Dr. Shannon Curry , the psychologist hired by Johnny Depp, responds to the questions of Amber Heard's lawyer. My reaction #AmberHeard #JohnnyDepp #ShannonCurry #Trial
I do know that in real cases they would ask that no matter what you want the public to believe, you need to tell us your attorneys the truth. It’s possible they know what happened but hired gun just carries out instructions of the lease owner. If she lied to the attorneys too they can easy withdraw from the case
@@theduckyninja1086 I guess she’s trying to “be chill” about it. Since it’s highly televised. A lot of judges I’ve seen would snap at them and tell them the ruling was final and to move on unless they wanted to be spoken to.
how is contemplating a fictive scenario not speculation?, funny how she tries to dismiss the psychologists report with bias but the biggest bias in that conversation is the attorney herself reading the report in defense of amber heard... hahaha. You can see the psychologist gained so much confidence after that idiotic attempt by the female attorney
She was trying to make her look like she was on Depp side all the questions before that, that last question she got objected was the final question to make her point that she was saying what team depp wanted, that's why the lawyer was so upset that even argued against the objection, you can even notice she was looking for more questions but because she didn't had any more questions she jumped to that last question that she had already think of.
The main point is that she's not Dr Phil. She's not going to risk her professional reputation by cooking up a phony diagnosis, nor speculate about whether Depp and his lawyers expected her to be a female Dr Phil.
The psychologist gives me such Harley Quinn vibes. Smart, sharp, attractive, and just downright confident. Couldn't have put anyone better up on the stand to deal with these clown lawyers.
the way she was basically asking the same questions over and over again with slightly different wording- i would've gone insane if i were the psychologist
That's a simple interview tactic, widely use by police, investigator, govt interviewer alike. If you're giving a different answer to each question then they know you're not speaking the truth.
I was once testifying in court when I was ten years old and for almost the entire HOUR the lawyer asked me the same question with different words over and over, I legit got tired and asked if he was searching for a different answer then the same one I was giving 😂 the other lawyer finally got the judge to tell him to move on
@@shadow23498 Elaine was so incompetent when she argued about the psychologist's bias. All she had to ask was "have you ever testified negatively towards someone who hired you?" Then she can establish the history as a sign of bias. Instead Elaine wanted her to speculate about this specific case, then argued it wasn't speculation. Then complained when she couldn't ask the question. Good grief. She's a high priced lawyer, if I can figure this out as a layperson, she should be able to.
Lawyer: lol she's just a psychologist? I can take her easy. Psychologist: You know my entire job is making sure my wording is clear and cannot be misinterpreted, right?
Trying to discredit an experienced impartial psychologist because her husband purchased muffins and she attended an interview at Johnny's house is laughable.
“My husband bought the muffins and I brought them to the office” “So you’re saying your husband was having an affair with Ms Heard and this is just a way to get back at her. Is that correct?”
The gallery was admonished by the judge multiple times for laughing, she finally had to take a zero tolerance stance because people were laughing at Amber, her attorneys and JDs snark.
a bunch did, near the start, then the judge said if there's any more laugh, cough, or otherwise disrespectful or disruptive behaviour, she'd kick everyone out
It's like she thought she could actually get through a line of questioning and a competent witness answered in unpredictable ways, leaving the lawyer nowhere to go.
@@sherpajones 100% and that part of “is that correct?” from the lawyer, then she answers “that’s not correct” it derailed this lawyers train of thought each time leaving her stranded all the time.
She is reaching so hard to disqualify this psychologist and she is grasping for straws however the psychologist is not going to subject her credibility for anyone and is sticking to the facts.
She may be pretty, but has less going on in the brains department. She walked straight into the traps set by this lawyer, rather embarrassing actually.
@@PeterHendtlass Please, tell us where these traps were, cos there were certainly no traps laid in this segment. The lawyer was too busy checking into the muffins!
@@karenjones1 They were the trap….? The focus on the muffins was to demonstrate that we know exactly who this woman is. They revealed everything you needed to know about this woman: somebody who has been bought.
