India’s prostitution villages | DW Documentary
소스 코드
- 게시일 2023. 06. 18.
- Sex work is a way of life for thousands of women in marginalized communities in certain parts of rural India. For many, it is the only way to make money - also due to the Indian caste system and centuries-old prejudices which make it difficult for the families to escape poverty. But winds of change are blowing.
In certain Indian villages, sex work is, in a sense, inherited. Mothers and grandmothers have already worked in the same trade. In the past, they mostly belonged to ethnic groups that worked mainly as performers. The British colonial power criminalized them, and to this day it is especially difficult for the men of these ethnic groups to find regular jobs. Therefore, the female members of the family are often the breadwinners. They are the ones who take out loans, build houses, make important decisions, which is otherwise rare in India. Our reporters Akanksha Saxena and Neerat Kaur looked around the villages - and found signs of hope: The young generation is trying to leave this sad tradition behind and fight for better education and rights.
#documentary #dwdocumentary #india
______
DW Documentary gives you knowledge beyond the headlines. Watch top documentaries from German broadcasters and international production companies. Meet intriguing people, travel to distant lands, get a look behind the complexities of daily life and build a deeper understanding of current affairs and global events. Subscribe and explore the world around you with DW Documentary.
Subscribe to:
⮞ DW Documentary (English): / dwdocumentary
⮞ DW Documental (Spanish): / dwdocumental
⮞ DW Documentary وثائقية دي دبليو (Arabic): / dwdocarabia
⮞ DW Doku (German): / dwdoku
⮞ DW Documentary हिन्दी (Hindi): / dwdochindi
For more visit: www.dw.com/en/tv/docfilm/s-3610
Follow DW Documentary on Instagram: / dwdocumentary
Follow DW Documental on Facebook: / dwdocumental
We kindly ask viewers to read and stick to the DW netiquette policy on our channel: p.dw.com/p/MF1G
![[나 혼자 산다 선공개] 팜유즈 바프 현장 대공개! 탄탄한 복근으로 모두를 놀라게 한 박나래🙊, MBC 240426 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/C-svV8EhHhU/mqdefault.jpg)
-Trapped by tradition-
Don't call it "TRADITION"
Trapped by systemized oppression
Thats how our culture and civilization is attacked in the veil of Journalism.
@@piplupempoleon4225 there is no religion as Hindu.. Hindu is a word for the people living in India or more appropriately near Indus river
We have a rich religion which does not by any mean have given a solidarity to prostitution
@@shobha377if you have a rich religion that doesn't condone prostitution *'then WTF did we just watched????* Huh?? 😡
they really lovbe showing indian culture as the worst thing in the world..
How it is oppression, they are doing a legal job, and they are earning a lot ... How it is oppressive.
This is absolutely tragic. No one should be forced into this. How do you refuse to stand next to someone but are happy to sleep with them? Hypocrisy is ripe
True, totally agree
use for pleasure only
And !! What about the money they're being paid with...??
For their self and children...??
please don't disrespect oldest religion in world
They are not forced , they are willingly doing so, just because their foremothers were doing so they are doing this, it is an easy money making.
‘To live is the rarest thing in the world. Most people exist, that is all’ - Oscar Wilde
Those who dream to live are ridiculed and shamed, those who talk openly abt living are threatened to shut up, those who actually live are isolated by society or lynched and defamed, many ppl give up in first stage after getting shamed for dreaming to live a dignitious life, and start existing with all burdens of inhuman traditions made by man, due to fear of abandonment.
This moved me. Seeing those young girls in class learning to read and write smiling and looking happy brought tears to my eyes.
I cannot believe in the 21st century we are still talking about a caste system and discrimination that victimizes women and children. Why is the government of India not doing enough? Respect the teacher and the NGOs that are stepping in and making a difference.
This is for poverty nothing to do with casete or etc...dw a hindu hate media typical put caste in every matter
The Indians will just blame the British, as they usually do, for all of their problems and their failures, and under the current Modi regime they've made it hard for NGOs to operate mainly because it shames the Indians and shows the world how little the GOI is actually doing for it's own people!
Caste was banned under Dr Ambedkar's excellent secular constitution in 1950, but as usual with the Indians they just ignore the laws that they don't like, and corruption plays its part too! It is what it is.
Government doing great. But nothing can be perfect in humanly world
I like how you left out men, or suffering of men is perfectly ok and nothing to worry about in 21 century?
