Animation vs. Physics
์์ค ์ฝ๋
- ๊ฒ์์ผ 2023. 12. 08.
- Come on guys... it's not rocket science
๐ ASK ME ANYTHING! โบ krplus.net/unoogai89join
๐ MERCH! โบ alanbecker.shop
๐ฌDISCORD SERVER โบ / discord
๐น๏ธANIMATORS VS GAMES โบ @AnimatorsVSGames
๐ทINSTAGRAM โบ / alanbecker
โ๏ธTWITTER โบ / alanthebecker
๐น๐ถWRITER๐ถ๐น
Terkoiz
๐น๐ถANIMATION๐ถ๐น
Terkoiz
@ARCpersona
@eds7236
@CoreAdro
@NotSoProishNoob
@n8sterAnimates
@doumaki4501
@Ellis02Media
@Fordz
@favfaris4714
@Hexalhaxel
@AnimatedZorox
@SimpleFox1
@smoilysheep4670
@Shuriken255
@Nemo0501
@kayalartwork
@jasonthe2343
@ajanimm
@ShadowQrow
@DevilBoyAnimation
๐น๐ถ3D๐ถ๐น
@UnderMineBlox
๐น๐ถSOUND DESIGN๐ถ๐น
/ e_soundwork
@dan_loeb
๐น๐ถEDITOR๐ถ๐น
@dan_loeb
๐น๐ถ MUSIC๐ถ๐น
@ScottBuckley
๐น๐ถ PRODUCTION MANAGER๐ถ๐น
@hatena360 - ์ํ/์ ๋๋ฉ์ด์
![[Original Song] ์ฐ์ฃผ๋ฏธ์(Would You M.I.A) ใ
ฃ๊ถ๋ฏผ&์ํ๊ณ &ํฐํ๋](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/cApabFGK8VA/mqdefault.jpg)
If anything isn't accurate, blame my lead animator, he's the physics nerd behind this. Watch the reaction/commentary here: krplus.net/bidio/csh9op6blaCbeqQ
W
25์ด ์
ong fr fr
nice
yoo
The Cowboy hat was clever. At first I thought it was just a random aesthetic choice until I realized it also was there to contextualize TSC's rotational position in 3D space, since otherwise we wouldn't be able to tell what direction his body was facing unless the surrounding objects and environment were not symmetrical in shape, which most of them were.
im pretty sure its also a reference to dr strangelove
โ@@maxberardi2146I was gonna say, riding a rocket with a cowboy hat is pretty on the nose if you know what he's referencing. Lol
It's also an homage to Major Kong in Dr. Strangelove riding an atomic bomb, after it falls from the bomb bay of his plane, waving his cowboy hat the whole way down.
It also visually differentiates which TSC we've been following.
@@DPSFSU Space Cowboy Reference?
Alan successfully escalated from classical mechanics to string theory
As a fellow person to understand string theory, I also understand that, simply through one wormhole, which can also be said as an opened wormhole, which would be held open by a type of matter that humanity most likely will never understand, there is a copy of our universe which just might have live that does understand this strange matter, and does understand everything we do not.
Actually, Alan casually
@@westongriffin9338 Is it like Quantum Immortality?
Halfway through the video the physics became so theoretical to the point of fantasy, probably why physics is so fascinating to alot of people.
@@Amogus-nj6dh what?
Little did everyone know, when Orange entered into the quantum realm, he had entered into a state of quantum superposition of all of his possible states. The very last time the wave function collapsed was when he picked up the string particle and turned it into a rocket, thus, that particle with energy interacted with him. After that point, he was forever in a state of quantum superposition of all of his possible states, so all of the decisions he will ever make for the rest of his life will forever be caught in a state of quantum entanglement with this very day, and the future is everything.
Well, that is, until he picks up another particle. But he's gotta do that at the same time as he exits the quantum realm.
But ultimately this is not possible to get into the quantum realm through a black hole or any other way ๐
Ok this actually gives me the goosebumps bro. ๐ญ
But it made me wonder (dunno if this is real) if our future selves is the present self trying to change or alter directions our past self is doing. Man the universe is so mysterious
what is this alien speak i dont understand ๐ญ๐ญ
we knew bro.
@thetank2997 but I understand it
Learning physics in schoolโ
Learning physics from alan beckerโ
Edit: wow ๐ฒ so much likes ๐ฟ๐ท
*Second Coming, the most committed devotee in Physics, decides to challenge you into this Physics duel. How much knowledge do you know? Will you survive the beats of unusual laws of Physics?*
Cara eu adoro seus vรญdeos alan backer
Cara vc ta certo
@@NguyenMinh792 bruh its not my subject i will study physics this year ๐
As a physics student THIS has to be THE greatest video I have ever seen on youtube. This will motivate a lot of people to explore physics.
Bust
@MrRiley2007 Nice try
Exactly wish I seen this before I failed my physics exam
Are you physics students? Nice -w -
Nah
As a physicist, this isn't a short film; this is a piece of art that is a perfect way to visually learn the world of physics.
I understood most of the stuff up until the stick figure was in the black hole, what was happening in there?
as a not physicist, I didn't learn anything from this video.
Does breaking reality itself with time in singularity considering as psychics?