Lawyers come off as so nasty and manipulative. "I'm asking you a question and I'd like you to try and answer it".. in other words "I want you to answer the way I want you to answer, so try again"
I love how half the courtroom literally just facepalms at 7:00 when Heard's lawyer asks about the muffins for the second time, after Dr. Curry had literally just given an in-depth explanation as to exactly what happened. 🤣🤣🤣
Oh my God, there are people face palming, throwing back their heads and laughing. Never noticed that. One guy in the back buried his face in his hands.
The crickets, the owls, and the bats damn near had me rolling on the floor 🤣 that and the spectators not even trying to hide their smiles lol Johnny’s got this in the bag.
I LOVED the "muffin story"! That has to be one of the most hilarious parts of the trial. Every time Elaine was smug and assured that she'd latched onto something juicy, she got her ass handed to her. She's a very slow learner.
It's been almost 11months now and now I can laugh about all this. I was so emotionally invested because as a DV victim I identified with Johnny and badly wanted him to win. But now I can see this defence was built around muffins, bruise kits, Depp peeing in the hallway, dinners and drinks, lawyers objecting to their own questions, and expert witnesses like Dr Smiegel.
Love the crickets. It seems like every line of questioning she tries gets shut down by a competent witness and she is scrambling for a new line of questioning.
I imagined Amber Heard told her lawyer team "that psychologist doesn't know how to keep secrets, she even told her husband on the day we gonna have a session. Her husband even bought muffins for me after knowing it"
%100 believe this, it’s based in truth and the world revolving around her even though it’s clear she frequently brings muffins into the office for clients not just her.
The hidden eye roll the good doctor makes at the end when she closes her eyes sums up the entire case of Turd's legal team. "My husband is not going to believe that his muffin buying made it into a trial. I am being questioned by crazy people"
❌ counts of lying under oath ❌ counts of assault ❌ counts of false allegations ❌ counts of defamation And whatever the charge is for shitting in someone's bed. Like SEND HER TO PRISON ALREADY.
The real takeaway from this is that no one should be automatically believed until their stories are tested in court. That might be inconvenient to those wanting to create easy, black and white ethical constructs, but it is the best path to the truth.
So many were expecting the judge to rule in Depp's favor before Amber said a word. Clearly, a sad indictment on the ability of the majority of the public to understand the simplest legal precepts.
The psychologist is an amazing girl. Beautiful and highly intelligent. Smart and quick mouth,confident and way ahead of the stupid lawyer who's trying so hard to side swipe her.....Nice work Miss Psychologist 😎🤘🤙👍
This is a perfect example of when things are done right there is no reason to lie her answers were quick she didn't hesitate or stutter. Amber's attorneys were outclassed plain and simple.
I find it hilarious that during the time the psychologist was answering questions no one often stood up to call hearsay. She was so on point in answering just facts and staying in the spectrum with her answers. I like how the lawyer on stand tried to twist the event about her interview, and many times the lawyer came back to the event to try to discredit the psychologist and Depp. It was amusing to see lawyers try to use mind games against someone who studies mind games as a profession
This is a perfect example of why the pandemic offers us an opportunity to make trials more fair, by playing them to the jury on a 90-second delay. Counsel plants knowingly false ideas in the heads of the jury; in a delay situation many of defense counsel's questions would be objected to, objection sustained, and the jury would never hear the false-trail questions. Eventually, as counsel realizes that they can't get away with it any longer, trials would be much shorter, reducing the backlog in many court systems.
My old manager used to bring loads of sweets to the office too 😂 she believed that helped team’s productivity and lifted our moods. Dr curry seems like a great boss
7:16 did she…did she not hear her explanation about the muffins? lmao I see the people in the crowd getting second hand embarrassment from that question
She needs to be in a movie as she would be a box office seller. Very attractive smart woman. Her eye roll to the world made the case. Lawyer was beyond her capacity. She needs to fight traffic ticket violations.
Why was the lawyer asked about the muffins 4 times when the psychologist said what was happening very clearly? Man, that desperate attempt by the lawyer was embarrassing.