(I understand this video about prostitution and men of low casts are suffering at least as badly, but in different industries. But regardless, you worded it strange. Yes, it is unbelievable, that in 21 century there are cast systems that discriminate and victimize men, women and their children which is horrible).
@@bishesh535 you must be Indian. Indians can’t stand being criticized for your system. Automatically compare it to other systems when it’s not about that. Even only fans, as horrible as it is, is still a “choice” for most people. These women in India don’t have a choice and for many it’s the ONLY one. That’s the difference. As she says, no one in her family had jobs and her sister “had” to get married. Why does her sister HAVE TO get married? Because of tradition and culture in this place. Fight for change in your own country and support women. Stop comparing to other countries and to justify the issues in your own. It’s not about other countries it’s about India.
My heart breaks for these girls and their families. Education is the freedom that the rich don't want the poor to find.
@@realShikha885 listen my family are also upper class Indian,for you to look at them and say that they are enjoying it explains exactly what the problem in India is. You and your upper class trash. There is no enjoyment in being poor. Put yourself in her shoe if only for a day. Then tell me how much you would enjoy it.
70k a month is like middle middle class income in India
Yeah, take edu loan, then work to pay back that loan and what u get from that job is hardly pennies. Also you have to include the salary u could get,while u were studyin
@@realShikha885 They are enjoying to be poor ???? Are you real Brahmin girl ?
@@realShikha885 This mindset of yours.....is sick
I am happy the man teached himself some important life skills and is educating the younger generation of women. I hope these families can break out of their poverty and this type of work as fast as possible😭
The whole caste system and the British power in the past is absolutely infuriating! 😠
I agree
For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life. (John 3:16).
Mate who gives af about the brits, they will get Karma soon, just focus on ourselves and stop blaming and improve.
@@pixelite43 For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life. (John 3:16).
This isn't related, AT ALL
But nice pfp good to see some FMA appreciation from India(I assume you're also Indian due to commenting on this video)
multiple Indians I met here in Canada told me 'the Caste system no longer exists in modern India', and they complained about the college reserve spots for 'lower caste'.
True, they are blinded by they're privilege that support for people struggling seems to be favouritism (even though they've clearly won life).
@@garbagecan52 see reservation system is destroying which thereby prevents which could have benefitted more people
It's a lie,caste discrimination is more with the current government in the centre
They're absolutely right. This is happening.
They are right,
Big salute to the NGO who helped him to get a degree. Now he is educating kids in his community. This must be encouraged.
ABB ZO DOCTORS TEACHERS KO SARKAR 25000 MONTHLY SALARY DETI H CONTRACT PR UNKO SOCHNA CHAYIYE KI 70000 MONTHLY TO RACHNA ANKITA BNA LETI H
@@dyalsaraswati391525k sufficient to live modest life in rural Rajasthan and it’s not about who gets to make more money. Even though prostitutes are earning twice than teachers salary, it’s not honest money and comes with risk of catching life threatening disease and generation social stigma.
Bhai, Soch badlo tumhari 🤦🏻♂️
@@weedlover9 PHIR TUMARE QUALIFIES HONE KA KYA FAIDA .4TH FAILS BECOME PM AND CM.AND 50%CRIMINALS MP IN OUR PARLIAMENT. WHY PEOPLE DON'T WORRYING ABOUT BRIDGEBUSHAN AND MODI ETC WHO MORE HARM THE PUBLIC THAN THESE PROSTITUTES. AT LEAST THEY NOT TAKING ANY PEOPLE TAXES MONEY FOR ADANI AND THIER LUXURY.
@@weedlover9 prostitution should be encouraged and be made a respectable profession in india coz the money they earn is better than what daily wage workers get from construction work and other such menial jobs
@@dyalsaraswati3915 DE FOFRRT GHTOOE R HERTNNN FEAMMMKL!!!!
Annand Kumar, Gundu Nager and the other teachers featured in this film are the heroes helping to get children educated and out of poverty.
Narender modi of Adani ambani say Bharat is global leader but Hindu girls like these escape Narender modi attention . Shameless
Education won't necessarily end poverty for you but it will show the right path, it will give you other choices and most importantly it will show you the reality of this life.
Aye 👍.
This is when is empathy transformed to compassion that work for servility
She is enjoying it.
