소스 코드
- 게시일 2021. 08. 05.
- Yemen has been at war for more than six years. The healthcare system has been decimated, famine looms, and millions are struggling to cope. But few observers have paid attention to the country's escalating mental health crisis that is accompanying this humanitarian catastrophe. VICE News gains exclusive access inside the few psychiatric hospitals still operating in Yemen today, finding patients both physically and chemically restrained. Such dire conditions reflect the severe lack of resources for Yemeni people, who the world seems to have turned their backs on.
Executive Producers: Bev Chase, Subrata De, Shane Smith, Craig Thomson, Maral Usefi
Senior Producer: Sean Stephens
Senior Editorial Producer: Andrew Potter
Producer: Amel Guettatfi
Senior Correspondent and Producer: Isobel Yeung
Field Producer: Ahmed Baidar
Associate Producer: Daniel Plyam
Archival Producer: Nikki Machrone
Editors: Kimmy Gordon, Chris Herde, Victoria Lesiw, Ilaria Polsonetti, Nelson Ryland, Alejandro Soto Goico
Director of Photography: Javier Manzano
---
Subscribe to VICE News here: bit.ly/Subscribe-to-VICE-News
Check out VICE News for more: vicenews.com
Follow VICE News here:
Facebook: / vicenews
Twitter: / vicenews
Tumblr: / vicenews
Instagram: / vicenews
More videos from the VICE network: www. vicevideo
#VICENews #News #emmys2022
![[SUB] 체력장(팝스)하라고 했더니 목숨을 거는 5세대 아이돌 ZB1 | [태양의 운동부] EP.2](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/hJBm_mtIhqY/mqdefault.jpg)
![[일상 브이로그] 드디어 얼굴 공개?, 미국인 가족들과 제주도 여행, 신라 한복 체험, 손님 초대상 차리기](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/e13yiIBMZnk/mqdefault.jpg)
Reporter: who do you blame?
Doctor: blaming myself is the only thing I can do.
That's heartbreaking.
Why do you think diamonds are so tough?
thats true strangs thats a hearo thats a thing that keeps us humans still alive
The staff are definitely traumatized as well. I worry that suicide might be an escape. The pain must be so unbarable. 😔
Social Media and Metal Health. A video i liked krplus.net/bidio/lJ1vn4SAqp3SXpw
@@petroe3884 It shows that their government is corrupt.
I can’t give much hate towards the doctor, he’s giving his best despite a situation he cannot control.
Facts
Ditto
You shouldn’t be able to give any hate? You see what he has in fact that mans probably the most honourable guy around.
islam is still the trashiest religion on earth
@@SdotGo2 uhhh then y are 2+billion ppl islamic
The nurse that had to turn away the man suffering from psychosis- the way she spoke to his friend, she seemed so angry, even heartless. But as soon as the door closes behind them and they leave the hospital, she is in tears. She was never angry with them- she is frustrated to the literal brink, and it breaks her heart to turn people away, but she has no choice. That is an unimaginable stress. And that scenario likely repeats itself several times a day, every single day.
How she and the doctor at the psychiatric hospital continue to come to work every single day and try to help those they can- there is not enough gratitude in the world for them. And sadly, they will never know all the people seeing these situations see them as the selfless, deeply giving, and truly heroic people they are.
War and adversity brings out both the best and the worst in people. Thank goodness for all the best.
It reminds me so much of overloaded ERs in the West. The reactions and feelings of the nurses are so similar, although the situation is of course of a completely different gravity.
I'm not American but I've seen a lot of Americans sharing a particular quote from Mr. Rogers about the people who are heroes during bad times.
“When I was a boy and I would see scary things in the news,” Rogers said to his television neighbors, “my mother would say to me, ‘Look for the helpers. You will always find people who are helping.""
Definitely true here.
I remember once I was walking down the street and some homeless drug addled man asked me money so he could buy food for him. I told him I had no money and went inside the McDonald’s and purchased a cheeseburger. When my door was ready I walked outside where he was seated at the bus stop. I saw next to him and started eating my cheeseburger. 🤗
@@baverfjant Thank you for this - I grew up in America and watched Mr. Rogers, but I’d never heard this before. Thank you again!
@@hakimbandaru1915 wtf
“I love my patients” what a sweet man, he’s doing the best he can for the resources he has - and you can tell he meant what he aaid
This doctor needs a Nobel prize. Imagine the suffering he sees every day. He is doing the best with no real support. Praying for you Doctor and for your many patients, your country and that the war stops.
