I think the teaser is explain their position of the group. Ningning is singing so she is the Main Vocalist, Giselle is doing rap so she is Main Rapper, Karina dancing so she is Main Dancer, meanwhile Winter is the Main Visual so SM only show us her amazing visual in the teaser
카리나 진짜 신기하게 이쁘다....어디서도 못 본 독특한 페이스;; 비슷하게 생긴상 연예계에서도 못본 것 같음. 고양이상은 또 아니고 뱀상이라 그러던데 진짜 맞는말ㅋㅋ 팔다리 쭉쭉길고 비율 좋아서 춤출 때 보는 맛도 있음..첨에 스엠상 아니길래 실망했는데 미안하다 사과할게ㅠ너네가 짱먹어 앞으로ㅜ 카리나가 2020년대 스엠상이다!!
언론에 에스파 오르내릴 때도 관심 없었는데 무대 한 번 보고나서 나도 모르게 에스파 무대 뜨면 다 챙겨보는 중... 그리고 카리나도 셀카 떴을 땐 예쁜 줄 몰랐는데 무대 보고 너무 예뻐서... 왜 셀카보다 방송국 카메라가 더 예쁨? 윈터는 스엠정석상이고 결정적으로 데뷔곡치고 노래 넘 잘뽑음 잘될듯
@@JD__0 you have to spend money to make money. it’s an investment but not a risky one seeing how just being from SM is a good enough marketing technique for new groups. if they were from a smaller company, i don’t think they’d be doing particularly well or stand out. they’re beautiful and worked hard to cultivate skills but if it weren’t for the whole AI debates and being from SM, I wonder if they’d be getting this much attention. the music doesn’t do much. sounds generic. can’t wait for the girls to actually have a direct hand in the music
@@kyleensing4411 yes they are lipsynching and it's pre-recorded BUT IT'S THEIR DEBUT STILL we can wait for other performances for sure they will sing live. Also, SM vocal training is superb so for sure their vocals are marvelous.
Guide to aespas' dictionary: MY - our fandom name SYNK - the connection between the members and the aes (an app) REKALL - the time the members spend with the aes FLAT - the place where the members could co-exist with their aes NAVI - guide/system that connects the girls and aes KWANGYA - the place where the aes live BLACK MAMBA - the virus or villain that disconnect the connection between members and ae You will not be able to understand the meaning of the song Black mamba without knowing these words
WINTER IS SO GLOWING. KARINA HAS HIGH CONFIDENCE. GISELLE’S VOCAL IS INSANE. NING NING PITCH IS COOL!!!!!!!!!! BEST ROOKIE!! I LOVE THEM SOOOO MUCH. SM YOU NAILED IT!!!!
특히 1절 닝닝파트.. 지젤 널 유혹해 삼킨건 어쩌구 반박 느리게 잡고.. 아야아야아ㅏ 부분은 카메라도 같이 해드벵잉하고.. 2절 지젤 거울 손동작 안무 제대로 잡지도 않고.. 바로 다음 닝닝 대각선 대형 다 겹치게 잡고 솔직히 음방 카감이면서 이정도도 못찍으면 어쩌잔거임..;;;;
가사가 예언이네... "I'm addicted 끊임없이 말을 걸어주는 나의 에스파 이런 교감, 너의 존잰 날 다른 차원으로 이끌었지" 유영진이 내가 이렇게 될줄 알았던 거네... 날 유혹해 삼킨 건 블랙맘바가 맞아... 계속 듣고 있어... 돈 쓸 준비해야겠다...이제부터 내 모든 액션이 어린 너네들의 힘을 키울 거야...
Winter looks like Winter, Ningning looks like Ningning, Karina looks like Karina and Giselle looks like Giselle - They are all ORIGINALS and will not be comparable!
people always compare at the beginning with things they know. I do too. But after a while when the girls are better known and have their own profile those comparisons will fade. I can't even remember who the single RV members were compared to at their debut!