Caste system is like a curse on our Indian society.It's better to get rid of this evil as soon as possible .Our govt is not doing enough for these people & as a society we have failed these
fellow citizens.
Rather than the government, its the people and society itself that should change itself for the better because after all they are the ones upholding it and keeping these discriminative traditions when it has been abolished for so many years already.
@@havensohn3821 totally agree with you👍 .
Specially our youth ,they need to be educated about this issue.
This has nothing to do with the caste system. These people voluntarily chose this profession. Why are they complaining now? Also I feel pity for such incompetent men who don't work and let their women do such work.
@@abc-_-xyzthey are not voluntary choosing this profession not is this a caste system issue, it’s poverty and lack of alternative jobs available.
@@bowofvana4309 You're contradicting yourself. As you said it's because of poverty and lack of employment, so that has nothing to do with the caste system. Poverty is a universal issue. It's not because of the caste system.
I feel more grateful for everything in my life when I see how unfair others have it. I hope they will all have better futures. Their optimism and strength are beautiful. I wish to live my life that way no matter the struggle
Thank you for clearly articulating my thoughts!🙏
I teared watching this... These women are so strong to be taking up this role as a breadwinner. May God protect them and provide for them in a better way.
I'm sure these ladies are very intelligent it would be great if there were community colleges to help them out.😊
I agree God please help them and their family
🤷
Amen
The great and all seeing Sai Baba has a message of hope
Tokoh Spritual Sai Baba Tutup
Usia
Thought provoking documentary, and those women are very brave to share their lived and living experiences. Well done DW 👏🏽
Thanks for watching and for the positive feedback!
not so much bravery, as it is, a non threatening situation, who's going to do anything to them for talking? the mob? They stop caring a long time ago when they got into this business
@@DWDocumentary Could you please make similar videos about the prostitutes of Berlin, Munich and all?
@@DWDocumentaryhow much you pay them to film ?
Prostitution in the West is legalized at least in Germany and it is made by Eastern European women, mostly Romanian, Ukrainian, and from the Balkans. @@SumanBhowmickdarkside
The caste system has always angered me. No one person is better than the next. It’s amazing that a country so rich in religion & spirituality, culture & tradition can even allow this. I suppose this would be a part of their culture that I just don’t understand & find horrific
Actually government don't allow this it's a mindset of people.But after 1950 it's decreasing and their is special reservation is also for them but still long way to go .
There is a racist caste system in the USA 🇺🇸 also since the birth of the nation
Sending a virtual applause for your outstanding work in the documentary world
Awesome that that teacher remained in his community to try and make a difference.
It was strange that there was no boys in that class at the end ,
Haven't you find it bizarre?
Did they were kicked out of class so DW reporters can film group of only girls. I can't fathom how it could be zero boys in a class.
Strange 😢
@@myentertainment55 Maybe they teach boys separately from girls.
@@myentertainment55boys and girls are taught in different classroom
@@myentertainment55based on your other comment, you are trying to create fake issue for men and trying to make boys victim of all situations
@@msunje9862that's horrible 😢
Ironic how mainstream Indian media will never show such on ground stories even in their dreams, yet they will have the audacity to call foreign media companies as "enemies". I wish these people come out of poverty and live a truly content life ❤
Lol, so according to you idi0ts now national media has to show pr0stituti0n news on TV?? Then, it should also report the H@lala abuse done to one community of the ccountry.
Very true indeed. Ware about India are you from. I would like to visit India one day. Looks amazing. Love ❤️ from Scotland 🏴. 🏴🫵🏽❤️🔥👍🏼
They have to work foe their uplifting no one going to feed them free
Godi media 😂😂
They r busy in organising Hindu Muslim debates ...and what and how Seema Haider is doing dear....such A pity and Shame on us Also Who watched them....Somehow n Somewhere 🥹
Salute to those who take practical steps to fix social ills.
Regardless of beliefs, nation, country...
Why the billionaire of india can splurge so much unnecessary $ for their wedding but cant give abit to help their citizens?
Rightly said
You will ask same question yourself when you will be become billionaire
By the way you can ask yourself that I contribute money 💰 as per my capacity or not
Then reply no then keep silent everyone can't contribute bro otherwise no one try to hardwork
Well said👍
Before asking this first tell how much have you contributed.
Because it's their money.
Salute to the man who taught himself and is helping the community. He will transform that community himself and help usher forth an intellectual community.
@@realShikha885 70K?