Here's what we've got so far from Amber: 1) He wasn't the only alcoholic and drug abuser. She drank 2 bottles of wine a day, took drugs as well by her own admission. 2) Caught lying about using the makeup that didn't exist back then to cover her bruises frequently, which was refuted by the makeup company. 3) Past DV arrest against her ex, admitted to DV against Johnny, suspicion of DV against her own sister (her sister was discussing it with her friends by the poolside in a video clip), and assaulted her ex-best friend in public. In contrast Johnny has no history of being violent towards women, and his ex-spouses all speak highly of him. 4) Audio recording of her admitting to cutting his finger in Australia (not allowed in this trial due to technicalities), proving again that her testimony was a lie. 5) Her psychologist lied about Amber having no DV history and was caught out by Johnny's lawyer. 6) Has NO witnesses or evidence (all conveniently random strangers that she doesn't know or deceased people like the bodyguard) 7) DV lawyers analyzing the case said her broken nose is fake and doesn't look like any of the countless injuries they've seen, and it's impossible to cover the swelling and bruising with makeup. 8) A former FBI and CIA body language expert said she shows signs of deception. 9) Allegedly got her nose broken, hit multiple times, her scalp and hair ripped off, penetrated by a bottle, dragged over broken glass and got her arms and legs "pretty cut up", then somehow felt safe enough to take sleeping pills with her "attacker" in the same house, woke up the next day and made him coffee, then went to James Corden's show miraculously healed. No marks, no scars, no pictures, no medical report . Hair stylist saw no signs of abuse. 10) Multiple witnesses (including 3 cops) saw no signs of abuse. 11) Claimed she wanted to leave Johnny, but in all the audio clips she was the one begging him to stay . 12) Claimed she always tried to de-escalate, but in audio clips she was always the aggressor preventing him from leaving and taunting him . 13) Allegedly feared for her life but bought him a large knife . 14) Allegedly hated his drinking problem and wanted to help him quit, but drank in front of him all the time . 15) Was completely different in her 2016 deposition, where she was arrogant and smirking. 16) Proven once again as a liar when she went back on her public promise to donate her divorce money to a children's hospital. 17) Fits Dr Curry's assessment of her mental disorders: >A) Overly dramatic and embellishment (He beat me up like in a scene from the Avengers) >B) Flowery language (He was the love of my life, It felt like a warm glow) >C) Lacks actual substance (He beat me and I thought oh the carpet is dirty. There was mashed potatoes on the wall and my dog stepped on a bee, but oops I don't remember if I threw the bottle at him.) >D) Mimicking (Copied Johnny's outfits every day and Dr Curry's hairstyle) >E) Needy and needs approval (Audio of her refusing to let Johnny leave) >F) Sense of shallowness (Facial expression changes in 0.5s whenever Camille objection stunlocks her) >G) Externalization of blame (Never takes accountability for anything and paints herself as an angel) >H) Deep seated anger and abuse of partners (DV) >I) Manipulation and self-centred (Gaslighting: Look what you made me do Johnny) >J) Fear of abandonment (Audio in Australia post finger accident of her crying and afraid it's over with Johnny) >K) Make a lot of accusations when feeling slighted (Threatens with restraining order and abuse claims after Johnny wants to leave her) >L) Makes threats with legal system to keep partner from leaving (Threatens with restraining order and abuse claims after Johnny wants to leave her)
The fact that people are still defending her when all of this can be proven is wild to me. She was the agresor and even their marriage counselor said that she took pride out of starting conflict with him.
![[EN/JP] 탑게이 impossible 완성시킨 💎라이즈①💎 l 홍석천의 보석함 시즌2 EP.09](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ydRNw-e9C3Y/mqdefault.jpg)
I like this psychologist - she's sharp, confident, calm, collected, attractive and brings muffins to the office
I will never bring mufenes to my office 🙄🤣🤣
I would like to eat her muffins...🤣
" can we address this? So we can stop talking about muffins?!
Lol Im dead!!! 😂 😂 😂
@@ohm7876 “The muffin man??”
it's really impressive how she doesn't lose her patience even when she knows the lawyer's trying to manipulate
I do kind of feel sorry for her lawyers. She's probably lied so much to them that they have no idea what to believe.
I was thinking the same thing 🤦🏾♂️
lol Gaslight your own lawyers so hard they can't put up any reasonable defense.
I do know that in real cases they would ask that no matter what you want the public to believe, you need to tell us your attorneys the truth. It’s possible they know what happened but hired gun just carries out instructions of the lease owner. If she lied to the attorneys too they can easy withdraw from the case
But t-the muffins...
No, I believe they are familiar with the case entirely, but they are simply incompetent.
