comment even? it's not about people complaining, it's literally about the mistreatment. no one deserves to get less than 10 seconds of lines at least in any title track, especially these foreign idols who've had it even worse than the korean trainees back in the days.
@@vg4025 is official, Shuhua sings 12 seconds of the song, she sings the last "hwaaa" in the bridge, just because she doesn't sings that much (maybe because her position is SUB VOCALIST) doesn't mean that she is mistreated lol
She is amazing💕
Thank you Music Bank for "SHUHUA" airtime 3:05 ~ 3:10 and 3:22 💗
I wait 'HWAA' every day every night ~💓
And the begging of this clip! Shuhua cheer up!!
shes so beautifulllllll i cannot
OMG my baby 😇
Shuhua ending fairy really hit my heart😫
Latata
miyeon is a literal goddess.
Shuhua is shininggggg😍
Yuqi Looks alot like Disney Mulan shes so pretty even her voice is a bit deep And Wow Soyeon i love that hairstyle and your outfit Go Leader Soyeon!
lip sing queens gidle and aespa
@@vc5831 gidle and aespa are real queens, stop crying😌
@@vc5831 (G)I-DLE and Aespa QUEEN OF VOCALS
A bit deep? Like her is DEEP deep, not a bit haha
The cameraman did a really great job tho, they didn't record the other members while this member is singing but turn to the whole group, love the respect😊🥰
the styling is so beautiful! i love miyeon and shuhua’s on them
The cameraman love shuhua Like me
no one talking about how shuhua dress was caught by minnie’s shoe at 0:23
I just noticed that wow
Its just laying on top of her shoes. I dont get why that would be something to point out
Tbh nothing big lol tf🤣
@@raygin6581 nah it isn’t something big I was just amused at how coincidental that was
Cameraman 🤝 being in love with Shuhua 😂
shuhua beautiful i love you
Shuhua is amazing 😍
Soojin Soyeon is so beautiful. (G)I-DLE is so beautiful
That's how YehButterfly's visual is used.
Shuhua❤️❤️❤️
Shuhua's visual omg i love you girls
I feel like this comeback is from Shuhua and Soojin.
They turn out a lot, really this is their era.
I think it’s yuqi’s era. She really shines and her hair is a hot topic. She really fits the song. Yuqi has never gotten an era so I think we should give her this one. She deserves it
@@iwatchyoutube3511 yeah she really fits this comeback, i think you're right.
SHUHUA❤
I love the whole group and have my bias in the group but I tend to find I watch the other girls in past eras more than Shuhua. But HERE, Shuhua is nothing short of CAPTIVATING. She stands out so much in this performance. She looks completely at ease, happy, and gorgeous. Her dancing is INCREDIBLE. I'm so proud of her- this is her era!!!!
Shuhua’s so beautiful ㅠㅠ
I cant leave without talking about Shuhua beauty in flower ver, all of them shine in this song
Y E S!!
really need Miyeon in a kdrama!
On 19th of January will be haired her webdrama on you tube it's called replay, if I'm not wrong
this live performance just like Hwaa ~ Shua ft. G Idle 😂😂 ..
i love to see shua at center and killing part , this come back Shua showing her best dance skill
이때 본방보면서 카메라 무빙 너무 좋아서 놀랐는데 엔딩 슈화라뇨..너무 좋잖아요..
I was expecting to see Yuqi's dress in mv, but maybe she wasn't comfortable on it? Anyways they always slay!!
yess,that truee🙂😭😭😭
Given what Soojin is wearing, unfortunately, I doubt CUBE cares about their idols being comfortable
@@ginaalexopoulou8908 This may be true! Soojin and Soyeon's dress are too short I wonder why they don't give that dress to Yuqi, imma throw hands now to the stylist
All the dresses were pretty short, while the dresses beautiful you can tell they’re not meant for dancing. Maybe if they went for something longer with same patterns or vibe?
I think that the dress that yuqi is wearing made her look more fat when she is not and the balloon sleeve made her movement more difficult to do, so if they gave her another dress maybe she will look more beautiful and more confortable
Shuhua is beautiful 💓
Shuhua is so beautiful😍💕💕💕
I love shuhua ending fairy