@@realShikha885 you want to earn some quick bucks honey?
@@thinktank8471never, I may stay jobless but will only Earn through dignity and high esteem
@@realShikha885stop speaking poooop
@@realShikha885 What do you have against someone trying to keep their family alive? What is your problem with these people who have just been thrown into this as a normal way of life? If you weren't born into something like this then try to have some empathy instead of hate.
It’s terrible to have prostitution villages.
But they (DW) won't talk about the issue in Europe because too many of the abusers and racists are immigrant Muslims while the victims are native European girls. Why are they (DW) ignoring the child sexual exploitation cases in the UK, the Netherlands, Germany, Austria, Norway, and Sweden, etc... hmmmm. The data clearly shows that immigrants are vastly overrepresented. This is why they won't investigate the problem. 89% of groomers in the Netherlands have an immigrant background, and 60% are Muslims, while most victims in the Netherlands are Dutch girls, not immigrant girls. The vast majority of victims in the UK are British girls, not immigrant girls.
That's what the Japanese had during WW2, with trafficked women, something they still don't acknowledge today to its Asian victims. "Comfort woman" aka sex slaves in the front lines.
Women from Korea (biggest), Taiwan, China, Philippines, Vietnam etc
But it is fine to have legalised prostitution like in the west 😆 hypocrisy.
It's terrible that the caste system, which was outlawed in 1950, is still allowed to continue. People don't give up their power easily it seems.
lol its normal all over the world there''s always a red light district or a location where sex work is rampant. nothing new it's been there since the beginning of time.
Buen documental, como siempre. 👍
Shocking but somewhat inspiring. Such strong women. Thanks for this documentary and shining a light on this.
lol
It's disappointing how Indian people and the government have failed to recognise the struggles and create systems for seamless integration of historically nomadic tribes of India since independence and even in modern India. They have always been an important part of Indian culture and society, but it's sad to see a day where they have to struggle to feed their families and access education due to their caste (nomadic tribes). Amazing documentary by DW! 🙌🏼
We can’t really blame government. Its these people who have failed. There are many who struggled and uplift their living from zero. These people are lazy and leech who choose to live like this and play victim and sympathy card.
Nomadic has nothing to do with caste system, firstly tribes weren’t part of caste system. They were openly welcomed if they visited any town or village. So I don’t know how we were not integrated before. Yes british pushed them in jungles even further. Read about that, when their land was commercialised and sold to outsiders.
Ask a question to congress goverment
You must be an A class ignorant to think that it has to do with caste or tribe. I'm from a lower SC It's just a primitive taboo that exists in certain parts of India as CULTURE. The government didn't force others or forced them into it. Their elders forced them to be this way. They evolved slowly while the rest didn't. The previous government was pathetic in terms of progress, be it social or economical.
@@asingha94 Do other Higher Caste Indians try to avoid you and touching you?
All these happen because of poverty. And it's more painful knowing that it isn't a natural cause but man-made. 😪🤧😭😭
Hardly so. Name a single rich country without prositutes.
@@samnote2459 Rich country also have very poor people. The root cause is poverty and uncontrolled births. It is expensive to feed 1 mouth.
No animal in the world bar humans, are entrapped by poverty and a life of prostitution. It's really sad.
@@samnote2459 I want my India to be better than them
@@skycloud4802 I will have to visit India soon!
Thank you for sharing this this documentry video.i feel so sorry for those young girls .
Thanks for watching and sharing your thoughts!
Great Documentary, Very well made.
Thanks for watching and for your positive feedback.
My heart goes out to these poor young women
Well "My heart goes" ain't Gonna Help mom....
Are they poor? They have made concrete Houses by buying land and paying off debts like 10 lakh INR. That's not a joke ! 70k 80k INR per month is more than enough, That's the salary of a good software engineer in India 😅😂😂 I am not advocating though.
@@realShikha885are you in the industry?
@@chinavirus841no, but your mum is
@@realShikha885 well from the video it’s very likely your mom, creep🤢
We need more people like that teacher . It's still shocks me how much idk about my own country.
Yeah most Indians live in a delusion that India is a utopia
Beat your wife and kids without discriminating - indian family slogan
Men caused this and then men are also playing hero of this. Crazy
If you think that male teachers are not taking advantage of them
@@Zebwgar Not all men are bad. Generalizing the whole gender is as sexist as the kind of thinking that perpetuate the discrimination of woman in India.