Shoutouts to the husband for picking up the muffins.
🧁🧁🧁
Lmao
Apparent Heard's lawyers thought the husband sunk the case by bringing muffins.
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Pretty sure he never did it again 😂Lol too much trouble 😂
Judge “That’s speculation”
Lawyer “That’s not speculation!”
You’re leading her into a speculation about an event that didn’t happen. 100% speculation.
Honestly why does the judge let these attorneys argue with her and suggest what she should do during this case? It's very unprofessional.
@@theduckyninja1086 I guess she’s trying to “be chill” about it. Since it’s highly televised. A lot of judges I’ve seen would snap at them and tell them the ruling was final and to move on unless they wanted to be spoken to.
how is contemplating a fictive scenario not speculation?, funny how she tries to dismiss the psychologists report with bias but the biggest bias in that conversation is the attorney herself reading the report in defense of amber heard... hahaha. You can see the psychologist gained so much confidence after that idiotic attempt by the female attorney
She was trying to make her look like she was on Depp side all the questions before that, that last question she got objected was the final question to make her point that she was saying what team depp wanted, that's why the lawyer was so upset that even argued against the objection, you can even notice she was looking for more questions but because she didn't had any more questions she jumped to that last question that she had already think of.
The main point is that she's not Dr Phil. She's not going to risk her professional reputation by cooking up a phony diagnosis, nor speculate about whether Depp and his lawyers expected her to be a female Dr Phil.
The psychologist gives me such Harley Quinn vibes. Smart, sharp, attractive, and just downright confident. Couldn't have put anyone better up on the stand to deal with these clown lawyers.
I see it haha
I was thinking this the whole time!
I second that opinion!!!!!
Bruh i was literally thinking the same thing!
I think its mostly her hair and maybe glasses that gives her this strong Harley Quinn vibe.
@@multigatawny5204 and face shape, and voice, and cadence, and clothing, and body shape... 🙄
the way she was basically asking the same questions over and over again with slightly different wording- i would've gone insane if i were the psychologist
I think that’s why we not the psychologists.
That's a simple interview tactic, widely use by police, investigator, govt interviewer alike. If you're giving a different answer to each question then they know you're not speaking the truth.
I was once testifying in court when I was ten years old and for almost the entire HOUR the lawyer asked me the same question with different words over and over, I legit got tired and asked if he was searching for a different answer then the same one I was giving 😂 the other lawyer finally got the judge to tell him to move on
@@LunaBell08 what u did? Were u a psychopath killer?
The lawyer is trying to make it sound like she had dinner and drinks (dating) with Depp. That was the whole 'discredit' strategy. It failed
I literally get second hand embarrassment every time that Amber Heard or anyone from her legal team speaks
Omg yes!! They are so cringe to watch!
Good. Maybe you won't act like that then.
Same.
@@squiggly_lines . You just did 🤭 .
So true! Elaine was the most messy attorney ever
"That is not accurate."
"What is accurate?"
"You are incorrect that's not correct."
The precision and shade of it all ♥️
Lol.
Watching this at 1 hour in the morning, listening to it and liking this line immediatly! She is a queen!! Go psychologist!!! 🔥
I loved that response
the fact that the lawyer tried to correct the judge 💀💀💀
Nothing can kill a case faster than a lawyer who thinks they are smarter than the Judge, when they really aren't.
Happens in every single court room and at times the judge does get corrected based on evidence code or case law
@@DaOne510 true but at the other side when a lawyer says something like "it goes to bias your honor" then it definitely isn't a good look at all
@@shadow23498 Elaine was so incompetent when she argued about the psychologist's bias. All she had to ask was "have you ever testified negatively towards someone who hired you?" Then she can establish the history as a sign of bias. Instead Elaine wanted her to speculate about this specific case, then argued it wasn't speculation. Then complained when she couldn't ask the question. Good grief. She's a high priced lawyer, if I can figure this out as a layperson, she should be able to.
Lawyer: lol she's just a psychologist? I can take her easy.
Psychologist: You know my entire job is making sure my wording is clear and cannot be misinterpreted, right?
"You're incorrect, that is not correct " some simple wording that screws with the lawyers brain😂😂
I so loved when she would say that is incorrect. Lawyer’s brain. 🤯
She is not credible. She’s getting an ego trip by testifying. Not very impressive
@@poojak11 let me guess, you’re on amber’s side?