I started recognizing them because of simmilarities to other idols. It's easier for me. Giselle looks alike Chaeryeong from ITZY (simmilar nose and lips), Winter looks alike Lia from ITZY (simmilar lips and eyes shape), Giselle looks alike Jennie from BP (both have baby faces and more round face shape), Karina reminds me of Yeji from ITZY (Simmilar face shape). It's not something wrong. It's normal to say "Hey, this person looks like one popular idol" or something like this. They are original etc. But it's normal people has simmilar face features, especially in Korea where they have their own standards and idols have to fit these standards
SM would killing us with Karina’s confidence , Winter’s beautiful face , Giselle’s deep voice and attractive aura , Ningning powerful vocals and cutest
stage presence =/= looking pretty and knowing how to stare at cameras. yall havent even seen these girls with a live audience yet to tell if they have stage presence or not
@@trishamitzellsagun6309 she's my bias too. i'm sure things gonna change soon and people will fall for her charm. i was quite sad that she didn't rap in black mamba but i am cheering for future songs.
of all girl groups that debuted this year, the one that shone the most was AESPA. music, videos, vocals, talent, dancing, visuals, rap is the complete package. MY MYNE , My bias Ningning & Winter
@@vanillaraven2618 Check ITZY's vocals in Be In Love and Surf, they're also vocally powerful. With AESPA they don't have complex choreo yet and I think they're still nervous with dancing so I can't give any material yet
People, calm down, usually all SM artists, no matter if they are seniors, use pre-recorded vocals for the first performances, so they can show of the dance and expressions, usually the second week is where they start singing live. This has always happened 🤷♀️
it happens to literally all idols, they prerecorded the stage on the first performance or even on the whole first week promotion. people tend to misunderstand this:(
Ok but now I understand why Karina is the center, she is not only gorgeous but also insanely outstanding when it comes to dancing/performing. I think I have found my bias
No wonder why SM didn’t show us Winters voice during them teasers. They wanna shock us with that angelic voice.
Exactly my thoughts
I think the teaser is explain their position of the group. Ningning is singing so she is the Main Vocalist, Giselle is doing rap so she is Main Rapper, Karina dancing so she is Main Dancer, meanwhile Winter is the Main Visual so SM only show us her amazing visual in the teaser
@@reireichii7912 winter will be the most talented (stongest vocal and dance) visual gg in SM.
@@zerohero109 In kpop
I’m sure she can sing but all I was hearing was the backtracking on all of them. Music & vocals were way too consistently stable throughout.
카리나 진짜 신기하게 이쁘다....어디서도 못 본 독특한 페이스;; 비슷하게 생긴상 연예계에서도 못본 것 같음. 고양이상은 또 아니고 뱀상이라 그러던데 진짜 맞는말ㅋㅋ 팔다리 쭉쭉길고 비율 좋아서 춤출 때 보는 맛도 있음..첨에 스엠상 아니길래 실망했는데 미안하다 사과할게ㅠ너네가 짱먹어 앞으로ㅜ 카리나가 2020년대 스엠상이다!!
@@williamlee2948 엥 전혀ㅋㅋㅋ그 사람들은 다 만든거고 카리나는 저 메추리 얼굴형 자체가 자연인데
@@user-ii5dq1lu9f 그 사람들이 다 만들었다는 근거는?
@@williamlee2948 강남가서 카리나같은 사람본적있어?신기하당,,,,카리나는 얼굴도 그렇지만 분위기가 뭔가 연예인!!!하는 느낌,,,,,
약간 세련된 배우느낌도 남
방구석에서 나오세요..
언론에 에스파 오르내릴 때도 관심 없었는데 무대 한 번 보고나서 나도 모르게 에스파 무대 뜨면 다 챙겨보는 중... 그리고 카리나도 셀카 떴을 땐 예쁜 줄 몰랐는데 무대 보고 너무 예뻐서... 왜 셀카보다 방송국 카메라가 더 예쁨? 윈터는 스엠정석상이고 결정적으로 데뷔곡치고 노래 넘 잘뽑음 잘될듯
와 딱 요즘의 저…
블랙맘바는 진짜.. 안보려고해도 보게되는 매력이 있음 에스파가 나오기 전까지 이런컨셉 누가 시도할 수 있었을까..? 자본도 많이 필요한데 굉장히 실험적임.. 지금은 광야가 뒷전이긴하지만 나중에 상황과 여건이 된다면 블맘같은 좋은노래로 또 나와주면 좋겠댜..
can’t believe they’re rookies, their vocals are seriously on another level and their stage presence is no joke
they have audience there?