The enemy of patriarchy is not all man. The enemy of patriarchy is men that continue to oppress woman and society as a whole. This teacher is ally of making things better. I hope you understand how bias and stupid your comment is. Close your KRplus and go touch some grass
I enjoyed this documentary; very well done. Thanks for educating me about this issue.
Thanks for watching and taking the time to comment!
As a indian it is not enjoyable,., this it hurts me deeply....
Excellently filmed documentary on a topic that is not brought up enough.
Ending on a positive note is always fulfilling. Thanks to the teachers who are making efforts to change the society. Thank you DW for this exposé
Thanks for watching!
yeah because useless white male suprimassit education helps us all the usa is a good example we have no poor ppl and all know how to file our taxes and manage money and the laws.
@@DWDocumentarydon't show incorrect Map of India
@@globalaffairs6714 bro i am also indian , that map was correct , pok is under pakistan and no one can deny this ,
@@namanffic4412
Pakistan is under our feet and no one can deny this.
I searched about the 'Criminal Tribes Act', and realized how Britishers forced these people into this profession, who were earlier regarded as artists in Indian societies.
They left in 1947, for how long we gonna hide ourselves behind shameful hypocrisy?
Government don't have free cash to give to people either they get job or left alone in this competative world
@@gaurav9664they left with a large breed of brown slaves carrying previous master's burden...
No it was forced by upper caste Hindus specifically Priests
@@baredesigns1 any evidence of it??
Or pushing certain narrative
This is heartbreaking. Praying for these women!
🤷
Untold stories being told by DW... Nice work guys. Sad, this is happening ☹️
Respect to the teacher at the end.
Education = social mobility
Respec wahmen
Education empowers marginalized sections of the society. It is the biggest antidote to oppression. While the oppressor sends their children to convent schools and to foreign universities but at any cost try to prevent Marginalized sections of the society going to convent schools and foreign universities.
I'd say respect to the women who endure this life / try to make the best of it
@@neverrl3379he true nature of men, men cause this issue and then play hero of it
This teacher is a real man!
much appreciation for putting this out but personally i feel it would have been better if you preferred english subtitles to the native language rather than a voice over in english
One of the best channel for postive news
So heartwarming to see those girls being taught and to see they’ve retained their innocence and dreams. Let’s hope and pray they make it and are happy! Hats off to the teacher helping them. That must be very satisfying work!
As an Upper caste Brahmin girl, I am also concerned about these girls. But they are so enjoying it at the same time.
Think as a woman not as which religion you belong to. You never had a choice of being born and bought up in your current religion. It's about respect for women not the religion alone.
@@realShikha885 girl, you are so desperate about noticing you by people, that's why you are making such nonsense comments 😂😂, or you have just a sick mentality.. anyway, by seeing your channel,it is easy to guess your personality
@@realShikha885 Enjoying what?
@@realShikha885you should try it as well
Deep appreciation to those working to break the evil cycle.
As an Upper caste Brahmin girl, I am also concerned about these girls.
Thanks to that upper caste Brahmin teacher Guddu Nagar, these girls are able to get educated. ❤❤
Our pundits told us they are suffering for their past lives sins , why we don’t give a f*ch
@@realShikha885 what’s the point on pressing your upper class brahmin here.. caste system should not even exist on the 1st place to this generation. Clearly you did not read Hindu scripture on the sole purpose of varna system existed last time
@@realShikha885why are you dragging about your caste under everyones comments do u want others to know that u guys also care for these girl??? These ain't gonna help!! Caste shouldn't be even existed in this century... What benefits do u even get by the caste???
Wishing these women peace. May they have the courage to get out of this corruption 🙏💖
God this is so heart-breaking 😭😭
I feel so bad for the girls born into this work. It's ridiculous that there is so much poverty tha you have to make the choice to sell your body or even be in a call center scamming for the money. I'm so glad that there are people working so hard to provide education.
so they changed her name for the show but didn't blur her face?
i don't understand the logic
I know right..must as well state the hourly rate and location
This is so disturbing. My heart breaks for them. How does their government not help them? Praying for the children.
More power to these women🙌 hope their lives change for the better. Thank you for making this very important documentary
The country needs to address children not allowed to be registered if they dont have their fathers name. Thats absolutely absurd!