โ@@danielhuelsman76 don't worry, we in physics don't really know either. That's the fun part
Yeh 100% its incredible. I can't get over how good this is โค
I will always remember, what Nature (probably) actually is:
We got Math, which is the language of Science, used in the science Physics that uses Math to explain the nature of energy, space, time and whatnot, used in the science Chemistry, which creates a world where particles (Electrons, Neutrons and Protons) interact with each other on the basis of Physics (and thus Math) to create elements and all the possible compounds between them, used in the science Biology, which applies these elements and compounds to nature, which interact with and create life through the sub-science organic chemistry and its compounds.
With all of this, almost all the 'non-sciences' get created, as a result of life interacting with other life, as a result of biology, as a result of chemistry, as a result of physics and finally, as a result of Maths.
History, Literature, Social Sciences, Medicine, Economy, Geography, Art (Memes lol), Music and much, much more boil down to this moment in Timeโข๏ธ.
Now, to try to explain the reason for all of this, you need Philosophy (or Religion). Humans created Math and it worked, works and will probably continue working, so its all connected to each other, even if apparently far-fetched!
*Crazy, isn't it?*
This took way to long.
\o/
Math is the fundament of Physics, Physics is the law of the universe, while Chemistry is the nature of matter. When these materials combine in a certain order, they form and nurture living entities.
everything is always connected
This is a beautiful comment on yt ๐ขdefinantly gonna use a Lin for graduation quote
No, it's not Nature that's all.
And the Creator! Because he is an Architect. Calculated, Measured, Weighed. This is how he laid the foundation for the harmonious order of the Universe.
And nature is just the nature of the surrounding world, it was not nature that created such laws of physics, only by the power of the Creator!
It's enough!
we theoretically CAN create an electromagnetic propulsion ring launcher in space! It would need thrusters on both sides of the ring to keep it stabilized and to aim us where we want to go. A space craft would need a strong electromagnetic field around it and properly set up so the positive and negative forces are on each end of the ship, and you would need to be properly stationed on the opposite end of what the front of the ships magnetic property (repulsion or attraction) is, and with the magnet being powered it could be a controlled launch!!! 8:38
@elijahkeeley nope! With the ring magnet have a positive attraction on one side and a negative attraction on the other side it will first pull you in and then propell you away from it
@@lightwolf2497 but on either side, the poles are opposites, therefore either side has attraction? so they would have to turn off in order to avoid undoing the acceleration
@@angeld23 what i thought is if we can create a single magnetic poles for example, both sides are negative. when we met the ring with positive charge they would pull us in while in the other side, negative charge of ring meet with our space craft negative charge they wouldn't pulling us back
@@Zeus-ju4hw How does single poled magnet make sense
@@anusthanbhandari2766 i mean take a sample of a rocket, using two magnet on both side of the rocket
Please never stop doing these. Biology, Chemistry, Logic, History, anything you think you can display the concepts of with your teams incredible animation. Thank you.
Would be cool seeing a animation vs history like a time warp so like the Titanic and Napoleon
Agreed. These are REALLY educational and addicting. They mix the intuitive visuals of 3Blue1Brown with the amazing story telling of Alen Becker.
You probably don't want history.
I wonder what history would be like
History sounds cool
The first half was a revision of my high school physics, and the second half was simply a cinematic masterpiece
It ain't no cinematics it's the laws of the univrrse
@@Soviet_government_ Yes - the laws of the universe, displayed in a cinematic way, masterfully (a cinematic masterpiece).
@@Soviet_government_ it was still cinematic
@@ungamer6241I think he meant to say Kinematics (branch of mechanics regarding motion)
@@ZeroTempz could be
As a MP student (Maths Physics) these videos are just awesome. It is really fun to notice every single theory and theorem that we have been learning in class.
Thanks Alan ๐ซก
I feel the same !
Now, we all need 'Animation vs Chemistry'.
noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooi hate the Chemistry
@@sgstaw5 ch3ch2ch2ch2ch2ch2ch3 go brrr
@@sgstaw5 I hate it too, but Alan will sure make it compelling and change your mind
All I remember about chemistry is most of it is basically addition. There's definitely more to it, but I don't remember anything past high school chemistry lmao.
@@main.ignisha All I remember from chemistry is me putting the wrong solution in stuff and the beaker exploded
Youโve seen destroying Minecraft with Minecraft and destroying Math with Math, but have you seen destroying Physics with Physics?
first
edit: why is everyone getting mad at my comment? im just saying first, and plus, yes nobody cares about me saying first so what's your point
And?
nope, this is a cool comment though
yes actually, just try a physics question that asks to divide by zero
HAH
From watching animator vs animation when I was a literal child to seeing this as an aerospace engineer, I thank you for creating one of the most top quality content that has ever existed on the internet during so many years
Glad to see another aerospace engineer here too!
Literally the exact same thing with me. i started watching him so long ago and now seeing this as an aerospace engineer is so awesome
Respect to you and alan becker bro
I was wondering why his name sounded familiar to me when I ran into this video. I saw the old video again and got a wave of nostalgia.
His improvement is amazing
YOO YOUR WORKING MY DREAM JOB HOWS IT LIKE
Now do it with another subjects!!! (chemistry, biology etc)
(Man, that magnetics part is SO AWESOME, i've studied that in school)
Sorry, bad english.