@MIDNIGHT BOSS Objection. Speculation
Trying to discredit an experienced impartial psychologist because her husband purchased muffins and she attended an interview at Johnny's house is laughable.
Lol she literally just went to his house for an interview and dinner was served...it was completely professional
Because she has nothing else. She knows her client is mentally ill because of her reaction at her deposition she missed because of hysterics.
@@johnsmith42688 Johnny usually doesn't just drop by your business. He'd have a mob outside her office when he walked out.
seriously, that's all they had, it's incredible
Discredited on account of Chow mein with a side of tofu 😆 🤣
Not Amber’s lawyer trying to manipulate a Psychologist 😒
LITERALLY
Like for real
A forensic psychologist at that! 😂😂
It is.
the whole muffin questioning was simply hilarious
May I clarify so we can stop talking about the muffins 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Leave the goddamn muffins out of this.
@@zainm217 no, they need to bring in the owner of the muffin company to testify
I'm sure she was hoping for her "legally blonde " / "perm" moment, but failed miserably
Hahaha literally
“My husband bought the muffins and I brought them to the office”
“So you’re saying your husband was having an affair with Ms Heard and this is just a way to get back at her. Is that correct?”
😂😂
Gold ..😃😃😃
“That is not correct.”
"Objection, that's a speculation" "It's not a speculation" Judge: "I sustain the objection" 🤣 Gee, I quite wish this trial would never end.
For Depps sake I wish it Will end, and he win, but I can see what you mean. This is a clownfiesta at heard office.
This Lawyer will be on a murder trial and be like "On the day of the murder did you or did you not purchase muffins before committing the crime?"
Facts lmao
🤣🤣🤣
😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
She was hoping for her “where you got in the shower” moment.
LOL the lawyer is obsessed with the muffins. Did she miss lunch that day at court?
@@la9102 for real she even explained already about the dam muffins . This lawyer is reaching terribly
Maybe her own husband never brought muffins to her office and now she is jealous
Missed breakfast
Maybe
The Star Wars quote, “The ability to speak does not make you intelligent.” applies to this lawyer 🤮
How are people in the audience not laughing out loud at this attorney?
They are laughing! So many times - look at their faces.
The gallery was admonished by the judge multiple times for laughing, she finally had to take a zero tolerance stance because people were laughing at Amber, her attorneys and JDs snark.
Because they would have been escorted out unfortunately
a bunch did, near the start, then the judge said if there's any more laugh, cough, or otherwise disrespectful or disruptive behaviour, she'd kick everyone out
They are , just need to step out if they lough loud, judge said order or ill throw you out
Is it me or this attorney was preparing for this case while she asked questions in court?
It's like she thought she could actually get through a line of questioning and a competent witness answered in unpredictable ways, leaving the lawyer nowhere to go.
@@sherpajones 100% and that part of “is that correct?”
from the lawyer, then she answers “that’s not correct” it derailed this lawyers train of thought each time leaving her stranded all the time.
J
She is reaching so hard to disqualify this psychologist and she is grasping for straws however the psychologist is not going to subject her credibility for anyone and is sticking to the facts.
She may be pretty, but has less going on in the brains department. She walked straight into the traps set by this lawyer, rather embarrassing actually.
Psychologist is totally totally avoiding
@@PeterHendtlass Let me guess... Incel?
@@PeterHendtlass Please, tell us where these traps were, cos there were certainly no traps laid in this segment. The lawyer was too busy checking into the muffins!
@@karenjones1 They were the trap….? The focus on the muffins was to demonstrate that we know exactly who this woman is. They revealed everything you needed to know about this woman: somebody who has been bought.
Lawyers come off as so nasty and manipulative. "I'm asking you a question and I'd like you to try and answer it".. in other words "I want you to answer the way I want you to answer, so try again"
exactly
Yeah, her tone was vile. I was so glad to see the psychologist do so well dealing with her crap attitude
She is like give it to me the way like it ! Dang ! She always like that ? 😮
I love how half the courtroom literally just facepalms at 7:00 when Heard's lawyer asks about the muffins for the second time, after Dr. Curry had literally just given an in-depth explanation as to exactly what happened. 🤣🤣🤣
OMG! I never noticed that. That’s hilarious 😂😂
Oh my God, there are people face palming, throwing back their heads and laughing. Never noticed that. One guy in the back buried his face in his hands.