@@bren3014 i think no. I'm so sad bcs this is they hot debut but... 🥺
They are rookies..
They are so good!! But I'm kinda sad because it's pretty obvious that the vocals are playback :(
you talk about vocals as if you can hear them sing
kbs music : how much money you like to spend on aespa debut stage?
sment : yes
sm: just give them all out budget, they’re perfect anyways
No wonder that SM has a debt on this quarter 😅
@@JD__0 not this quarter actually the last quarter,
@@JD__0 you have to spend money to make money. it’s an investment but not a risky one seeing how just being from SM is a good enough marketing technique for new groups. if they were from a smaller company, i don’t think they’d be doing particularly well or stand out. they’re beautiful and worked hard to cultivate skills but if it weren’t for the whole AI debates and being from SM, I wonder if they’d be getting this much attention. the music doesn’t do much. sounds generic. can’t wait for the girls to actually have a direct hand in the music
don't take this comment too serious guys because i stan aespa too hehe~ lets support the girls~
여윽시 대기업...
대중적인 노래보다 소속사랑 그룹 성격나타나기에 딱 좋은노래ㅡ들고 나왔네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
무대연출이나 라이브 안무 전부다 역시 대기업답다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ완벽함
대기업은 다르군
애들이 잘하긴 잘함 비교 불가임
대기업중 한곳의 9인 걸그룹은 왜그럴까요 돈도 많은데...
@@user-vx6kq2yu9j ??? 그쪽 이야기는 그쪽 영상가서...
@@user-ln3cc8jf1v 뭐래ㅡ대기업 얘긴뎈ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
0:33 노래 한소절 시작도 안했는데 내 심장을 뒤흔든
*SM'S VISUALS, VOCALS AND TALENT NEVER DISAPPOINTS*
Exactly
Dont forget lipsync
@@kyleensing4411 lol are you even for real questioning SM's vocal training?
@@kyleensing4411 yes they are lipsynching and it's pre-recorded BUT IT'S THEIR DEBUT STILL we can wait for other performances for sure they will sing live. Also, SM vocal training is superb so for sure their vocals are marvelous.
TRUE
Gissele wasnt even wearing that much make up and she still looks gorgeous
언니들 솔직히 말해봐 미래에서 돌아왔지!! 어쩜 신인티가 하나도 안날수가 있냐구ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 짱스파 최고야 진짜
와 윈터랑 카리나 진짜 무지 이쁘네 사진보다 비디오가 헐씬 이쁘네.... 진짜 온미녀 냉미녀 스카일 너무 이쁨
예 ... 참
@@dimensionteas4785 ㅉㅉ
Guide to aespas' dictionary:
MY - our fandom name
SYNK - the connection between the members and the aes (an app)
REKALL - the time the members spend with the aes
FLAT - the place where the members could co-exist with their aes
NAVI - guide/system that connects the girls and aes
KWANGYA - the place where the aes live
BLACK MAMBA - the virus or villain that disconnect the connection between members and ae
You will not be able to understand the meaning of the song Black mamba without knowing these words
Thank you
Thank u❤❤
Thanks.
thanks!
So how would you pronounce the group’s name?
WINTER IS SO GLOWING. KARINA HAS HIGH CONFIDENCE. GISELLE’S VOCAL IS INSANE. NING NING PITCH IS COOL!!!!!!!!!!
BEST ROOKIE!! I LOVE THEM SOOOO MUCH. SM YOU NAILED IT!!!!
Sorry but it was prerecorded
@@Random-rv3us yeah, it s the first week, so
In SM we trust. They never failed to impress us.