It is indeed
Its actually not required by law. There are several single women who have adopted children in India, including former Miss Universe Susmita Sen and Bollywood Actress Raveena Tandon. So it's not something necessary. But only something that school made up to perpetuate prejudice, they wouldn't have any need for 'father's' name if the mother is filthy rich
That is actually Arab countries our constitution is fair
no need to mention the name of the father, also no need to mention caste, but people mention caste in school certificate because this is a document for future and there are reservation for higher studies and in getting jobs, and low caste will be eligible even though their rank and marks are low.
This happens only in a few cases.
Great reporting! A friend of mine in Florida is a florist and works occasionally doing weddings for Indian people. You'll be surprised to hear that those wealthy Indians living in the US spend over $100,000 just in flowers. I've heard that some bills go over $250,000. I wonder if those wealthy Indians living here do some volunteer work in India to help the lower casts. That's another topic for DW to explore. Cheers.
Poor are poor because of their mentality, it is not about caste. Today because of govt initiative dalit or untouchable are becoming millionaire and billionaires in india. And these people in videos are certainly not poor. Earning 80000 a month with no skill is a big deal in india
You can’t help all people in the world. Everyone has to try their best to live a good life.
You have a point.
Our rich class are not generous .
Most of them spends a shit load of money for such useless venture.
Majority of our people attitude is to do studyhard , do hardwork , earn money and look after themselves.
Never bother about the poor lives around us
@@bishesh535 kuch bhee!
I am pretty sure that those Indian would not help at all. Infact I would not shocked if they treated others without any respect.
I almost broke out after seeing them smile, such a beautiful one. I hope they keep that in the upcoming years and stay strong.
The strength to smile after all this?
Thank you for sharing their stories
Incredible human beings
worthless
DW is unparallel in dedication, seriousness, and fearlessness.
But they (DW) won't talk about the issue in Europe because too many of the abusers and racists are immigrant Muslims while the victims are native European girls. Why are they (DW) ignoring the child sexual exploitation cases in the UK, the Netherlands, Germany, Austria, Norway, and Sweden, etc... hmmmm. The data clearly shows that immigrants are vastly overrepresented. This is why they won't investigate the problem. 89% of groomers in the Netherlands have an immigrant background, and 60% are Muslims, while most victims in the Netherlands are Dutch girls, not immigrant girls. The vast majority of victims in the UK are British girls, not immigrant girls.
And propaganda 😂
It’s German sponsored so expect European bias
@@LaggardInLove Propaganda when it shows India's problems but when it shows good things about India then it's government's good work
@@LaggardInLoveat least better than BBC even fake left UK media like mirror
I can't believe 😪 I am so sorry for women whose have to sacrifice their body and soul for surviving. It's not fair. Some countries live a totally different life. The world is full of pain for poor people.
Not some countries
In Every country
Poor lives a devastating life
Run to Jesus. He loves you. Jesus is LORD and Savior of the universe.
@@suzannakoizumi8605 stop trying to convert ppl lol..
Jessup was not lord he was a messenger
No prostitution in your country? Be honest.
@TONI__KROOS When you get into a very terrible situation and really need help, just call on Jesus. He will save you. Bury that thought deep in your heart until you are desperate. Remember that Jesus loves you.
My heart goes out to these girls and their families
Whenever you hear poverty and strife...you know the words British colonial will be in the mix.
4:43 such sad eyes.
Poor young woman. My heart goes out to her, being in such horrible circumstances.
@@ExMuslimsOfBangladeshshe literally sacrificed herself and her life to pay off the family debt and support her family as she is the only breadwinner... The second woman does everything it takes for her daughter not having to follow the same path... Yes they might be able to earn what is considered above the average salary in India but for what price... It's obvious listening to the second girl her soul suffers doing this kind of work... They don't do it out of the whim and for selfish reasons... they have been trapped inside the system that was sustained for decades, centuries.. they are its victims and yet heroes.. more than you'll ever be.. so you stop your nonsense comments and get some help
The girl feeling deep responsibilities for her family is really sad😢 somebody help this community
Fascinating film. I have a research project on the history of the Nats mentioned in this film. How might I contact the creator?
This is heartbreaking.
Thanking you for bringing it to the attention of the world. Maybe there can be a change in favor of these women.
Where is that 'Proud Indian🇮🇳 ' comment gang?
Still A proud Indian. India has problems, we were ruled by British stooges who did nothing for us, Congress was a looser mentality Personified, absolute losers.