😂😂😂
The crickets, the owls, and the bats damn near had me rolling on the floor 🤣 that and the spectators not even trying to hide their smiles lol Johnny’s got this in the bag.
I was rolling at that🤣🤣🤣🤣
What is up with this woman? She's giving you answers, girl. You just don't like them.
The lawyer giving me secondhand embarrassment
Whoever added the owl hooting to the crickets is my hero.
You can see the people in the court showing amusement by the failure of the lawyer throughout the video.
I got to that part literally as I was reading this 😂. I’m cracking up.
It’s the crickets for me!!! 😂Ms. Heard’s legal team doesn’t seem too sharp. Extremely embarrassing.
Lmao, career done after this case
How the heck this woman even became a lawyer? 🤦🏻♀️😂
👍 to the psychologist!
this psychologist is very professional. they don’t allow their words to be twisted, and they are calm, collected, and answers the questions.
there were points where i could see the "bitch what?" on her face
@@cassdiscord5331 its great that she actually kept her cool i would have lost it
c'mon gender neutrality :)
What u mean “they” lol you should use she as she is a woman
@@queenbee7074 why should it be a problem that im saying “they” ?? what problem do u have with gender neutral pronouns
The judge wasn’t having any of it
This attorney is the epitome of the saying, "Don't take a knife to a gunfight." She's grasping at straws with this Psychologist.
Heard must have got those lawyers on the cheap. I can't believe how incompetent they are. It's embarrassing.
This lawyer was so condescending, I’d feel so uncomfortable up on the stand if anyone spoke to me like that.
WTAF! What kind of questions are these 🤦🏾♀️
Rule Number 1. Do not ask questions you don't know the answer to.
I LOVED the "muffin story"! That has to be one of the most hilarious parts of the trial. Every time Elaine was smug and assured that she'd latched onto something juicy, she got her ass handed to her. She's a very slow learner.
It's been almost 11months now and now I can laugh about all this. I was so emotionally invested because as a DV victim I identified with Johnny and badly wanted him to win. But now I can see this defence was built around muffins, bruise kits, Depp peeing in the hallway, dinners and drinks, lawyers objecting to their own questions, and expert witnesses like Dr Smiegel.
Love the crickets. It seems like every line of questioning she tries gets shut down by a competent witness and she is scrambling for a new line of questioning.
I love her soft smile when she messes with the lawyer! She's awesome!
People are quick to jump Amber Heard's attorneys but look at what they had to defend.
Wow, this psychologist doesn’t need a cheat sheet like another psychologist.
I imagined Amber Heard told her lawyer team "that psychologist doesn't know how to keep secrets, she even told her husband on the day we gonna have a session. Her husband even bought muffins for me after knowing it"
%100 believe this, it’s based in truth and the world revolving around her even though it’s clear she frequently brings muffins into the office for clients not just her.
I was okay with the crickets, but as soon as I heard the owl I had to laugh out loud! ,😂😂😂
This psychologist is one smart, acute person. Great analytical composure.
The hidden eye roll the good doctor makes at the end when she closes her eyes sums up the entire case of Turd's legal team.
"My husband is not going to believe that his muffin buying made it into a trial. I am being questioned by crazy people"
".... so we can stop talking about the muffins?" Nearly peed my pants.
❌ counts of lying under oath
❌ counts of assault
❌ counts of false allegations
❌ counts of defamation
And whatever the charge is for shitting in someone's bed.
Like SEND HER TO PRISON ALREADY.
They keep coming for this psychologist and she's NOT having it.
could we move on from the muffins please 😭
My god the clarity of her. It's so satisfying.
What's with the muffin obsession? 😂😂
how pathetic to insinuate that at such a high profile case you may want to sway some opinions your way by offering a couple muffins...? good lord...
That lawyer is so unlikeable, rude and is harassing the witness.
This psychologist is way smarter than all the defenses attorneys put together.