I do GISELLE & WINTER makeup tutorial on my channel. Check it out !
@@Random-rv3us normally all idols do prerecord for 1st first week cause they are focusing on the dance
I love giselle voice the most but all good.hehe sry
차암..스엠이 실력하나는 딴소리 안나오게 잘 뽑는단 말이지...
excuse me miss Giselle ,it's illegal to be THAT pretty.
Thats hot
Really pretty 朱咪咪
right?? smh giselle calm down now i have to repeat ur fancam coz ur blinding me :D
@@pinkyhahah LMAOOOOO NICE HAAHHA
@@kissme8705 she mentioned it by paris hilton 😂😂😂
their outfits look like they'll going to attend awards show.
에스파 최고 이게 데뷔무대라니
3:26 와 깜짝 놀랐다 윈터..? 엄청 예쁘네 장난없다...
Look at how Karina stares at NingNing 2:53 -- that's so precious, look at her being proud of her maknae 🥺💖
It's so cute 🥺
How did you noticed that?That is so cute 😆😆
girl i was going to tell that too.. they're so cute. karina is an amazing leader.
That’s cuteee
Ningning is really all that guys. Her vocals are no joke, visuals on point, and her charisma off the charts. Queens only!
Indeed
ningning world domination
YES
YESSSS
she looks like Jennie
아 난 이때의 겜캐릭터 컨셉이 좋은데 스파이시랑 드라마때부터 뭔가 애매해지고있음
윈터 진짜예쁘다... 음색도좋고ㅠ
The song: 💀🐍🌚🌪🖤☠️⚡️
The stage and outfits: 😙🧚♀️💅🏻🦄🌸✨
🥺🔫
I totally agree!
When Karina sang the "black mamba" part there her voice changes from soft to savage
where?? timestamp please
@@ishityle i think 2:12
카리나겁나이쁘다싶다가도
윈터는머리가너무잘어울려서 자꾸눈이감ㅋㅋㅋ ㅠ 매력오져
카리나 성형빨이라 ㅇㅇㄹ이랑 처지비슷한듯
@@user-bk5pt5oz5t 조까세요저도한국여잔데요 카리나좋아함~
@@user-ew7ni8gx9x 성형빨인거 안물어봤음 딴데가서달으셈
@@user-ew7ni8gx9x 도대체 뭔 어디를 성형했냐고 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ ㅜㅜ
님은 성형하면 카리나의 반이라도 될 수 있나요ㅋㅋ 이런애들이 트위터가서 카리나대신 나 데뷔시켜라~ 이러고있을듯 ㅋㅋ
근데 에스엠 여기도 그러고 엔시티에서도 그러고 광야에서 만난다구하넴..
제발... 만나지마.......
엑소도그럴걸..?ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
수만이가 에셈유니버스 다이어져있고 어쩌고 했으니까 다 이어질듯;; 괜히 초능력 컨셉이 아닌거같아...
수만씨 광야에 진심임
영어자막 켜면 GWANGYA 이렇게 써져있음 번역도 안하고....ㅋㅋ
이육사 시에 먼훗날 백마타고 오는 초인이 있다는 그 광야에서 컨셉 따온거같은 느낌인데
여기 걸그룹 귀현이라고 해도 이상하지 않을 듯.. 수만씨 이젠 알겠네요
Don't sleep on Ningning guys, she's there slaying the stage with her amazing vocal and powerful dance. Plus, look at that stunning visual.
Her visual & her voice is so unique. It is something new for kpop world
I do GISELLE & WINTER makeup tutorial on my channel. Check it out !