Let's us see what Bjp can do.
i am a proud INDIAN. every country has problems. who cares if a bunch of people are stupid enough to think that prositution is a way of life? what can any govt do?
hats of to DW Documentary for bring it in limelight
That teacher is amazing teaching English and india at same time 👏👏👏👋👋
Real journalism.
Incredible that it's a man, who teaches the youth in hopes of improving their future.
@Damdumps that comment says a lot more about you than it does this dude, these girls or any of their situations lmao.
@@damdumps3566 talk about projecting.. jeez
@@fr4me.01it is reality, y’all are so delusional if you think these men are not taking advantage of these girls
@@damdumps3566 bruh😂
@@damdumps3566you think all men think like that about young girls? Interesting...
You have used wrong Image of India onmap @5.23 kindly correct it..
good work! thank you for highlighting these women and their challenges.
My heart broken. I can't think straight how these kind of things possible on earth.
Bro u are from bangladesh, and not familiar with such. How is this possible??
I'm in AP. Here people's eat every exotic animals and birds.
Bangladesh has biggest brothel in the 🌎 world
Prostitution is the oldest profession in the world, so it should not surprise you.
How is your heart broken ? Did you forget the prostitution rackets in the form of Daulatdia ? That's the biggest prostitution ring in the world in Bangladesh. 🇧🇩
My heart goes out to these families!!!
I wish I could contribute meaningfully to help these people break the shackles and soar into an open sky!!!
Jdam would do that
@@skankhunt9078Sorry, not understood.
Very powerful documentary 👏
Heart wrenching.
Thanks for covering this up!! 🙌🏽
Pr0paganda of DW.
The main drawbacks of Indian society is caste system,heirarchy, low income(very low earnings in labour works), discrimination and prejudice by law enforcement and justice system.
You also forgot.....corruption!
Patriarchal society is the main problem.
All correct: in other words, abject misery and the complete sham of functioning democracy.
@thezoldics7648 Do you even know the meaning of patriarchy?
@@user-te8lh8kn3m Indian Society was never a patriarchal Society in the Ancient times. Women have Commanded Armies into the Battlefield since Centuries. Even the Rig Vedas mentioned that........We were the most Liberal people about Sexual Orientation after all we wrote the Kamasutra not some American or British
Salute to DW for great documentary, no Indian T.V channel dared to do such great tragegey Indian society
The teacher is so inspiring for me. I am a college teacher too. Sometimes you can change lives. ❤
Next time we complain about having a bad day, let's be grateful that we have it good in comparison to other folks.
This mentality is toxic -
You really need somebody else to be in misery to feel good about your own state. Perfect.
sigh
Western logic
These women are truly inspiring. They're so brave to put themselves into a rather dangerous profession, but a situation brought on by systemic oppression.
These women deserve to never feel the grips of poverty or evil John's coming to use them.
I wish you nothing but love, joy and healing. You are truly powerful 🙏
As an Upper caste Brahmin girl, I am also concerned about these but at the same time they're enjoying it.
@@realShikha885far from enjoying it. Do you enjoy your 9-5 work? They deserve 2lakhs per month instead for being able to sleep with complete strangers. No work is fun,but they are doing something i could never do,so they deserve everything. 100% guaranteed,they dont even like their job,but when it comes to survival,you cant be choosy
@@ruthiLfc😊
Why to have so many children ???
People attract poverty to themselves by not controlling their sexual desires or use contraception, and just pop children•
@@realShikha885 this is a fake account. That's all I can say.
I pray for them. They are real hero's in life. India should bow down to them as a nation.
heartbreaking 💔
As a citizen of alwar rajasthan I praise dw to show ground reality which is ignored by indian media 👍
Rajasthan mai esa hota hai kya....chi...
@@vidhanchandrasahu1185 not only in Rajasthan but all over india
Does this happen in Alwar?
Instead of highlighting such issues Indians keep bragging about how rich their country is.. ground reality is very different.. indian media is obsessed with Seema haider instead of working for the betterment of Indian women..
@@ze9763 food is the only reason...
What they don't tell you, is that their own family members insist they do this....
Yes. The caste system is just the excuse. They want to make easy money, and it keeps on perpetuating the stereotypes of this groups/castes.
When slavery is introduced by an outsider it never lasts, but when your own people betray you it can become a tradition. Same in all parts of the world.