Ei vc e do Brasil eu sou do 6 ano e nรฃo entendi muito o vรญdeo me explica
โโโโ@@LucasOliveira-ij5wd Bem, รฉ muito complicado para explicar, vou tentar simplificar as coisas, mesmo que sou ruim em fรญsica, para comeรงar, o prรณprio tรญtulo do vรญdeo รฉ: fรญsica, รฉ uma matรฉria que comeรงa a estudar a partir de 5ยฐ ou 6ยฐ sรฉrie. Ainda รฉ cedo para entender, mas, se quiser ver vรญdeos de fรญsica, รฉ um bom comeรงo para ver, acredito que tรชm vรญdeos que sรฃo fรกceis de entender, mas, a maioria dos cรกlculos sรฃo difรญceis de entender. Vou editando pouco a pouco... Vai ser bem longo e tem muitas coisas que eu nem imaginava e nunca estudei essas teorias por serem bem complexos/complicado para compreender...
0:20 distรขncia, o ponto onde o TSC ou The Second Coming (o personagem de cor laranja) caminha.
0:30 velocidade, a letra v รฉ a velocidade, nesse caso a velocidade que ele caminhou.
0:40 eu nรฃo sei traduzir, se eu nรฃo me engano รฉ deslocamento ou distรขncia, indica o deslocamento percorrido por ele, provavelmente com a presenรงa de linhas sรฃo o deslocamento percorrido no sentido ร direita, o total e a esquerda, a ordem de cima para baixo.
Vou tentar editar o resto mais tarde...
Mas, sรณ posso dizer que o vรญdeo em si estรก repleto de cรกlculos que รฉ diferente da matemรกtica. Alguns, que a partir do foguete ou a imรฃ, acredito que tem ligaรงรฃo com astronomia, a maรงรฃ desintegrada se refere a biologia (essa matรฉria tem a mesma sรฉrie da fรญsica, como se diz, substitui a ciรชncia para biologia) ou ciรชncia (a partir de 2ยฐ ou 3ยฐ sรฉrie que comeรงa a estudar), por fim, ele encontrando com ele mesmo volta para a fรญsica, o final do vรญdeo eu nรฃo entendi nada... Vou ver direito e tentarei explicar.
Observaรงรฃo: o comentรกrio que vocรช viu estรก em inglรชs, traduzindo: agora faรงa outra matรฉria (quรญmica, biologia e outros)
(Cara, a parte da magnรฉtica รฉ TรO DAORA, eu jรก tinha estudado na escola)
Espero que entendeu o que editei, desculpa se ficou longo, e acho que tem um vรญdeo com um professor reagindo com esse vรญdeo. Acho que ele explica melhor do que eu.
@@SoulierKaiser Obrigado amigo vc e de qual sรฉrie eu sou do 6 ano bora ser amigos?
@@LucasOliveira-ij5wd tenho 30 anos, eu jรก estudei certos cรกlculos de fรญsica. Mas, nem todos por ser complexo.
Se quiser ser meu amigo, tudo bem. Depois vou tentar continuar a traduzir, ou vou tentar encontrar o vรญdeo de um professor que encontrei.
Bro... I'm tearing up, that was so beautifully done. Don't even get me started with the sounds and music... I'm honestly freaked out rn because I swear I've seen this exact video a long time ago... it feels so familiar... like home.
As a guy who loves physics, I absolutely love this, from classical mechanics to general relativity, then quantum mechanics. Alan and his team are do amazing job at this
I'm not a physics expert/nerd. But I do know my fair share of knowledge about physics and I understood most of the concepts of physics in this video.
I hate the physics subject that we learn at school bc itโs so boring, but i actually find this even more interesting and a better way to learn.
bro i actually play psp on all class of physice on the back
Yo at the end i think what they mean (or not) is matter is infinite, you canโt destroy or create it as with the portal at the end / beginning
Math>Physics
Alan deserves an Oscar award
Wazzup bro
Whoโs Oscar
10 mins ayo
2 min
โ@@deaconation7013oscar is like thropy
15:32 I love like in this moment you represented the Kardashev's Scale and different universes, and also Types of beings according to his Scale. Thank you a lot for this work and this moment in particular
The Story ๐ค๐ป
The Music ๐ค๐ป
The Acting ๐ค๐ป
The Visuals ๐ค๐ป
The Concept ๐ค๐ป
The Animation ๐ค๐ป
The Screenplay ๐ค๐ป
The Character(s) ๐ค๐ป
The Cinematography ๐ค๐ป
This is an absolute masterpiece worthy of multiple awards and recognition. โจ
Kudos to Alan for taking us on this journey of minimalism combined with complexity and science. ๐
This short film deserves a special screening. โค
Fax bro
italy
True
โ@@lcareoHey I'm italian
Fr
I don't think that just anyone gets how wide and complex this must have been not only to animate, but to calculate and put together *as a story*. I know you touch a lot on what Interstellar did already, but I think this shows far more of just how physics works altogether than Interstellar did. Watching the video, I had absolutely no words. This - was - insane.
This is simply - godsent.
I dont understand why anyone would dislike this, it's amazing.
I agree, I was just amazed, with my mouth opened, this animation, together with those concepts of Physic, It was an unique experience, imma save that video to show it to some people later... Its wonderfull
Eh, it isn't exactly "Calculated". Don't let those numbers fool you, it's far from accurate. But this is art, and in art, the proximation is more important than accuracy.