He probably loves the suffering. You do know he's a human right?
@@louisbirdsongjr8069 don’t project what you like unto others, just because you may have a certain mental variation or problems doesn’t mean every human also likes human suffering. Be well and I truly hope you don’t hurt anyone or yourself.
@@louisbirdsongjr8069 And without fail, there it is, that one derange comment going against the grain for the sake of going against the grain. Sad out cry for attention...
@@user-ot2nh8qb7d Right! always. It's annoying I swear.
Check out Denis mukwege who got the prize in 2018; he's also seen suffering
It’s hard to fathom, that if we weren’t born where we were, this could be our situation. I’m so sorry for people who suffer with so little help.
Yes I couldn't agree more
yes, it's this realization that stops people from being cruel, when they hear about refugees fleeing these situations. there's no go back and fight in your country when you imagine yourself in their situation and how no amount of fighting would save you
yeah its insane. im half yemeni but my parents migrated to a richer country so this hits home honestly. I have an anxiety disorder and I am so privileged to have access to amazing mental health facilities
“There by the grace of God go I”
Hopefully your full of science sauce or the left will want you in the gulag
A noble doctor and nurse, and a suffering mom. All of them put in a very difficult place where options are not even available. Heartbreaking.
I'm in a UK mental health ward rn and I've never felt so blessed to be here as I have after watching this heartbreaking video. Praying for all those who need help and relief 🙏.
The doctor is a selfless man, we won't even last a day in his shoes. So honourable..
Who's "we"?
@@MargaritaMagdalena Virtually anyone. I doubt most people will be able to do what that doctor does
Most doctors are selfless..
All their youth into studying and volunteering. Than more training. Barely any hollidays, and always being called back to the hospital, dealing with multiple patients.
Covid was an eye opener. Especially warfare triage in a public hospital..
The doctors who left.. I can't blame them either. They must've left for their family. But I wonder how they feel knowing they willingly left a place in need.
@@winter7091 Except for surgeons. They're in the top 10 professions with the most psychopaths.
@@MargaritaMagdalena i mean.. that makes sense right.. i dont think there psychopaths, just De-sensitized.
Normal people would not be able to cut someone open Or deal with the stress of that person dying. Any small mistake can kill that person. Its a high intensity, high stress, job. They have to stand and be concentrated for hours.
Vice has opened my eyes and educated me about the unheard voices and unseen people of the other parts of the world.
Yes, me too!!!
Word
@Cian MacGana shut up...
@Cian MacGana chaining up the mentally ill that’s so wrong let them roam the streets like USA does
@Cian MacGana i agree but also in San Francisco
My heart goes out to that mother who had to chain her son up. I can’t imagine how wretched their situation must be, day in and day out. I hope they’re able to get him some medicine or treatment.
Mine too. She is protecting him from himself, from hurting her family, and from the abuse and stigma he might face from his own neighbors. She does not have any other choice. I am sure she and his entire family are heartbroken. I cannot imagine living every day through 6 years of war, with no end in sight.
How can I complain about anything after watching this, and seeing what the rest of the world‘s reality looks like?
He seems like he is on the autism spectrum, and likely has several comorbid psychiatric conditions.
I can really feel his sincerity. I hope this man is having some rest too 'cause what he's been doing is physically and mentally exhausting. Truly shows he cares for these people who are in need.
The doctor was right. He's undoubtedly seen and heard of some horrible things done to families by traumatised fathers, brothers and sons, with his overwhelming work load and lack of staff, the best thing he can hope to do is just keep them sedated and inside the facility.
It sucks but, that's just the reality of the situation.
🌍😟
Yes but he or she is being scapegoated to be blamed. It is not their fault that they are mentally ill, so it would be unfair to lock them up because of their mental disabilities.
Belgium is one of five countries that allow doctors to kill patients at their request, and one of two, along with the Netherlands, that grant the procedure for people with severe *mental illness* such as *severe chronic depression* . The idea is that those with a psychiatric illness should be afforded the same rights as those suffering from a physical one.