SM: debuts aespa with girl crush concept
Also SM: gives aespa fairy-like outfits
Is it girl crush? Some said this is futuristic concept like f(x) electric shock
@@dhe5655 its a mix
Lol
its not really girl crush
I wouldn't dare call aespa as a girl crush concept bcs we cannot classify sm's group into only one concept bcs they r too diverse😂🥰
Why no one talks about Giselle? She's very charismatic and her visuality is impressive, a goddess ♡
Yes she is so pretty and charismatic 😍
Yeeeeaaaahhhh
Yeeeeeees
SHE IS MY BIAAASSSSS 💕💕💕💕
im scared that giselle will become the 'jisoo' of the group :(
와 정말 데뷔 무대라는 것이 믿기지 않을 만큼 실력도 최상에 여유로운 모습... 너무 존경스럽네요. 연습에서 나오는 자신감이겠지요?
에스파 덕분에 저도 열심히 살아야겠다는 생각이 드네요
The second chorus' deep *BLACK MAMBA* is what turned my stairs into an elevator.
The choreo looks deep cool bro!!
I do GISELLE & WINTER makeup tutorial on my channel. Check it out !
Don't understand the physics of that but yes
@@r10t49 😂
thats killing part
wait what lmao
와 지금이랑 많이 다르네 카메라 마사지 대박
멤버들도 멤버들인데... 무대가 너무 예쁘다...
Karina's Beauty is unreal
Karina is more beautiful in less make up
Her face is so small
@@zahwaezas5100 She's like mannequin
@@me_irah.1111 agree!!!
It didn’t look like a debut! as expected from an SM group!
Always expect unexpected from SM artist
윈터음색 이개쁨.. 로제랑 잘어울릴 듯
@@sseon7 잘 어울릴것 같다고 했지 뭘 비볐냐ㅋㅋㅋㅋ그럼 이옷이랑 저옷이랑 어울리는데 입어봐 그러면 그것도 비비는거임?ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
그 컬러 발음이 너무 좋아
로제랑 잘어울리진 않지만 음색 타팬이 봐도 정말 이쁘네요! 음색이 시원하고
뭐가 어울린다는거지? 무리수좀 두지마라
윈터는 윈터고 로제는 로제지
쓸데없이 거론을 하노
@@ashleykim135 개인 의견말하는데 쓸데없이 시비를 거노
카메라 무빙 진짜 xx.... 어떻게 실직 안하고 계속 일하지.. 안무 포인트를 전혀 못잡네
ㅇㅈ 진심답답
다른 카메라 수준들이 높아서 그렇지 저정도면 그나마 봐줄만 한거에요ㅠ 해외 한류콘서트 같은 곳은 저기랑 비교가 안될 정도로 규모 큰 대형이었는데도 노래하고 있는 사람 얼굴'만' 찍더라구요.... 동선 춤 하나도 안보이게ㅠ
그래도 이정도면 괜찮은편....더 심한거 너무 많아
KBS 뮤뱅이 원래 그럼
특히 1절 닝닝파트.. 지젤 널 유혹해 삼킨건 어쩌구 반박 느리게 잡고.. 아야아야아ㅏ 부분은 카메라도 같이 해드벵잉하고.. 2절 지젤 거울 손동작 안무 제대로 잡지도 않고.. 바로 다음 닝닝 대각선 대형 다 겹치게 잡고 솔직히 음방 카감이면서 이정도도 못찍으면 어쩌잔거임..;;;;
Winter is going to be an absolute Legend.
Yes. I agree! My bias! I always choose the best as my bias 😁😁😁
Trueee
@@eyebrowstj omg i always found you too on every wendy's content/video..
And waw winter is your bias! I'm happy cause i found wendy winter stan haha
True
omg yes. Stan the vocal queens of SM
I feel like Karina does subtle smiles towards her members a lot during the dance like 2:53 here to NingNing. I think it’s so sweet
Aww Leader Karina❤️❤️
🥺🥺
Leader Karina :')
I was looking if someone else commented about it too
LEADER KARINA 😭💕
다른 걸 다 떠나서 무대랑 노래만 봤을땐 나름 좋은데..? 신인인데 신인티 하나도 안 나고 노래도 괜찮은 거 같음
뜰거같냐?
다 괜찮은데 데뷔 전부터 카리나 인성문제때문에 욕먹구있조...