Indeed, I felt the same as you did man this was incredible
TSC might be the smartest of the entire cast, Because he already got into tons of disciplines that require math. And he learned a lot already
Iโm about to say so
I like how orange just saw an apple headed into a black hole and thought, 'well, only one thing to do now!', and just yeeted himself into the black hole without a second thought.
But all in all,(as far as I kow), everything was perfectly accurate. I got most of the formulas and the theories, but when orange started falling into the black hole, my brain stopped working fr. ๐คฉ
I can see a lot of physics teachers dedicating 16 mins in one of lectures so they can have their students watch this masterpiece for many years to come. This will inspire a lot of students to consider exploring physics. What happens in the singularity and beyond in this video is a nod to Interstellar, I assume.
Finally found this w comment
โ@@sleppistickman5742.....
Interstellar was based on real physics, its a reference to CTCs, tho it is definitely a creative interpretation since no one knows what it's actually like
ๆไน่ฟไน่ฎคไธบ
Physics students will absolutely watch this for forever, I don't understand it, but maybe one day I will
This was absolutely stunning to watch. I canโt wait to see what comes next!
Maybe an โAnimation VS Chemistryโ?
Chemistry is so much more complex than most people realise, and the kinds of things you can do with it are nuts.
chemistry nerd over here lol, it would be amazing if they did. (just a suggestion though.)
Animation vs Chemistry would go crazy ngl
as a chemistry student i was going to request this too!
No way orange can live against a black hole ๐๐๐
breaking bad?
Iโve been struggling with physics for quite some time now, and motivation has been a serious issue. This animation has filled me with inspiration to pursue a life of physics and Iโm more motivated than ever, thank you for this masterpiece โค๏ธ
The physics here seems mostly fine, with the most glaring errors being:
Throwing a ball forward while on a frictionless surface would grant the thrower equal linear momentum to that of the thrown ball in the opposite direction. Upon stopping, the momenta of the thrower and ball would perfectly cancel and their joint center of mass would not have moved. That aside, neither the ball nor the stick man should have been able to come to rest on the frictionless surface to begin with.
The magnetic acceleration system seems to be an ill-conceived coil gun? If the large magnet rings are spontaneously demagnetizing at the moment the rocket reaches their center, it works, otherwise, the force of the magnetic field pulls backward on the rocket just as hard as it pulled forward and the net momentum gain is zero.
The paradoxical situations are so cool but they hurt my brain at the same time
Also, this is probably one of TSC's strongest versions as he can literally manipulate physics and has an understanding of it.
I think itโs just an interstellar reference
not once did he directly manipulate physics in this video lol not too sure what you're talking about my g
Up until now the strongest version was creative block that would destroy the Minecraft universe
With this addition, he has become a sort of higher dimensional existance that can manipulate time and space and physic concepts as if they were literally toys
โ@@youtuber-tg1puVery cool reference to our existence, dude. Very well "spoken".
@@djmewtwo6981no itโs the awakened version
It's so amazing a lot of physics was covered in a 15 minute story. Also, it's absolutely mind-blowing that a story with no words written or spoken can be so interesting
The most interesting thing about this is that it can be understood by anyone anywhere in the world
If you haven't seen Alan's other work, he does a LOT of wordless storytelling, especially in some of his more recent work like Animation vs Minecraft Season 3 and Animator vs Animation 6.
The things he manages to convey are seriously awesome.
Sim/yeah๐ฎ๐ฎ๐ฎ
It's 16 minutes and 18 seconds to be exact ๐ .
Came for the animation, stayed for the existential questions. ๐น
I'm a physics student, I'm extremely fascinated by this video, I could understand everything and my mentality was taken to new frontiers, thank you for everything Alan and your animator!!
This was freaking beautiful! I almost cried at the end! Your videos make math make sense and I always enjoy the animation but this one was soulful. Wonderful job!
I really hope this series continues. Animation vs. Chemistry, anyone? Could have a great time building up new elements and eventually leading to the atomic bomb and such.
I would watch this
How about creating a DNA?
โ@@ayzekpie9432that's shown in this video
Animation vs Biology
Animation vs. Geometry would be great!
From "vs Math" a few months ago to "vs Physics" just now, this has been a gloriously geeky animated semester. Thank you so much for these, Alan.
Thank Terkoiz too. He's the one who lead this.
I think he will release Animation vs. Chemistry :)
So Epic
@@hungmcsr8562 oh I can't wait for that :)))
Oh my gosh, that was one of the most amazing videos Iโve ever watched on KRplus. It was just as informative and illustrative as a class lecture, but it was so much more creative, humorous, and awe inspiring. Thank you so much for making this (and the animation v.s. math video). Watching this has helped me really understand and remember why I want to study Physics. Itโs helped me remember why Iโve always loved this felid, even as a kid, and it motivates me to continue that childhood goal of knowledge and exploration. Thank you again for all the long hours it must have taken to make this masterpiece. โค
my man just compressed 12 years of physics at school into a 16 minute video
Great job man!
school? String theory :D yes
I havenโt learned Doppler effect and physics of black holes, but luckily someone explained it to me
Good job man๐๐
The video feels like physics class. It starts out easy and suddenly it gets complicatedt
yeah but if you haven't learned them you won't understand anything
As a physics student, this was incredible - the way so many complex ideas, from Lorentz shifts to gravitational slingshots to Schrodinger's equation, can be expressed so aesthetically and easy to digest and curiosity inducing for all viewers is amazing.