Also Recently Australian euthanasia activist Philip Nitschke and Dutch designer Alexander Bannink created a suicide pod. Called the “Sarco”, short for sarcophagus, the 3D-printed machine comes with a detachable coffin, mounted on a stand that contains a nitrogen canister. ~
~
“The person who wants to die presses the button and the capsule is filled with nitrogen. He or she will feel a bit dizzy but will then rapidly lose consciousness and die fast and painlessly,” said Nitschke, who has been dubbed “Dr Death” for his work to legalise euthanasia. ~
~
The “Sarco” is a device “to provide people with a death when they wish to die,” Nitschke said.~
~
“This is a situation where one person chooses to press a button … rather than for instance standing in front of a train.”
“I believe it’s a fundamental human right (to choose when to die). It’s not just some medical privilege for the very sick. If you’ve got the precious gift of life, you should be able to give that gift away at the time of your choosing,” Nitschke said.
@@JD-jz5rr I believe that i also believe when a hospital has to shut down. The aggressive mentally ill patients secretly get disposed of. Same thing happens to random refugees that end up somewhere so the government has to build a camp for them till they can figure out where to integrate them and especially which ones they deem safe and not crazy. They slowly take small groups away so know one notices and just gun them down. Are world can be very barbaric. Back to killing the insane, even if you had the legal right to slaughter all the mentally ill in the world, it wouldn't do anything cause one thing I learned is we all lye somewhere along the broad spectrum of mental illness. Even though scientists are beginning to understand more of the brain. They still don't know how to properly treat it and the strange thing is only a true ill person can understand another ill person. They say some of the best psychiatrist are real paranoid schizophrenic psychopaths themselves.
I have sympathy for the mother with the abusive son. I imagine it must've been many long, trying years before she came to the conclusion that chaining him up was the only way to deal with him, especially in a country that offers next to no mental health services.
probably better like that than calling the police on him and thrown in and out of jail for the rest of his life like it is done in other countries without mental health care
Its like he is a werewolf
@@mansashaka Similar to owning an aggressive dog, whom cannot be trusted around others. But you still love them and care for them with all your heart! My childhood dog was the same way. Had to be put away when company came to visit. He interpreted any stranger as a threat.
@سعد عابدين Wow, what are they doing to your country? I am American, so I am in the dark to what is going on over there.
@سعد عابدين i wish the best of luck to you in your country
This Doctor is a good man for staying when so many have fled the country and the woman deserves a medal for staying to.
I feel horrible that the doctor is trying his best and isn’t given the proper resources to treat people with these illnesses. He truly loves what he does and the people he tries to treat as many people as possible
That vet at the beginning was suffering with PTSD....as a Marine it kills me to see that happen to a vet.
get vets off dirty big pharma!
he has the eyes of a man who has lost all humanity, but I'm sure somewhere inside, there still is a part left of him. Hardest part is knowing that he has no way of finding it and getting himself back. He will continue being the shell of the man who once was. Just look at his eyes and you can see the guilt and regret for the things he was forced to do. May he find peace, in life or death. I really hope he finds it.
WW1 Vets got the worst treatment after the war. Imagine being in a trench for 4 years and coming home and no one giving you a praise.
You are right as someone who suffered ptsd and now a nurse I see ptsd in him beyond saddening he could with help and right medication live a good life
Isobel is a great reporter. Listens to the people she’s talking to, cares about them, and asks the right questions without being overbearing
Topic really dark -> send Isobel. I hope she'll be getting lighter assignments in the future
Too many sssssssss in her words.
She is the wrong reporter for this assignment. Too emotional. The doctor, the family with the mentally ill son, they chain up, are doing the best they can under these circumstances.
And all that and she's gorgeous
@@emcee1337 not really, he’s be heavily medicated and in care for the rest of his life. That isn’t an “evil” look, that is the look of not knowing what is going on or what is real. I fully commend the mother for doing everything she can for her son, he could hurt others or someone could kill him in retaliation.
Thank you, Vice. And, God bless this Dr. for caring for these patients. I pray for their care.
These always need to be so much longer, VICE does a really great job telling a story and I always get surprised that it ends so fast. I hope Yemen can see some positivity soon.
the doctor kept it real as possible, respect. In heaven he can truly rest
No one has proved a heaven actually exists. Religious prattle is useless.
@@andrewharper1609 ok andrew
@Andrew Harper If something is made up, it doesn't mean it doesn't exist. I made this sentence up, see how it exists.
@@andrewharper1609 respect peoples’ religions
@@andrewharper1609 that wasn’t the point of the comment but ok
So many suffering ppl all around the world yet you have Bezo spending $5 billion to go to space for just 15 minutes. There's seriously something wrong with this world 🌎
A point well taken thank you
He's also funding space research. Research usually leads to innovations in medical science.