@@v_v1915 애초에 에셈 소속이고 6년만에 나온 신인 걸그룹 + 병크에 각종 논란 이렇게 안고가는데 화제성은 보장되어있지 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@v_v1915 ㅇㅇ ㅈㄴ 뜰거같음
@@v_v1915 니 인생보단 뜰거니까 걱정 ㄴㄴ
가사가 예언이네...
"I'm addicted 끊임없이 말을 걸어주는 나의 에스파 이런 교감, 너의 존잰 날 다른 차원으로 이끌었지"
유영진이 내가 이렇게 될줄 알았던 거네...
날 유혹해 삼킨 건 블랙맘바가 맞아... 계속 듣고 있어... 돈 쓸 준비해야겠다...이제부터 내 모든 액션이 어린 너네들의 힘을 키울 거야...
NING NING's ending was perfect!! Shine our main vocal maknae!
Winter looks like Winter, Ningning looks like Ningning, Karina looks like Karina and Giselle looks like Giselle - They are all ORIGINALS and will not be comparable!
people always compare at the beginning with things they know. I do too. But after a while when the girls are better known and have their own profile those comparisons will fade. I can't even remember who the single RV members were compared to at their debut!
They arent so original. ...
Idk Ning Ning kinda look like Jennie from BP
I started recognizing them because of simmilarities to other idols. It's easier for me. Giselle looks alike Chaeryeong from ITZY (simmilar nose and lips), Winter looks alike Lia from ITZY (simmilar lips and eyes shape), Giselle looks alike Jennie from BP (both have baby faces and more round face shape), Karina reminds me of Yeji from ITZY (Simmilar face shape). It's not something wrong. It's normal to say "Hey, this person looks like one popular idol" or something like this. They are original etc. But it's normal people has simmilar face features, especially in Korea where they have their own standards and idols have to fit these standards
Ughh they are Taeyeon and Tiffany's daughters.
지젤은 눈썹이나 메이크업을 바꿔야겠다.
예쁘장하긴 한데 왜이렇게 밋밋하고 무미건조하게 느껴지지...;;
조금만 메이크업 화려하게해도 확 티날거겉은데
ㅇㅈ 눈썹이 밋밋함
그리고 약깐 의상도 백댄서랑 겹침... 흰색옷 /////
아직 얼굴도 잘모르는데 제대로 안보면 누가 에스파인지 잘모르겠음... 특히 닝닝 머리도 묶어서 더 잘봐야됨 ...
@@user-ie1dh4xx3b 자세히보면 백댄서 상의흰색 하의연분홍이라 멤버도 흰색2명 연분홍2명으로 맞춘거같은데 흰색옷은 그냥 백댄서에 흡수돼서보임
@__ 한일 혼혈이라 확실히 발음은 진짜 좋아요ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 살짝 어눌한거뿐이지 억양은 찐한국인임
선구안. ㄷㄷ 헤메 바꾸고 지젤 대존예됨
무대 보기 전에 스엠에서 올렸던 영상을 봐서 그런가 카메라가 많이 아쉽넹 뭔가 자꾸 중심축이 안 맞는 느낌도 들고
SM will hit jackpot with these girls. I was still overwhelmed by the fact that Ningning is actually debuted, i was so fond of her since SR16G era.
The duality in Karina amazes me 2:58.
이 의상이랑 윈터랑 너무 찰떡임
이무대가 레전드무대다…데뷔첫무대 완전뮤비느낌…너무 예쁘다ㅠㅠ
The duality tho. With that elegant costumes and a badass song.
Their aura alone screams elegance and supremacy. Yeokshi, SM artists are THAT artists.
SM would killing us with Karina’s confidence , Winter’s beautiful face , Giselle’s deep voice and attractive aura , Ningning powerful vocals and cutest
이 무대보고 입덕한 사람 이유 많은 이유를 알겠음 .. 일단 내 얘기임
When Karina's visual is more like ai than her actual ai. Her beauty is unreal!!
BTW I'm Winter biased, Ace in an all-rounder group
They don't look like rookies. Just like professional idol
It feels more like comeback than a debut.