I don't know what you're talking about, i couldn't understand a thing.
Is that possible ?
I have huge respect for people who has anything to do with Physics as a career. Physics is extremely fascinating!
I counted the frames where orange walked 1.5 meters, he walked 1.5 meters in 12 frames, which meant he could walk 60m/s which is 6 times faster than Usain Bolt.(correct me if I'm wrong)
I am not a physics student, nor have I ever been.. but I understood the concepts for at least half of the video.. then it got confusing
That was _exquisite._ From high school kinematics to whatever lies beyond the limits of our understanding. Thank you for it.
Genuinely astonishing, both in terms of animation, storytelling, and the dedication to explaining the physics behind everything. Giving this the highest praise I can.
Regardless of how well you understand physics, this video is a great showcase of music and sound design! Everything from the velocity equations being calculated to the change in pitch made from varying speeds of probability waves as the two TSCs walk toward the Einstein-Rosen bridge portal. It's always fantastic seeing how well Alan seamlessly meshes the aural and visual realms to make something entertaining and enlightening. Plus, it's always a warm sight to recognize some bigger names in the Stickfigure animation community, like Fordz, Shuriken, Hatena, and Terkoiz! Phenomenal job, everyone!
*Einstein
I love how time travel was explained as a causal loop
Nice got a pin
Not only is this an excellent animation, with amazing physics representations, but its also a display of _why_ TSC is the most powerful character in the Animation VS series. He identifies, learns, and masters pretty much anything placed in front of him. Even the most intelligent physicists take a decade or more to learn half of what TSC does in this16 minute video, and though there is no way of knowing how much time elapsed for _him_ between the first and last seconds of the video, you also have to remember he's learning this by himself, with no learning material or teacher. He's incredibly intuitive, amazing adaptable, and remarkably resourceful with everything and anything he is given.
Perfect๐
Honestly, he should be featured in a deathbattle by Screwattack!
I think this is a aspect that all stick-figures have - rapid learning, self-improvement, and photographic memory. I personally head-canon that the AvA universe is where human imagination and concepts come to life and "imprint" into reality, explaining why random stick-figures, video game characters, phone apps, even cave art can turn alive. Due to this, since stick-figures are culturally seen as "badass" going by the thousands of "stick figure fighting" videos, the concept of a stick-figure is a badass by their nature, and a badass can learn concepts really quickly (such as mastering martial arts almost instantly after observing for a minute).
Also explains why the physics dimension seems to work off of our *MODERN* understanding of physics, not a "more complicated" true life version - it's not actually the dimension of physics, its the dimension of humanities *understanding* and *concepts* of physics. Most of the higher end phyics stuff TSC had learnt would probably not even work, because humans don't know if Singularities, Tipler Cylinders, Manifolds, Worldsheets etc even exist aside from "well our current models could work or need to work with these in place."
Also why the Math Dimension uses human Maths, not "real" math - mathmatics as we understand is a language we invented.
he got actual 200 IQ
@@sidratulmursalinbhasha2960 no
This is incredible, the last thing I watched by you was animator vs animation II like 7 years ago, I had no idea you were still doing stuff
First half: School physics revision
Second half: *Reality warping*
5:49 This shot was breath-taking, it didn't feel like an Alan Becker animation anymore, it had evolved into something more. This is why Alan is the most popular animator on KRplus.
FOR REALLL
This is a beautiful work of art
the thing is that it isn't an alan becker animation no more, at least not only him. Its a team that works behind all of the animations in this channel
@@bunashud9793 Yup
sooo it evolved into a rendered sphere? WOAH ๐คฏ๐คฏ๐คฏ
This escalated deep, evolving from just against the animator, to beyond physics and the known. I would like to know how the chosen one has arrived at these places such as the world of mathematics and physics in question. Impressive what Alan came up with, it is a work of art, and without a doubt deserves great recognition.
Same question, where does this video and the maths one fit in the wider timeline? Of AvM and AvA
Itโs the Second Coming tho, the Chosen One is the black one
I think of the physics one to be the continuation of the math one, since in the end of the math one our Chosen One got literally teleported at random into realspace. What is more real of a realspace than a world of pure physics? In other words, he overshot his goal, of home, by quite a bit. XD
Nah, for math he walked into a calculator app and for physics he was snooping in the physics engine of kerbal space program
From what Iโve heard/read. Animation vs Math wasnโt Alanโs idea, it was one of his team members. So he had to trust them that they know what they were doing, and according to an actual Oxford Math professor, who did a reaction video to Animation Vs Math, the math equations in the video are all correct and accurate
So wonderful, the cinematic ambience tells me that Science can give me that goosebumps...
Also, this video also gives a new way to get isekai'ed. My mind is really blown at the end!
"If only Physics was like this"
That's the thing: It is, we just don't see it
You just made physics so interesting to me. The fact that it just ended with it all being a loop is incredible.
Well, if Alan cut off the "the end" and KRplus allowed 15 minutes on shorts, then it would be a perfect loop!
Once you see your future, your past, it started a loop already. Unless at the end, you decide to "loop out", then the loop will end.
Infinity
it was also completely justified, because time and space become each other in the space below the event horizon, it's a logical consequence of the path he took
instead of "this story needs a grand conclusion, lets make it a time travel story now" that some tv shows do...