Personally I think Besos just wants the attention and fame that space trip brought him. You always have friends when you have money!! No money you get nothing
@@nikhilck629 not enough.
@@harmonyboehnlein1262 even worst, shame on him.
Blaming myself is the only thing that I can do.
That sucks, my heart goes out to these people.
The fact that he comes there everyday to do his job and feels it is his duty, I deeply respect that
Isn't it crazy to think that there is many, many rich people on this planet who could singlehandedly help an entire country if they wanted to? They applied for 100 million. Jeff Bezos is estimated to be sitting at more than 200 billion.
Jeff makes double that in one day
@MiGueL Gonzalez I don't know what your saying, but these people are still living on the planet, just hungry and ill because of no help. They aren't dead. I think it's a crime that a few trillionares hoarde enough money to help most if not all the world, but they just don't. And as far as keeping the population down, what is the difference if whatever population there is, is determined to pollute and destroy the environment and make the planet uninhabitable.
It's not as easy as dumping money into an area in hopes of solving the problem the issues in Yemen are very complex.
Their is a war inside U.S streets without the tanks and rocket launchers yet theyre closing hospitals, schools and mental institutions (mostly in low income neighborhoods) and these billionaires don't help their own why would they help Yemen?
The more money you have the more you want. Only earth can fix this by swallowing all humanity, everyone is equal underground
Yea but why would he involve himself in a ongoing war that caused all of that?
Never underestimate what trauma will do to a person. Mad love to everyone in Yemen. The doctors, the nurses, the adults & the children. I hate governments, all governments, for the horrors they inflict onto people.
We should all govern ourselves.🤗
You hate all governments for inflicting horror onto their people? What horrors have the governments of, say, Finland and Iceland inflicted onto their citizens?
@@maxb9315 dude I think it's called a hyperbolic statement.
@@e.vanl. It's certainly hyperbolic, but I detect no irony in it. There's no indication that it isn't to be taken at face value.
@@maxb9315 touché
The mom who has her son chained up for everyone’s safety including his is doing her best with what she has, that is commendable.
Absolutely heartbreaking. Please pray for these people to find healing
The doctor shouldn’t blame himself for the patients not being able to get what they need, it’s whoever started the wars fault n the people that continue to fight are also to blame.
So blame the Western Countries.
@@risktak3r1994 ?
@Amir Babs thanks for explaining.
@Amir Babs clarify, cause i have no knowledge of politics lol
@yourmomuglysi to a elaborate a little during the WWII, France and England had signed a treaty with princes of the middle east to fight off the ottoman however in all of that westerners we're finding ways to make Israel a state in the middle east. Once this occured the princes of the middle east felt betrayed n that where the problems begin along with the oil control and the American CIA involvement in the late 80$ early 90s.
*Good looks @amirbabs
this doctor...he is very eloquent! He obviously cares so much about the patients and he is doing the best he can.....so so stressful. these health workers are saints. most of us would never be able to walk in his shoes.
Social Media and Metal Health. A video i liked krplus.net/bidio/lJ1vn4SAqp3SXpw
unfortunatly its rare to find health workers like this man, in my country health workers are worse than devil, all they care about is money they'll take from you they dont even care about your situation, of course not all but majority
Praying and sending love to those who are suffering due to mental illness whether it is because they suffer from one or because someone they care about has it. Also, my hearts goes to the doctor and nurse who take care of the patients and have to deal with that hard reality.
Thank you Vice and the beautiiful reporter! I wish its longer but very grateful to acknowledge this.
“This is only the beginning”
The saddest part is that he’s right
I cringed 🙏😭
I dont think theres a person in Yemen without some degree of mental health issues.
God bless that doctor. He was speaking the truth, instead of trying to misrepresent or somehow embelish the reality of his situation, he spoke the bare truth unflinchingly.
This is so so sad. I hope that people can come together and help!
1:00 imagine carrying a dead lifeless child out of ruins, you can tell the children are either dead or extremely close, they can’t even hold their head up. Heartbreaking, I feel so so sorry for them and their family.
This is beyond traumatizing. The mother and the doctor are doing what they can. You and I would lose our minds in a situation like that. This makes me realize that our problems are absolutely nothing compared to this. I wish I could do something for them.
May God have mercy on all of us.