Yeahhh
Maybe because they have trained for years for their debut?
@@cristaljustice4534 yeah i can see that they don't feel nervous or awkward at the stage even tho it's their debut.
They trained to be a professional idol
진짜 윈터 너무 예쁘다.......... 윈터 확신의 에스엠상 ㅠㅠㅜㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ ❤️
ㅇㅈ
Karina's stage presence is no joke for rookies PERIODT
stage presence =/= looking pretty and knowing how to stare at cameras. yall havent even seen these girls with a live audience yet to tell if they have stage presence or not
Winter is so pretty, Ningning's vocals, Giselle's facial expression and Karina's charisma!!! wow
Winter looks like Taeyeon’s twin 👯♀️
닝닝이 너무 좋다 음색 표정 분위기 다 좋아
스엠은 스엠이다....
these girls slayed their debut stage and they are so pretty
They all did great! But i can't help noticing Giselle's charisma plus her cute smile throughout the whole performance.
She's my bias but she's underrated :(
@@trishamitzellsagun6309 she's my bias too. i'm sure things gonna change soon and people will fall for her charm. i was quite sad that she didn't rap in black mamba but i am cheering for future songs.
Karina really is the most doll like looking woman I have ever seen...she is so so talented at dancing and I really like her voice
Karina is the most Yeoreum(WJSN) look alike woman I have ever seen
@ryujin's green wig Plot twist, she is an hologram displayed on stage
The choreo: hard hitting, intense and leg breaking
The outfit: light, princess and fairy like, soft af
But they still nailed it. 😏
of all girl groups that debuted this year, the one that shone the most was AESPA. music, videos, vocals, talent, dancing, visuals, rap is the complete package. MY MYNE , My bias Ningning & Winter
SAME
@@chedgatchalian8401 thanks, fighting to support them
AEspa to vocal.and itzy to dance i love both!
giselle is my bias, love her sm
@@vanillaraven2618 Check ITZY's vocals in Be In Love and Surf, they're also vocally powerful. With AESPA they don't have complex choreo yet and I think they're still nervous with dancing so I can't give any material yet
Main dancer, main vocal, center material WINTER ACE!!! Hope SM can push her more in the future i really like her🥺
INDEEEEED
She's lead dancer n lead vocal btw
HIDDEN ACE!!!!
@@bininyaleejaewook8334 we know what we mean is Winter has the MAIN material😉
Winter ace we love Winter
카리나 넘 이쁨 여신. ♡
뭔가 지금 데뷔한 아이돌은 팬들을 만날기회가 많이 없어서 팬들과의 유대라던가 그런게 좀 적을 것 같다
When you get not enough time to said
"shining, shimmering, and splendid"
Just say : Aespa!
Ahahhaha good one!
Best comment hhhhh
People, calm down, usually all SM artists, no matter if they are seniors, use pre-recorded vocals for the first performances, so they can show of the dance and expressions, usually the second week is where they start singing live. This has always happened 🤷♀️
it happens to literally all idols, they prerecorded the stage on the first performance or even on the whole first week promotion. people tend to misunderstand this:(
@UC8DmDlpELljD6at-gHHn4MA they I- they were literally defending them but just saying everyone except mamamoo so we don’t discredit them
Thanks for the info
@@ekaass1735 // the way mamamoo uses prerecordings as well so idk why you tried to exclude them lmfaoo
not all and not just mamamoo
No one gonna talk about karina's turn at 00:20 look like a doll😍
little “huh” at giselle part from karina is really cool and addicted
Sameeeee
Ok but now I understand why Karina is the center, she is not only gorgeous but also insanely outstanding when it comes to dancing/performing. I think I have found my bias
*Karina, yup agree!
Yiee welcome to karebears ❤️😍
Agree... I can see clearly now... SM never failed.