True. My heart would explode if my daughter told me that she will be the breadwinner by prostituting herself.
Wow, this is heartbreaking
This breaks my heart I would love to give one of these ladies a home. It is such a cruel world. 💔
Brilliant documentary! Keep up the excellent work
Thanks for watching and taking the time to comment. Be sure to check out our channel for more content.
@@DWDocumentaryplease show about Afghanistan issue
@@emandas5640 worry about your own country first.
When we look at their lives, we come to the realisation that how much fortunate & at better place we are.
We often complain about our life's circumstances, but when we look at the challenges of people like them, then our personal challenges seem too small. 😊
Yes May Allah make us all ne grateful.and help these people out of this misery.
@@ruxanajewoon517 May Allah bless everyone. 😊
@@explorer.samrat Ameen n u also
As a Brahmin girl I am concerned about these girls, but at the same time they are enjoying it.
@@realShikha885they don't want to work hard....easy money for then
I just came from my second trip to India. Been to New Delhi Jaipur Agra and Mumbai. Experienced the grandiosity of India too. Visited slums ! I found love for India ! I hope for those who are suffering under this tradition be free someday. We are all equal in the eyes of God.
Many countries can be with any race but I found how special India is. No one can ever be Indian enough except Indians that's how special and beautiful they are.
Thank you for making this documentary. If I can, I'll find a way to help these women.
Thanks for watching !
I hope these women and men are able to overcome their current challenges. Education will open new doors, and I really hope these young women can have a brighter and better future.
You're dreaming.
Wow!! This is eye opening! Poverty affects all poor people in the same way, unfortunately 😕 the caste system needs to be broken. Thank Goodness for the Teacher‼️
Caste system stands broken at legal level.
Its practised sporadically by groups otherwise
@@offred6013 legally untouchability is outlawed but cast system is still alive and is practiced at every walk of life. Just see the priests of templs they are all exclusively Brahmins. Look at all the lowly jobs such as street sweepers, manual scavengers all are given to the Dalits. caste system enforces strict endogamy. Honour killing of couples who dare to marry outside from from their caste is still not uncommon. Caste system is against love.
The people who deny that cast system doesn't exist or it is practiced sporadically come from the oppressor caste who enjoy the privilegeds of the Caste system
They are not prostitutes because of their caste ,
They are lower caste because of their prostitution work
Being an Indian, I am not only horrified but also stigmatised and feeling sorrow... after getting freedom of 75 + years .. we could not overcome these curse ...... but I will keep working to support my nation........
👍
My heart just melted..😢
Caste system now also practices in today’s society.
Same people talk about caste based reservation!
Full marks to DW Reporters and Team for a sensitive reporting & bringing this issue to the forefront. I hope that district administration wakes up from the slumber and takes some or many small steps for upliftment.
Lol, thanking DW. Their country themselves legalised pr0stituti0n. And you appreciating them for making documentary on India. They haven't even shown the correct map of India.
Found this documentary.
Helped me a lot understanding my India.
Please leave links where we can donate to these organizations that help the people by providing education
Hey, don't donate anywhere without knowing reality
Great docu, thank so much for sharing...caste & democracy..? Freedom & rights ..? ✌️
I'm glad this is getting coverage
This ‘coverage’ is part of Western liberal propaganda
I think you should also make a documentary on caste system, and how people downplay it even after increased discrimination
Perhaps that's the privileged sections. The same goes with discrimination against blacks in the US. Many don't prefer to acknowledge it as if it has never existed(exists)
Talk about reservati0n caste category system.
*Not increased. But decreased now a lot. Still there. But going in the correct direction
@@priyajoseph7108 There's more racism coming from supremacist African-American and their culture, than from white people.
I'm not denying the history, you should just open your eyes fairly and realize how racist people have become against white people in America, like, there's no denying it, they can openly be racist about white people in their tv shows and their politicians show this exact behavior as well, meanwhile preaching that they are the liberators.
Unless of course you have been thought by black supremacists that black people can't be racist.
If that's the case, there's no reason left to elaborate any further.
First you lower caste people should stop voting in the name of caste, it will end eventually.
The teacher is so inspirational. Frustrated by seeing the women around him sell their bodies, he teaches himself to read and write, and is now responsible for saving other families from this fate. Legend.
Amazing documentary! I hope all the girls get educated and break out of the shackles of the caste hierarchy one day.
Education is crucial to break this circle.. Great work by teacher