They people in this hospital have lost their minds! A comparison with “normal” people finding themselves in such a situation is stupid!
it doesnt mean our problems are less everyone has their own share of problems however we surely are very very privileged to be born where we are
@@embrace7052 well objectively speaking I would say that many people have struggles that are less critical than this, but that’s just imo
1985 Move bombing USA bombed a black Philadelphia neighborhood and killed kids. "Greatest country on earth"
@@embrace7052
did you born war-tone county.?
Damn I feel really bad for the Doctor, he wants to do better but he legitimately can't.
i truly feel for this doctor hes doing the best with what he has and blames him self truly heartbreaking
The doctor was so well spoken and concise. My heart breaks for him. He is special. I hope he has his own habits and people to turn to.
As a mother I can’t imagine having to chain my son to the wall because he can’t get mental health care. This is very heartbreaking.
Dam it happens even here in Australia, not the chains but my eldest son it took 13 years to get help if I could of legally restrained him he wouldn’t have been more traumatised by the abuse of care workers and police because I couldn’t keep him and his family safe 24/7 !
Autism adhd and epilepsy is not a good mix ! Even harder with no or late diagnosis.
I can
I can
My brother has pretty severe Schizophrenia. Trust me when I say we don't treat our mentally ill much better.
This is so sad for your family I can only imagine your pain . I'm so sorry and hold your family and brother up to God in my prayers
What happened?
This is a sorrow situation, mental health needs to be taken much more seriously
@@frumpd63 im sorry to hear that that's awful
@@frumpd63 Damn that's horrible. How is he coping in prison without his medication?
Sad seeing my grandad hometown like this. I think he's lucky not seeing his hometown in this current condition. He'll be devastated.
My thoughts and prayers to all my brothers and sisters there.
This is truly heartbreaking. You can tell the parents are trying. They’re only human.
As a yemeni, I've been suffering to find a decent mental health care center in yemen. But i didn't find any.
The main reason for this is lack of mental knowledge and its importance next to the culturalimpact. People here feel ashamed to admit that they have any mental illness which led to lack of funding and skilled doctors.
The war is the main reason imo
@@DrJames_YT call me crazy but im gunna have to take his knowledge on his own culture over your opinion
@@kelseyj.c7828 I'm a Yemeni too, lol
@@DrJames_YT well that takes the wind out of my sails
@@kelseyj.c7828 😂
As a severely mentally ill person I forget how lucky I am to have been born in the USA. It hurts more than I explain to see mentally ill or traumatized people left untreated, neglected, or harmed.
I dont know how they do it. I could not get used to that type of daily suffering and I honestly would work to end my life if in their shoes
Social Media and Metal Health. A video i liked krplus.net/bidio/lJ1vn4SAqp3SXpw
At the same time, I hope you understand what kind of disasters USA government have caused in the Middle East, whether Democrats or Republicans, they are all the same.
@@MaoLei sure but they also have done alot of good, but that of course dosent make the news. It's called sensationalism
@@anthony9013 i think the same… I would have ended my life a long time ago with that much suffering. Sometimes I think there are people living way worse than me, having bigger problems and I am here suffering and hurting for nothing almost
Jeez, I hope to God that things improve for every1 in that country, that the war stops... God bless them docs...
This is heartbreaking...what are we doing to each other and for what?
Im a retired US Soldier and I suffer from severe PTSD, as watching this video, it hurts my heart when I see the subtext and picture of these men saying they can't get over what they have seen and now they are chained together and being tranquilized. This is no why to treat a human being, but our US government does the same to us to this day. They didn't put chains on us but when I came back from Afghanistan, they had me so loaded up on nerve pill, it would knock me out, I didnt remember the 6 months I was in the hospital. I hope everything gets better in Yeman and all countries that has Soldiers dealing with PTSD, its a horrible mental issue
How should they help you?
By not loading you up with meds is one way
They need separation of church and state to start with...
@@314shorts by not starting wars and turning sane people crazy.
Soma Coma...
I'm from Yemen and watching this makes my heart feel so much pain..I hope war comes to an End.
Seeing your own people suffer is a tremendous pain may allah give peace to Yemen my brother
It’s make my Heard feel so much beautiful things 😄
@@wednesdayaddams8334 shaytaan people like you destroy the world god sees this all and he will bring justice
I’m so afraid for my family in Yemen. Allah protect them
@@sarahrose1765 amiin ya rab may Allah protect the people of Yemen
Horrific and heartbreaking! I pray for all of them and I’m so sorry they are enduring this. I pray for healing and freedom for all of these people. 🙏🏽💕
This is completely inhumane and I understand their system is screwed up. I’m just so sorry. This world is so cruel
Thank you again, Vice, for increasing my awareness of the world around me. Maybe the greatest reporting of our generation.