Karina is Unreal 🔥
처음 컴백했을때 말들이 많아서 아~ 그런가보다 했는데 점점 진짜 너무 좋아짐 특히 닝닝 개귀여워ㅠㅠㅠ
I love how Karina smiles at Ningning as she singing her part 2:52
Still pre-recorded but we cannot deny *their visuals are TOP-NOTCH, and so are vocals esp Ningning and Winter*
Maybe some other time they will sing live, knowing SM powerhouse of vocal artists, so expect that they can sing live like their seniors.
@@graceahn3819 2nd week
Sm artist always use pre-recorded during 1st week. We should know that by now.
@@graceahn3819 Indeed, it's just normal for sm artists to be pre-recorded at first days of debut
The rookies always do that for their 1st ever debut stage
During the live show...
Before: 78k viewers
During Aespa: 117K VIEWERS
After: 51k viewers
AESPA IS NO JOKE 😱😱😱😱
wow, the drop from 117k to 51k. honestly I stop watching the live after aespa performed.
@@princesscastillo7392 lmoa same to me😂
@@princesscastillo7392 same😂
I saw it too, because I was there too and I was waiting for aespa
@@princesscastillo7392 same 😂👌
_aespa is the next generation of gg who will carry the whole kpop industry on their shoulders in the future_
Vengo del futuro... Aespa es el líder de la cuarta generación, ganó todos los ROTY. Aespa es el futuro del Kpop.
Karina looks just so out of this world. She's like straight from a webtoon or an online game or something.
They're all pretty here but i think i like Karina's charisma the most!
Agree
Yash
Karina is GORGEOUS
Agree
yeah Karina really caught my eyes
All are so talented. Their visual are definitely a bonus.
If Lami & Yiyang didn't quit SM and debut in Aespa, then the visuals would be even better.
@@thareqinsans I Love Aespa As 4 Member Girlgroup But Lami and Yiyang Would Make Aespa More Perfect!
@@thareqinsans they didn't left though aespa was really created to be a 4 member girl group there's a huge reason why these 4 girls were chosen.
@@thareqinsans yiyang yes but lami emmm no
There's 3 left more members left tho! The visuals bout to be boom!
독기봐…. 이게 신인이야
윈터 김민정 존예❤
They don’t look like a rookie group, they look like seniors, so stable and professional and talented plus their visual 😍
They're great but I guess it's pre recorded and it's lip sync I guess
But stage presence and visuals is Outta the world
@@xoselena1 yes it is pre-recorded so we can't talk about stability, but for sure their studio vocals are superb
in every group debuted i found this kinda coment. 🙄
is this live? ningning didnt dance in her high note
@@sirgawain6844 because it’s required for all lol. it’s not hate xD
Winter’s visuals and stage presence are on another level! LOVE YOU WINTER
데뷔 무대인데 완성도도 높고 앞으로가 너무 기대된다 에스파 화이팅 !
I SEE TAEYEON VIBES IN WINTER AND YURI VIBES IN GISELLE.. makes me miss my gg so much 😭
Winter 예쁘고 노래도 잘하고 춤도 잘 추고 품격도 좋고 Winter만 좋아
The way they went on their knees is literally CHIEF'S KISSES
SHOOKING
2:52 the way Karina smiled at NingNing is just so sweet T-T
에스파 - 블랙맘바
노래, 안무, 가사 총 98점 드림👍
karinas gaze is so hypnotic and her attitude on that stage is crazy. she’s such a queen
our karinaa
Yess agree
kai female version lol
she is the queen bro
IKR shes killing it
Winter looks like Gahyeon, Ningning looks like Jennie, Karina looks like Yeoreum.
Only multifandom fans gotta understand this comment 😅
Ningning eyes looks like Jennie
I understand! Look at my username 😁😁😁
I thought I'm the only one who thought Winter looked like Gahyeon 🥺
giselle looks like chaerin from cherry bullet.
NingNing is literally Jannie wow They are so similiar
Karina is my bias 🥵
닝닝 미모 너무 예뻐❤❤❤❤❤
Ngl but they're more hotter than their Avatars ❤️🔥
Dude, if you're going to use the word hotter, remove the word more. It's either more hot or just hotter.
karina's visuals are really unreal wow. she looks like a doll