Imagine thinking you’re gonna fool a psychologist. Amber and her fits each other so well
just give the damn lawyer a muffin 😒 🙄 😑
The real takeaway from this is that no one should be automatically believed until their stories are tested in court. That might be inconvenient to those wanting to create easy, black and white ethical constructs, but it is the best path to the truth.
beautifully said
So many were expecting the judge to rule in Depp's favor before Amber said a word. Clearly, a sad indictment on the ability of the majority of the public to understand the simplest legal precepts.
That is correct 😂
The psychologist is an amazing girl. Beautiful and highly intelligent. Smart and quick mouth,confident and way ahead of the stupid lawyer who's trying so hard to side swipe her.....Nice work Miss Psychologist 😎🤘🤙👍
I would love to have this psychologist prepare a report on the psychosis of the lawyer.
The lawyer really needs to know the details of drinks and what kind of food they had LOL
This is comedy gold....saved to bookmarks to watch again!!!
the lawyer is embarrassing
Can you imagine if most of this wasn't recorded? The media would be calling it a slam dunk for Heard right up until and even after she lost....
Depp's lawyers aren't even trying to hold back the smile. This is so amusing to watch.
That lawyer is embarrassing herself here 😬
I want the muffins!
You can’t HANDLE the muffins!!!
This is a perfect example of when things are done right there is no reason to lie her answers were quick she didn't hesitate or stutter. Amber's attorneys were outclassed plain and simple.
I love watching the reactions of the crowd behind
I find it hilarious that during the time the psychologist was answering questions no one often stood up to call hearsay. She was so on point in answering just facts and staying in the spectrum with her answers. I like how the lawyer on stand tried to twist the event about her interview, and many times the lawyer came back to the event to try to discredit the psychologist and Depp. It was amusing to see lawyers try to use mind games against someone who studies mind games as a profession
has this lawyer done any courtroom cases before or is this like her first time?
I would've taken my chances with Joe Pesci in his Vinny role.
Lawyer: do you know the muffin man.
Maybe the muffin man did it! They never caught him you know....
Amber Heard should pack it up apologize and leave the public eye it’s already over
She should go to jail
“Yes let me try using psychological tricks on a psychologist”
"What could possibly go wrong?"
This is a perfect example of why the pandemic offers us an opportunity to make trials more fair, by playing them to the jury on a 90-second delay. Counsel plants knowingly false ideas in the heads of the jury; in a delay situation many of defense counsel's questions would be objected to, objection sustained, and the jury would never hear the false-trail questions. Eventually, as counsel realizes that they can't get away with it any longer, trials would be much shorter, reducing the backlog in many court systems.
i love how the people in the back are even giggling along 7:02 it's so BLATANTLY OBVIOUS how comical the lawyer's questions are LMAOOO 😂
even Depp's lawyer at the front has a big grin on his face.
@@terrya8989 When didn't Ben Chew have a grin on his face?
Smart, smart, assertive psychologist
The owl sound effects 😂😂😭
Love the crickets...nice touch 👌
Is it me, or is Elaine not very well prepared????
Beware, Muffingate, lol
Watching Heard's defense fall apart is so gratifying. I watched the proceedings live last year. It was fantastic
I adore Dr psychologist ! She is just brilliant
THIS psychologist has a mind like a steel trap and that lawyer is caught fast. Lol.
Ambers lawyer is the definition of "fishing without bait, without tackle, and with no idea where there's water".
She makes me proud to have chosen the Pychology career path
Sounds like someone was feeling a bit hangry there lol.
Lol, the crickets and owl sounds were sooo appropriate. 😏
IMHO, this stubborn insisting on the "dinner with Mr Depp" was very damaging for AH defense.
My old manager used to bring loads of sweets to the office too 😂 she believed that helped team’s productivity and lifted our moods. Dr curry seems like a great boss
His lawyers just seemed so much smarter than hers, the whole "mega-pint" thing got me.
Everyone on Johnnys legal team look so cool, calm, and collective😂 on the other side it’s all over the place!!
May I clarify what happened so we can top talking about the muffins
-Dr.Curry-
7:16 did she…did she not hear her explanation about the muffins? lmao I see the people in the crowd getting second hand embarrassment from that question
4:57 the owl had me crying 😂
She needs to be in a movie as she would be a box office seller. Very attractive smart woman. Her eye roll to the world made the case. Lawyer was beyond her capacity. She needs to fight traffic ticket violations.