Watching this has just created such a weight on my soul. I feel it. This is devastating and want to know how I can help.
hold your government accountable for selling weapons and fueling proxy wars. for example, Sweden says they love human rights and sell weapons to other countries do you see the contradiction.
Some charities like OneNation and MATW are doing a great job providing water, food and medical aid to people. Orphans are also being sponsored.
@@ibrahimhassan711 if we don't fund the proxy war...somebody else will
@@ibrahimhassan711 do the same for your government 🤷🏻♀️
@@maxezaz7694 What is MATW? Websites?
God, I'm in love with Isobel. She's such a good reporter and she's so compassionate and understanding of people's struggles, but gets to the bottom of it.
Couldn't have said it better myself. Love all her reports.
And she is very gorgeous and sophisticated for such a young woman. Hope that’s too much.
I have more respect for the doctor who actually spends his life doing this rather than an attention-seeking woman on camera
@@314shorts @Joseph Santana yet without this "attention seeking woman" you so venomously deride for seemingly no conceivable reason other than jealousy you wouldn't have learned or cared about the doctor
@@Casowsky incorrect, they could just film/interview the doctor as well as people who are there actually helping. Anyone who becomes a reporter is just attention-seeking and lacking in intellect, comparatively to other professions. This isn’t quantitatively-backed, obviously, but is supported by my life experiences with such professionals
props to these families doing something about the severity of the situation instead of just ignoring it.
Thank you for being this to the world and will look for way along my journey in life to help these people somehow. I think there are people that want to help, some with money others with actions, but many times the convenience and opportunities are not there. I hope these come soon…
1:57
...This tears me apart inside.
He is so proud of his calling but he sets aside the trauma.
I say let there be peace for Yemen. 🇾🇪
You can tell doc is extremely smart, just fed up with the situation he is stuck in
Why would you assume that he is dumb in the first place?
@@hobyoprincess I didn’t? Why would you assume that I assumed he is dumb? Are you?
This made me cry. This gets no airtime.
4:34 this man is devoted to helping his patients 🥺
I'm watching this on Sunday night in Singapore grateful for my job, food, shelter, peace and the ability to see a therapist for the stresses I deal with. Brothers and sisters in Yemen and many parts of the world live in a different reality damaged by wars, conflict and illnesses. I can't imagine COVID-19 and climate change on top of all the problems they face. I pray for their well being. Don't know what else I can do from so far away.
Damn that was dark…
Im glad im on the US even though its only a little better here
Watch Africa addio documentary for a darker experience
@@GoSoxxx93 it's MUCH better
Hi kuya wil
God help those people in such dire need of peace. The man and woman in charge of the hospital patients, the mother whose son is in need of help with his mental illness. Their situation is the saddest thing I have ever encountered. God help and protect them, and inspire those who make war to start to make peace so damaged people can be helped.
How absolutely heartbreaking. It goes to show how much suffering is caused by ignorance
We're all going to die from our own arrogance.
i think you mean to say we're all going to hell
Ignorance. most of the key information we need to vote for our politicians are carefully omitted by the media . Had people known about the stuff our politicians have done and their track record, some parties wouldn't even exist as a mainstream as they do now .
Whoah, it's *God's arrogance. Or just his plan & you're complaining.
we, humans, are really rotten to the core. I have a solution i keep in my mind for a long time, a total suicide, but others said I'm crazy. our existence bring pains and of course some hapiness, but i'd rather doesn't exist at all.
@@SlackerU please don't blame God. It's SATAN you must blame. God loves His children and what father would want this for their children although SATAN wants to destroy what God loves and cause his children to suffer. Damn Satan and soon he will be chained in hell for eternity
God bless those who put their lives on the line for others.
Those empathetic people in societies always stick out, in any nation they’re found in. Genuine lights in a dark world and blessings to humanity
Blaming myself he said....what a legend...respect just respect to u Doc
if u r going through something just remember how blessed u r
I feel bad for the mom having to chain her son. I'm sure that was a painful thing to do for her.
Feel bad for the son also. It saddens me that he might end up chained permanently. Very very sad.