As a Civil Engineering major (junior), this and "Animation vs. Math" have brought me to tears. BOTH of them beautifully encapsulate the entire reason why I'm still passionate about what I'm studying. Thank you
i earn more than 10k in 1 week without studying lmao
@@cenkkinqzzzz3002job? just curious.
@@mrbigsta4221 its called lying on the internet
@@deathstare0 lmao
@@deathstare0 Nah. He's a politician only job you need little to no skill.
Iโve been watching all your videos for few years at this point and this was genuinely breathtaking, Just imagine this being a high budget movie or a tv show with great visual effects, truly a brilliant job both with the physics and the story line, please bring more these type of content
THIS IS BEAUTIFUL. im a college physics student and i loved this animation. Everything is so well done and carefully animated, its just... perfect. thank you, i can sleep better now haha
I'm not a physics student or a teacher, but I find this stunning. Great animation!
same, I just forget anything i learn especially cause of no interest
Brothers? ๐จ
just the oranges in this chat
im infiltrating the oranges
You have to watch Interstelar. It doesn't go as far as this animation did, but it sure gets pretty close.
I'm a physics student and I'm blown away by this video. It's the most awesome thing I've ever seen on youtube. It makes physics look so cool and fun. I bet a lot of people will want to learn more about physics after watching this.
He literally showed what took me over 3 weeks memorise in 3 seconds
Acho que sou uma dessas pessoas...
You're right!
But not me.
Physics is fun and cool. I've been learning by myself about it and I feel so good about the fact that I understand a lot of the concepts in this video.
Yea
๐คฏ๐คฏ๐คฏ๐งYou deserve an OSKER dude.๐คฏ๐คฏ๐คฏ๐คฏ๐คฏ๐คฏ๐คฏ๐คฏ๐คฏ๐คฏ๐คฏ๐คฏ
It is very impressive that you could put all the different knowledge in Physics and other related subjects in one single video and connect them in one way or another. Thank you very much for making this video public.
This is probably one of the most beautiful renditions of physics Iโve ever seen. Many props to Alan and his team for making physics so entertaining.
the physics looks really cool and real
are youe eje?
the ragdoll physics are gonna be even stronger with this one
True
**Falls Violently**
Fr
4th
Fr
student: teacher, what are we going to use this for?
alan becker: just look
This is by far my favorite animation on this channel, itโs so complex yet so simple at the same time and it is executed so beautifully. You deserve a damn Oscar for this
Oscars are cringe.
Award* not Oscars.
โ@@LuisAngel-sb8xd yeah true
instead of saying "Oscars" they should say "Award" like the guy on top of me
@@LuisAngel-sb8xd Actually oscars are for movies. This is also counted as a short movie so it nominates for oscar awards
@@ImTheOne_WhoAsked yall are going way too in depth with this, the film is good, thatโs all Iโm tryna say, calm down
You have made a real and lasting contribution. I am a physics teacher and will show this for years in my class. I am an animator and I'm aware this must be a labor of love. Whatever it took, it was worth it! Fantastic! You will inspire millions in art, science, whatever!
Omg hi Mr Lawrence
can i get an extension Mr Lawrence
Sir Lawrence let me pass your class
mr lawerence i am a new student i am you
Hello Mr Lawrence I don't know who u r
bro wanted to learn kinematics and ended up discovering he was literally god
Throwing the ball forward wont move him forward. While the ball is about to be left from his hand, the thrower will be slightly pushed back as a reaction force. I believe this is quite a simple mistake.
I am in awe. The only thing missing here is Orange looking in a telescope size of a planet and seeing Alan and his team beyond the microwave background radiation.
Alan and his team are the canonical gods of the animation vs academia (thatโs what Iโm calling this branch of spin offs)
@@Anonyomus_commenter that's a genius name idea
It's also missing the Red, Blue, Green and Yellow, and Blue cooking something from the very fabric of reality. ๐น
โ@@Anonyomus_commenterCould also be animation vs academy
The shift from classical physics to Newtonian physics to Magnetism to Modern physics to black holes to Quantum physics was so satisfying to watch.
And then the few minutes of string theory at the end
And to theoretical physics
โ@@trbz_8745ะะฐ! ะะฝะฐัะธั ั ะฑัะป ะฟัะฐะฒ ััะพ ััะพ ัะตะพัะธั ััััะฝ, ััะฐ!
Chem teacher here... I'm thinking about the moment at 2:17 where Orange uses a weighted "lasso" to propel himself across a frictionless surface. He does this by throwing the weight and letting the "tug" on the rope pull him forward. According to Newton's 3rd, this shouldn't be possible, right??? When he throws the weight, it should apply an equal opposite force, which pushes him backwards. And then when the weight pulls the rope tight, there should be equal forces acting in opposite directions along the axis of the rope. Thus, everything should "cancel" and he should have a net displacement of zero meters. lmk if this is wrong *shrug*
Not a scientist, but the way I interpereted it was that the "ice" begins as only near-frictionless, but later transitions into a perfectly frictionless surface.
Orange seems to have at least some friction, given the way they slow down after throwing the ball lasso. And when pulling the ball in the first time, an arrow in the opposite direction (possible representing friction?) appears. Whether Newton's law still allows this I can't really say.
Maybe it's the angular momentum being transitioned to a purely forwards momentum after building up velocity, since the angular momentum is just coming from the force of Orange's arm alone?