Why was the lawyer asked about the muffins 4 times when the psychologist said what was happening very clearly? Man, that desperate attempt by the lawyer was embarrassing.
This attorney does not have half the brains Dr. Curry has. Ms. Heard and her legal team are doing to be unemployed after this 3 ring circus.😂
Here's what we've got so far from Amber:
1) He wasn't the only alcoholic and drug abuser. She drank 2 bottles of wine a day, took drugs as well by her own admission.
2) Caught lying about using the makeup that didn't exist back then to cover her bruises frequently, which was refuted by the makeup company.
3) Past DV arrest against her ex, admitted to DV against Johnny, suspicion of DV against her own sister (her sister was discussing it with her friends by the poolside in a video clip), and assaulted her ex-best friend in public. In contrast Johnny has no history of being violent towards women, and his ex-spouses all speak highly of him.
4) Audio recording of her admitting to cutting his finger in Australia (not allowed in this trial due to technicalities), proving again that her testimony was a lie.
5) Her psychologist lied about Amber having no DV history and was caught out by Johnny's lawyer.
6) Has NO witnesses or evidence (all conveniently random strangers that she doesn't know or deceased people like the bodyguard)
7) DV lawyers analyzing the case said her broken nose is fake and doesn't look like any of the countless injuries they've seen, and it's impossible to cover the swelling and bruising with makeup.
8) A former FBI and CIA body language expert said she shows signs of deception.
9) Allegedly got her nose broken, hit multiple times, her scalp and hair ripped off, penetrated by a bottle, dragged over broken glass and got her arms and legs "pretty cut up", then somehow felt safe enough to take sleeping pills with her "attacker" in the same house, woke up the next day and made him coffee, then went to James Corden's show miraculously healed. No marks, no scars, no pictures, no medical report . Hair stylist saw no signs of abuse.
10) Multiple witnesses (including 3 cops) saw no signs of abuse.
11) Claimed she wanted to leave Johnny, but in all the audio clips she was the one begging him to stay .
12) Claimed she always tried to de-escalate, but in audio clips she was always the aggressor preventing him from leaving and taunting him .
13) Allegedly feared for her life but bought him a large knife .
14) Allegedly hated his drinking problem and wanted to help him quit, but drank in front of him all the time .
15) Was completely different in her 2016 deposition, where she was arrogant and smirking.
16) Proven once again as a liar when she went back on her public promise to donate her divorce money to a children's hospital.
17) Fits Dr Curry's assessment of her mental disorders:
>A) Overly dramatic and embellishment (He beat me up like in a scene from the Avengers)
>B) Flowery language (He was the love of my life, It felt like a warm glow)
>C) Lacks actual substance (He beat me and I thought oh the carpet is dirty. There was mashed potatoes on the wall and my dog stepped on a bee, but oops I don't remember if I threw the bottle at him.)
>D) Mimicking (Copied Johnny's outfits every day and Dr Curry's hairstyle)
>E) Needy and needs approval (Audio of her refusing to let Johnny leave)
>F) Sense of shallowness (Facial expression changes in 0.5s whenever Camille objection stunlocks her)
>G) Externalization of blame (Never takes accountability for anything and paints herself as an angel)
>H) Deep seated anger and abuse of partners (DV)
>I) Manipulation and self-centred (Gaslighting: Look what you made me do Johnny)
>J) Fear of abandonment (Audio in Australia post finger accident of her crying and afraid it's over with Johnny)
>K) Make a lot of accusations when feeling slighted (Threatens with restraining order and abuse claims after Johnny wants to leave her)
>L) Makes threats with legal system to keep partner from leaving (Threatens with restraining order and abuse claims after Johnny wants to leave her)
Wow.
You helped me understand some things a lot better, thanks!!
Y'know... when you put it all together like this it almost makes it seem like _Amber_ is the abuser? *shocked pikachu meme*
tone/ _heavy_ sarcasm
The fact that people are still defending her when all of this can be proven is wild to me. She was the agresor and even their marriage counselor said that she took pride out of starting conflict with him.
Ace! Love this analytical view. More factual too than shallow opinions and bias
I’m happy for Johnny I hope he has a peaceful life now
Am I the only one suffocating from that lawyer's incompetence?