My heart aches how the Doctor spoke about this difficult situation. I hope anyone in some kind of power that's able to help will see this video. Even if it's a little help, everything counts. I blame myself for not educating myself on these tragical situations earlier. God bless
That last family, the mother who chains her own son, it’s so sad, but you can see they feel they have no choice. He’s violent, he’s attacked her many times and they can’t afford to bring him back and forth to the hospital, it’s not his fault either the poor man, but they are doing what they have to do. It’s just so sad.
I'm glad this reporter is covering these stories about Yemen
Brub, I feel sorry for this doctor. Why is he blaming himself. If hes doing his best and doesn't have resources.
He wants you to think that
@@samsonsoturian6013 some people have morals sorry you haven’t met any
@@faizaanwar3662 I somehow have a feeling that's an ironic statement from you.
There are many clues in the video, the doctor getting angry and defensive when asked about conditions for the patients is only one of them.
Where do these guys get their funding? There's no government and the families of the inmates can't afford to feed their own kids. Are they getting paid by the same militias that are recommending these men get locked up?
The inmate's speech was guarded and they were quite calm and gave the most basic facts about themselves in spite allegedly being crazy and tied up. This likely means they get in trouble for complaining.
Also, they tied all these guys up because escapes are both their biggest problem and biggest concern.
And finally, the people running the show are NOT qualified healthcare professionals.
All this together and it seems this asylum is largely fraudulent. It's a prison for hire taking inmates from anyone who will pay.
@@samsonsoturian6013 These are all assumptions and the man is probably doing his best to help the people where ever they came from
@@faizaanwar3662 assumptions? You didn't read what I said because this ain't a conspiracy theory. And I repeat, these people are not doctors and they're paid to keep people locked up in the "asylum."
This is really heart-breaking. Even in the most developed countries, peaceful times, and with far more resources, mental health treatment is often still insufficient. I can't imagine how difficult it must be struggling with the same conditions in a country torn apart by war, with no real resources to devote to helping you. I hope these people find peace, and that those treating them find some comfort and recognition in the work they're doing.
I'm currently off-work being supported by my family, on medication and going to therapy. I wouldn't have access to any of that in 60% of the world
@@TheJerbol ALL CAPS
I understand the illness suffered from the patients in this video. They have gone through life and death situations everyday. Its truly understandable.
I dont understand those who claim they have mental health issues because of "work stress" and mundane life cycle and then, announcing on social media that theyre gonna commit suicide. Thats attention seeking and the only medicine for them is beatings to put some sense in their soft snowflake asses.
this video made me cry a lot. just the dr. and the end :(
I stop to watch because I'm crying. This Woman is very nice and courageous...I am myself mentally ill.
It's so sad that war can cause such impact to the lives of people.
I salute the doctor.
I salute the nurse.
I understand the mother who chained his son.
This report has brought me to tears. Yemen has been forgotten in the Western world and it's most vulnerable are stuck being treated like cattle. The war needs to stop. Countries need to unite and help build and protect hospitals!
Why should the west care about a bunch of muslims trying to wipe each other out ?
The West needs to let the others figure it out on their own. They do not like us most of the time and have very (sometimes well placed I'll admit ) hate towards the West.
This is a good video thanks.
I deal with a lot of mental illness and trauma disorders- I came here horrified but it’s really not their fault. You can only do your best with what you have and you can’t have what isn’t there. It breaks my heart for the staff and the people who really desperately need that little available help.
It’s bad enough here in the U.K. this is horrific truly but I wouldn’t blame the doctor. He clearly cares a lot.
Same here, I thought our healthcare system was down the pan but this shows me how blessed we really are in a lot of ways. I wish you peace, health and safety going forward, dealing with trauma is very difficult but I hope you can get to a better place in time ❤ 🙏
Isobel seemed like she was going to cry before the doctor said "Blaming myself is the only thing which I can do". That guy is in a tough position and it must've been hard to see what she saw.
3:00 - tragic. It’s the easiest thing in the world to criticize imperfect situations.
Thank you for the truth
This man needs support to do more..🤷🏻♀️💖✨
i feel for the mother, what a horrible question to ask her "some people would say how could a mother chain her son" how dumb of a question to make her feel horrible to choose to protect her self and her family. i know what its like to live with an untreated schizophrenic man, and its the most traumatizing thing, mentally and physically destroying to the people living with him. the fact that this mother chose to chain her son in their home rather than kill him and abandoned him; speaks volumes of her love for him even after everything he's done to her! i wish i could give them all the money they need to get treatment but all i can offer is my prayers for now. may Allah protect the families and the mentally ill and soon provide them with the relief they need.