I see the same problem. But the comment before me could have already answered it.
You're correct. It's impossible. The magnetism explanation also doesn't work as he's adding energy to the system without doing any work, and there are tons of issues with the black hole part obviously.
It's a fun little video, but it's not a perfect explanation of physics.
@@aust2354 That's a fair point. (Newton's laws apply with or without friction.) Upon closer inspection there's a small arrow that shows mu = 0.1, which means there's technically a small amount of friction. So technically he could "lasso" himself across the ice.
the โForce by throwing the weightโ is cancelled according to Newtonโs 3rd Law, but Rotating the weight makes centrifugal force and its reaction(=-centripetal force). when he threw the rotating weight at โSpecific timeโ, the angular momentum has transformed(A lot has been omitted, but as a result) as horizontal momentum to the surface made him go forward.
If Orange rotate the weight, he starts spinning on the frictionless surface.
So the โSpecific timeโ should satisfy;
1. When Spinning Orange is Facing to Forward,
2. When Rotating Weight is at 90deg to Forward.
no hitting into things. safe for the being. looks great
its rather scary that the whole animation starts off as a normal little story about orange having fun with physics and then becomes a complex situation about a supposedly infinite loop jesus christ i had goosebumps watching it all
His name is the second coming not orange
We reached from simple child play kinematics to wave fronts, orbital physics and magnetism in like 6 mins. It was a journey tho !!
Su nombre es the second coming no naranja ๐ก
Thatโs only really if you care about AvA lore
@@Booda428 easier to just call him orange tbh
i love how the thing that motivates him to go into the black hole in the first place, effectively starting everything is an apple, the thing which prompted issac newton to discover physics and effectively start everything
Symbolism Happens
Mavity!
more than that, it is the paracausal apple.
He looks handsome and clever with the cowboy hat
It's like Interstellar xD My first thought when I saw the beginning of the loop xD (If you don't get it, watch the movie, I ain't gonna spoil it.)
this is a cinematic masterpiece.
Did... Did I just get an existential crisis (over the vast finite infinity and the intricate strings of our Universe)... Over an Animation?
God-tier work.
Loved the way you started from basic physics principles and gradually moved to the advanced concepts.
Bro he just went from normal physics to theorical physics, there was no progression what so ever
@@chesterlai9444 You really dont get what he means? He means that the concepts of the physics became more difficult to understand as the video continued. Nobody talked about wether its just theories or real physics
@@chesterlai9444 why someone always Gotta be negative
i might be wrong but... at 7:18 how could he continue go front in the same speed as the space ship?
โ@@user-vw6bd7bb5n Because in space there is as good as no resistance or friction. Lets assume the rocket didnt accelerate. That means that, while orange was on the rocket, the rocket and Orange himself experience the same velocitiy. When he let go of the rocket, he went on having the same speed as the rocket because (like I already said) in space there is most no resistance or friction.Things would change if the rocket was accelerating. Then Orange would stay with a nearly constant velocity when he let go of the rocket while the rocket itself is going faster over time
If you could turn this format into a video game, you'd have an incredibly powerful tool to teach kids physics.
and probably one of the most high quality videogames humanity had ever seen. id be all for it, though its better if alan sticks to animations as making a videogame of this quality could lead to a rockstar games clone lol.
Alright. You will get a reply soon when it's done. Thanks for giving me the challange.
The videogame that comes closest to it that I know is Outer Wilds, wonderful game. Physics is always a wonderful subject if you are interested and ready to learn.
I agree that will help the quote on quote Gamer kids to learn something
GTA 8 :
Question- once Orange crosses the inner event horizon and enters the singularity doesn't he start to set up a demonstration of causality? He is his own reason why he took the trip in the first place: cause and effect. Did i catch that right?
As someone who grew up watching animator vs animation and now studies astrophysics, this is amazing!!
Okay, he's done it. We absolutely need animations based on other science based subjects ๐
Fr
He should do statistics next.
I think Chemestry's next
โ@@Alexander99602 chemistry*
@@pokenath242 no, he said โchemistryโsโ which means chemistry is
As a physics student I can say that this is amazing! I see weโre going for an โinterstellarโ interpretation of singularities, which is cool to see as well.
How many interpretations of singularities is there...
I wanna study physics too๐
singularities aren't confirmed to exist their just theories.@@alphieum3703
@@alphieum3703 too many, trust me, toooo many (i'm physics student too)
Interstellar interpretation is canon according to neil de grasse tyson
Jeez, this is good. As someone equally excited by science and creative media your animation really satisfied both. Well done!
The tone to the music really highlights the beautifully mysterious nature of physics but also the bummer of its constraints.
I was not expecting to see a sequel to Animation vs Math, but this came out amazing. Can't quite grasp the concepts used for this short like I could for the math short (the most I could fully understand was the segment with the rolling balls and the rocket orbiting the planets to gain speed), but it was still amazing to watch. Curious to see where this goes, if we end up getting a part 3.
The sequel we didn't deserve, but needed.
1st
Scares and excites me that I see Alan Becker, out orange boi and the speed of light squared in the same animation
YESS
โ@@bigfuze320the 'orange boi' is named The Second Coming
Yes
As a Physics Major, the entire animation was marvelous. Hope i could had learned physics like this
Go solve your differential equations lil bro.