People suffer while most live a good life. I pray for the ones suffering and thank God for what blessing I have now. Amen.
Most?
This is beyond heartbreaking
If only this doctor could see that, because of this exposure, he DOES have so much support from the outside world, even if only from individuals on their couches. I just wish we could all somehow like, sign a card or something to send to him, so he has a tangible piece of human support for the particularly difficult and heavy position he is in. ❤ feeling for everyone featured in the video
Another amazing piece of media.
Isobel's the guarantee
Isobel's the GOAT.
It’s all because these never ending stupid senseless wars. Hopefully future generations can solve issues without the endless bickering and war.
Wars will never end as long as humanity is on this planet sadly.
@@kaym7704 i don't believe that and i don't think you do either. all it takes is for people to create a more powerful weapon. after the invention of the nuke, we had almost 80 years of peace. people only respond to the stick or carrot and with that logic wars will stop existing in the near future if people create a terrifying weapon. not to say there won't be small skirmishes or insurgencies but no massive scale wars.
@@ibrahimhassan711 we have that weapon already, the atomic bomb, it's a weapon of peace, nations who own that weapon do not fight wars against each other any longer, they learnt to live with what they have since the risk of losing what they have outweighed the risk of what they could win in such a nuclear war.
Unfortunately, those who have the weapon of peace are against everyone having it because then they lose the biggest market in the world, the weapon market which thrives from non-nuclear wars.
...so for as long as there exists Greed in mankind, wars will always be present and from today's point of view...wars will never end, sadly.
Don’t only call senseless wars say it how it is . We see an aggressors with bombs from different country and a victim within their own territory. Am not yemeni but that is how I see it. So who is to blame?
It’s not senseless for the LEGITIMATE Yemeni government to take responsibility and do its JOB by protecting Yemenis from foreign influenced GANG attempting to take power in Yemen by force! TRUE Yemenis see what’s happening in Lebanon with iran supporting hezbolla and we Yemenis don’t want that garbage in our country with iran supporting the houthis leading to yet another failed state in the Middle East!
houthis had a chance to be a part of the flourishing democratic process that was born post dictator saleh’s departure but chose to take power in Yemen by force via iranian support now they will either eat dirt or go live in their host country iran as houthis WILL NEVER BE ACCEPTED BY YEMENIS!!!!!!!!!
Yemen for Yemenis
Saudi Arabia for Saudis
iran for iranians and their puppets the houthis
This doctor is a hero. At least he is trying. At least he is still there. He is doing what he can.
Watching that doctor made me cry he is so stressed and he is getting blamed for all of that he shouldn't be blamed for this the man is suffering he does make a point.
This is incredibly depressing
This is such a sadness. The families and medical staff are literally at their breaking point. Trying to do the best they can with such limited resources.
Unlike the delicate flowers that are western citizens, the medical staff is nowhere near breaking point. Don’t make the mistake of assuming that your delicate nature and paper cut emergencies are shared by the rest of the world.
Anytime I feel like I’m having a hard day…I think of the doctors, nurses, the family members and finally …the people who suffered mental anguish with no support
The doctor, the nurse and the mother are all genuine people when giving a response to a question about getting mental help… I honestly felt her answer before she even said it… I’m devastated and heartbroken the Yemeni people are suffering needlessly from the constant day in and day out of war… Everyone with little money and help suffer more when the richest people are out there causing chaos just for their enjoyment… No more wars… let there be peace… and my the doctor, the nurse and the mother as the rest sleep well and peacefully at night
this doctor has some type of passion about his job... can def feel it ... he is doing what he can with what he was given ... bless this whole situation for all involved
The world might have stopped caring about Yemen but I have not. My heart goes out to all the people in yemen who are struggling.
Your not alone. I’m strongly thinking of moving there.
@@interestingg where do you live now??
@@darrencole7379 UK and you?
@@interestingg why would you put your life in struggle and danger?
@@inamdarsaquib9528 I’m happy to give up my luxury life here to help the orphans in Yemen. Just waiting for the right time to move there.
I think about Yemen so much 🙏🏽 Praying for peace and the end of a selfish war
When you have a mental health issues you are imprisoned with in yourself just imagine actually being chained and imprisoned at same time that's bought some bad memories back for me