@@j.a1905 go dive inside my pfp lol
"lil bro๐ค"
Even just as someone in High School with Physics class this was amazing...
Yes, I am a nerdy kid, but still
@@Yourmom082 "lil bro๐ค" - ๐ค
Argue with math, you get a dark souls boss fight
Argue with physics and you get interstellar space travel
Animation vs Electricity would be cool.
My God๐ญ I never expected I will see physics like this, so beautifully done everything, I am so excited, proud and emotional too, like my imagination just came in the way that I can see it through my eyes and will never forget it
Thank you so much animators I respect you a lot๐โค
I am a Mechanical Engineer, finishing my PhD in fluid mechanics, and I was lost from minute 8:56. You guys in Physics are ages ahead of us in Engineering when it comes to the understanding of the universe's laws and theories. Hats off.
You can get up to about the 12:40 mark from educational KRplus videos. I'm CompSci but I have an addiction to staying up late watching PBS Space Time videos which made this make a lot more sense.
So, you drop the hat in the video.
As someone who only got as far as a Bachelor's in physics, 11:33 is the boundary of my understanding. Maybe I should be watching PBS Space Time lmao
As someone who didnt understand what was going on, it looked cool.
As a high scool student, I've lost it after the 4:40 mark.๐ข
This has blown my mind in ways i can't even express.
Also the fact that its basically an endless loop makes this even more jarring and actually quite spooky. Alan has blessed us with another one of his animations.
@@MrRiley2007 nah
This is so true.
Yeah, a loop with various differences every time. Which obviously means this isn't canon ๐
@@Marukanitel I mean, we are inside tsc dream
Iโd say itโs more a time *fold* than a loop.
Nerdy stuff. does physics inevitably descend into theology?
This is a really cool palindrome. how can something so simple be so complicated
I like how math and physics were both given their own little world revolving around the subject. Math stems out far further than what was actually shown but even with everything it ended up being absolutely amazing, and now a world revolving around the very thing that makes everything around us into what it is... I can't wait to see what's next.
whats next is most likely either gonna be chemistry or biology as those are the next two subjects in science that are this fascinating when delved into, but who knows, alan could easily surpise us with something we wouldnt have expected.
Since what's the "science" subject as we know it is ramified into both Physics and Chemistry (at least where I live), we can just wait for "Animation vs Chemistry"
next one will probably be chemistry if we are working in order of purity
chesmitry and they cook meth
This has to be the greatest masterpiece I've seen. The Minecraft one was good, the math one greater, and you reached different levels here. I hope your team does more of these videos in the coming days.โค
As an Engineer, this has touched my heart deeply. It even brought me to tears. Thank you so much for sharing this to the world! Subscribed.
Woah, I'm a student who is studying physics rn and this made me aware of what I'm in for. This video definitely excited me for all this and scared of how complicated it's gonna be. โบ Thank you so much for this mind-warping video, Alan and Crew!
Somos 2 ๐
So true๐
Good luck guy
As someone who is very much into physics and basically every branch of Science, I highly think this is one of the most impressive piece of sci-art I've ever seen. It's so beautifully rendered. The entire video just shows/makes you realise how humanity has understood the physical/natural laws during its thousands of years of the existence of their curiosity. It's so impressive, cool and surreal whenever I see in that perspective.
are youe elso?wwi
Itโs very amazing to see the full scale of all physics, I would like to see new sciences like chemistry or astronomy, will we see this in the next episodes?
we have animation vs math and animation vs physics now all we need is animation vs chemistry and animation vs biology
I love this dude. You're demonstrating not only physics but now TIMELINES? It's incredible to see TSC just have to repeat things over and over.
Iโm new to Alan Becker but what is TSC
โ@@ImSomebody249The Second Coming, the orange stick figure
โโ@@ImSomebody249it's the orange stickman name, I forgot what it is stand for but you can still search it up or the full name
Edit: Alright just read the comments and it's stand for The Second Coming (TSC)
@@ImSomebody249 You'll want to watch alan becker's animator vs animation series to really figure everything out
great interstellar reference :D
I hardly ever comment on videos, but I have to say as a student studying physics at University, this has to be one of the most incredible pieces of art on the platform. Of course I'm biased, but thank you Alan!
"This next test applies the principles of momentum to movement through portals. If the laws of physics no longer apply in the future... God help you."
Since that i haven't Physics at school, this demostrates how physics work on a simple way that I even understand. Great work making this and keep this on for the future.
"Interstellar" in brief..
Greatest video of all time... Deserve appreciation..
Yeah, and all without saying a dam word. Beautiful stuff man.
Interstellar is more heartbreaking
i love how we can tell how old you are just from how you write
+
@@user-kx8pu6ys5i Or maybe english is not his first language? Not everyone on YT is from the US or was thaught english growing up.
I really gotta question after this episode how smart TSC actually is. In the math episode, some of what he did can just be justified as him using bigger numbers as better weapons, but in here, he figured out how to accelerate himself using magnets by magnetizing a pole and using the pole to somehow magnetize the rocket, and somehow finish a time loop through infinite timelines and repeats until it somehow let his past self leave
way to spoil it bro
@@tree6835 Why are you reading the comments before you watch the video?
i was about to comend the fact that this video is a perfect time loop. anything that needs to happen has already happened. black holes man they are funky.
I guess he's just a hypersonic learner
Loki style , he created himself to become the god of the Timeline.